Camille SAINT-SAËNS (1835-1921) Symphony No. 3 in C minor, op.78 Organ (1886) [36:50];
Symphony in A major (c.1859) [26:30] Le rouet d’Omphale, op.31 (1871) [8:19]
Carl Adam Landström (organ)
Malmö Symphony Orchestra/Marc Soustrot
rec. 2013, Malmö Concert Hall, Malmö, Sweden NAXOS 8.573139 [71:40]
I’ve not come across the early A major symphony since
it appeared many years ago on a long lost LP recorded by Martinon.
I could hardly remember a single note of it when I played this CD. That
probably says it all. However, this is the work of a 15 year old so
it would be churlish to get sniffy about it. The symphony is still a
remarkable effort from one so young. Essentially a homage to Mozart
it’s a tuneful and very skilful piece of craftsmanship. In the
first movement there are references along the way to the four note motif
from the last movement of the Jupiter symphony. This same motif
also occurs in the Third Symphony — 6:15 in the third section
prior to the great organ entry — so it seems that Mozart remained
an important composer in the life of Saint-Saëns even during his mature
period. There are hints of Schubert and Mendelssohn in the two central
movements followed by a lively finale in the style of Mozart. It’s
all very agreeable. The performance is excellent and has been captured
in warm, close sound.
Turning now to the much recorded Organ Symphony I’m
afraid we enter a market that already has several fine versions and
despite this Naxos offering being good, unfortunately good simply isn’t
good enough when up against some stellar opposition. There’s absolutely
nothing wrong with the standard of orchestral execution but we need
more than orchestral excellence to grab the attention. Turning to specifics
the Poco adagio is unbelievably slow and the great tune loses
its shape despite the best efforts of the splendid orchestra. The Allegro
moderato has plenty of thrust to it but where are the timps? They
are swamped and backward – maybe soft sticks are the problem.
This lack of bite makes the performance as a whole sound lethargic.
The final blow for many will be the famous organ entry. It’s a
real damp squibb and doesn’t have the thrilling, all engulfing
effect you experience from Barenboim (DGG) or Dutoit (Decca) or for
that matter on the old Mercury version under Paray (my favourite). The
organ should dominate but what we have here is a rather feeble sounding
instrument that merely blends in with the rest of the orchestra. Reading
the booklet notes the organ is in fact a console using virtual pipe
organ software with digital sampling taken from an organ in Caen, France.
I would have preferred a recording venue with a decent, regular church
organ at hand. Whereas the A major symphony with its traditional classical
forces sounds excellent the Organ symphony recording lacks
amplitude and sparkle. It’s smooth, plush and warm but it just
isn’t particularly exciting. The fast passages are lacking bite.
Le rouet d’Omphale completes the programme and very
good it is too. The scampering spinning theme is delicately palyed
and the Hercules section is dark and ominous. The ending is reminiscent
of Pohjola’s Daughter with the music slowly disappearing
and fading away into a puff of smoke. Maybe this CD will sell despite
the Organ Symphony. Most readers will have the old warhorse
in their collections anyway. The playing throughout, despite the interpretive
issues I have highlighted in the Organ symphony, is always
good. This disc is really only recommendable for the “fillers”.
That may good enough to tempt people at the price.
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger