Classical Editor Rob Barnett Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Stan Metzger MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
us financially by purchasing this disc from
Benjamin BRITTEN (1913-1976) War Requiem [80:05]
Anna Netrebko (soprano); Ian Bostridge (tenor); Thomas Hampson (baritone)
Coro e Voci Bianche dell'Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, Roma/Ciro Visco
Orchestra dell'Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, Roma/Sir Antonio Pappano
rec. 25-26, 28-29 June 2013, Sala Santa Cecilia, Auditorium Parco della Musica, Rome, Italy
Latin and English texts with English translation. WARNER CLASSICS 6154482 [80:05]
Looking back over 2013, the centenary of Britten’s birth, I
am amazed and encouraged by the number of reissues and new recordings
of the composer’s music that have hit the marketplace. Three
new recordings of the War Requiem have been reviewed here on
MusicWeb International. These have been supplemented by two historic
recordings, one by Karel Ancerl, the Czech première from 1966(SupraphonSU
4135-2), and the first performance from Coventry Cathedral on 30 May
1962 with Britten/Meredith Davies (Testament SBT 1490). Furthermore,
my interest in this work was rekindled in November 2013, when I attended
a performance of the War Requiem at the Royal Albert Hall with
the BBC Symphony Orchestra and Chorus conducted by Semyon Bychkov.
This was the first time I’d heard it live and it was for me
one of the most memorable and moving events in my entire concert-going
It was on 14 November 1940 that the 14th Century Church
of St. Michael’s, Coventry was bombed by the German Luftwaffe.
It had only been elevated to cathedral status, on the creation of
the Coventry Diocese, in 1918. Eventually, plans were drawn up to
build a new cathedral at right angles to the ruins of the old one.
In October 1958, some three years before the estimated completion
date, the Coventry Cathedral Festival Committee approached Britten
to compose something fitting for the consecration. He was delighted
with the request and grateful to be given carte blanche to
compose anything he wished. He had for many years cherished a desire
to write a large-scale choral piece ‘à la Elgar’,
and several subjects had stirred his imagination - the tragedy of
Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and the 1948 assassination of Gandhi. These
ideas remained pipe-dreams. Now, an opportunity arose in which he
could rise to the challenge.
His decision was to compose a setting of the traditional Latin Requiem
Mass, interspersed with poems by Wilfred Owen, who was killed during
the First World War, sadly just one week before the Armistice in 1918.
True to form, and in keeping with his habit of working to tight deadlines,
Britten only started work on the Requiem in 1961. It was completed
in January 1962, barely four months before the first performance.
Thinking back to the concert last November, I truly believe this is
a work that needs to be experienced in a live performance setting
to be fully appreciated. One then gets some conception of the spatial
separation between the different groups involved. Britten composed
the work for a main orchestra, accompanying the soprano soloist and
mixed chorus in the Latin mass parts. A chamber orchestra of twelve
instrumentalists accompany the tenor and baritone soloists in the
Wilfred Owen settings. A boys choir with its own conductor, and supported
with a chamber organ is positioned distant from the main body of performers.
This spatial separation has to be apparent and audible for any recording
of this work to be successful.
The present recording was made in June 2013 in the Sala Santa Cecilia,
Auditorium Parco della Musica, Rome. Two months later, Pappano and
his forces performed the work at the Salzburg Festival to great critical
acclaim. Pappano has been musical director of the Orchestra dell'Accademia
Nazionale di Santa Cecilia since 2005. For this recording he chose
three distinguished soloists, the Russian soprano Anna Netrebko, the
American baritone Thomas Hampson and the English tenor Ian Bostridge.
Being no stranger to this work, and having many performances under
his belt, Bostridge is a very apt choice; he has this work in his
All three soloists are excellent. Anna Netrebko, like Galina Vishnevskaya,
harks back to Britten’s choice of a Russian soprano in the first
recording. With such power and force in her delivery, she projects
well. Hampson shows great sensitivity in shaping his part and imbuing
it with a formidable range of tonal colour. However, it is Ian Bostridge’s
contribution which stands out for me. I much prefer him to Peter Pears
in the Britten recording. Clarity of diction, beauty of tone, phrasing
and dynamic control all add up to a performance which is both consummate
The success of this recording seems to hinge on the fact that Pappano
brings all his experience and talent to the fore. Excelling in opera,
he coaxes the soloists, choir and orchestra to deliver a strongly
argued performance. The warmth of the Italians adds to the success
of the mix. The opening Requiem Aeternam beginsvery
quietly. Pappano gradually builds up the dynamic level and tension,
and there is great drama throughout. The orchestral sound is vivid
and immediate. What is evident is the conductor’s scrupulous
attention to detail and preparation.
The brass section in the Dies irae ring out with burnished
tone, and the sheer visceral energy at Tuba mirum (The trumpet,
scattering a wondrous sound) is breathtakingly shattering. The instrumentalists
that make up the chamber orchestra are terrific, and the contrast
between them and the full orchestra is palpable. The adult choir is
first class, with clarity of diction always apparent.
The choristers are excellently placed and one senses spatial separation
from the main groups. They have that distant, other-worldly and ethereal
quality. However, Britten specifically asks for boys’ voices,
favouring that particular timbre. Though the booklet does not specify
the make-up of the voices the chorister group sounds mixed to me.
from German television of Andris Nelsons conducting a performance
with the CBSO in Coventry Cathedral 2012 uses a girls’ choir,
and it is clearly not ideal. In Helmuth Rilling’s recording,
the choristers lack the distant perspective completely and sound unimaginative
and expressionless. In fact, this entire performance generally leaves
me cold (Hänssler
Classic CD 98.507).
All told, Pappano’s is an impressive achievement, and one I
will return to often. Unfortunately, I have not had the opportunity
to listen to the McCreesh (Signum
SIGCD340) and Jansons (S&H
review of concert; CD on BR
Klassik 900120) recordings, that were also released in 2013.
The booklet notes set the context and background. Texts and translations
are provided. At 80 minutes, the work is accommodated on a single
CD, and this is an advantage. This version will provide an excellent
alternative to the composer’s own on Decca.