Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
review may be sent to:
76 Lushes Road
Essex IG10 3QB
Ph. 020 8418 0616
financially by purchasing this disc from
Leonardo VINCI(1696? – 1730) Artaserse (1730)
Philippe Jaroussky (counter-tenor) – Artaserse; Max Emanuel Cenic (counter-tenor)
– Mandane; Daniel Behle (tenor) – Artabano; Franco Fagioli (counter-tenor)
– Arbace; Valer Barna-Sabadus (counter-tenor) – Semira; Yuriy Mynenko
(counter-tenor) – Megabise
Coro della Radiotelevisione svizzera, Lugano
Concerto Köln/Diego Fasolis
rec. Deutschlandfunk Kammermusiksaal, Köln, 21-28 September 2011
Libretto with English, French and German translations enclosed VIRGIN CLASSICS 6028692 [3 CDs: 67:26 + 65:46 + 54:36]
Leonardo Vinci should not be confused with the Renaissance polymath Leonardo
da Vinci (1452 – 1519). The latter, however, besides all his other skills,
was also an able musician who allegedly could play any stringed instrument.
He is said to have composed music as well but nothing of this has survived.
His nearly namesake on the other hand was an important musician, highly
regarded during his lifetime and long after his demise – being poisoned
with a cup of chocolate since, rumour has it, he had an affair with a
high-born Roman lady. Artaserse was his last opera and it had
a short run in February 1730 due to the death of Pope Benedict XIII, after
which all theatres in the Papal States were closed. Vinci’s opera was
revived over and over again through the whole of Europe and is in the
notes for this issue declared ‘the most celebrated Italian opera’.
The libretto is by Metastasio and Artaserse is the Persian king Artaxerxes
I, son of Xerxes I (Serse). He ruled from 465 BC to 424 BC. The story
is, as so often in baroque operas, rather complicated: Mandane, sister
of Artaserse, is in love with Arbace, son of King Serse’s general Artabano.
Serse is against this love and banishes Arbace. When the two lovers secretly
meet in the castle garden Artabano appears, carrying a bloody sword. He
admits to Arbace that he has killed Serse for his ill treatment of Arbace
and also because he wants Arbace to become king. Then the two exchange
swords. Now Artaserse arrives and Artabano tells him about the murder
and accuses Dario, Artaserse’s older brother, of the deed. Artaserse orders
Artabano to kill Dario. A little later Artaserse admits that he loves
Semira, Arbace’s sister.
The murder of Dario is announced and Megabise, a general who supports
Artabano and also is in love with Semira, brings in Arbace, in chains,
and announces that a bloody sword had been found among Arbace’s possessions.
Arbace is condemned to death but Artaserse doubts that he is guilty and
releases him so he can get away.
In the temple Artaserse swears that he will uphold law and order in his
kingdom. To affirm this he is about to drink from a sacred goblet, not
knowing that Artabano has poisoned the drink. Before he has time to drink
Megabise and his soldiers approach the castle. The attack is averted when
Arbace kills Megabise. Now Artaserse hands the goblet to Arbace so he
can prove his innocence by drinking from it. In this situation Artabano,
to save the life of his son, admits that he has poisoned the drink and
also that he murdered Serse. Artabano is captured and lead away, but Artaserse,
in love with Semira, condemns him, not to death but to exile. In the concluding
chorus everybody hails Artaserse: Justice becomes beautiful when accompanied
by mercy. Happy end to this bloody story!
At this time women were not allowed to appear on stage so all the roles,
male as well as female, were sung by castrati. This means that there are
five counter-tenors and one tenor (Artabano) appearing on this recording.
Their voices are, however, very individual and pretty soon one learns
the specific timbre of each of them … and what voices! Philippe Jaroussky
has had a comet-like career and though still only 35 he has a recording
career of more than thirteen years behind him. He is a superb singer,
brilliant, powerful, technically perfect and so beautiful of tone. Go
to the opening of CD 2 and listen to the aria Rendimi il caro amico
(tr. 2). Irresistible … but then so are the rest of the cast. Max Emanuel
Cencic’s more lyrical voice is extremely well suited to Mandane’s role
but he is just as apt in more dramatic utterances. I was very enthusiastic
about Franco Fagioli when I heard him as Giulio Cesare in Helsinki a year
ago and have longed to hear him again. His Arbace is tremendous with breathtaking
virtuosity. The long aria that concludes act I, Vo solcando un mar
crudele (CD 1 tr. 27) should become a baroque hit and I can’t imagine
it better sung. Valer Barna-Sabadus as Semira has some of the most beautiful
arias and Bramar di perdere (CD 1 tr. 15) is another hit. Yuriy
Mynenko has thrillingly brilliant top notes, making the general Megabise’s
arias suitably warlike. In Sogna il guerrier le schiere (CD 1
tr.13) he, the warrior, dreams of troops, in the same way a hunter dreams
of woods and the fisherman dreams of nets and hooks.
The odd man out is Daniel Behle as Artabano. It’s almost five years since
I first heard him, as the Prince in La cenerentola in Stockholm.
He then seemed ideal for such lyrical roles with fluent technique and
ease of delivery. I also noted that he had ‘enough heft to make his top
notes ring out’. Since then I have heard him as a recording artist, not
least as a superb Lieder singer. Here he surprises with a tone that is
powerful and baritonal, almost like hearing Placido Domingo’s Otello when
he was at the height of his powers. It seems that Behle is ready for the
lirico-spinto repertoire. The real highlight is, to my mind,
the da capo-aria in act III when he fears that his son is dead, Figlio
se piů non vivi (CD 3 tr. 9), where the outer sections are among
the most moving moments in any baroque opera.
Artaserse is brimful with lovely music, from overture to the
invigorating concluding chorus. Concerto Köln is certainly one of the
best orchestras in this genre and Diego Fasolis draws excellent playing
from them. I know people who avoid baroque operas since they can’t stand
the interminable secco recitatives. They look very long here too, when
one sees the libretto, but they fizz along at brisk speeds and they are,
just like Handel’s, expressive and individual.
The more than three-hour-long work was over in almost no time and then
it was tempting to play it all over again. With excellent sound, splendid
notes and a libretto in four languages to add to all the excellent singing
and playing this is one of the best baroque opera recordings I have heard.
Don’t miss it!