Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Symphony No. 6 (1968) [20:33] Lumen in Christo (1974)* [21:33]
Symphony No. 7, The Sea (1977)* [18:13]
1. Lo, the unbounded sea [7:44]
2. The untold want [4:19]
3. Joy, shipmate, joy! [6:10]
Seattle Symphony/Gerard Schwarz
rec. 15-16 October 1989 (No. 6), 6-7 June 1994 (Lumen in
Christo), 18-19 May 1992 (No. 7), Seattle Opera House, Seattle,
Sung texts from the Naxos website.
NAXOS AMERICAN CLASSICS 8.559704 [60:19]
So Gerard Schwarz’s Hanson cycle - first released on Delos
- moves towards its conclusion; appropriately enough this volume
ends with the composer’s own farewell to the symphony,
the Whitman-inspired Seventh. Before that we have the Sixth
- commissioned by the New York Philharmonic to celebrate their
185th season - and the choral Lumen in Christo, written
for the 50th anniversary of Nazareth College in Rochester, NY.
Far from being mere duty pieces all three display the deceptively
simple, open-hearted qualities that suffuse so much of Hanson’s
work; moreover, his Romantic spirit is undiminished, despite
the changed and changing musical milieux of the 1960s
It’s all too easy to sound apologetic when writing about
these pieces, but one just has to hear the Sixth - in six continuous
movements - to be made aware of a strong and individual voice;
from its seminal woodwind theme the symphony is articulated
with an economy of style that’s never short on drama.
The first big tutti - goodness, what a formidable bass drum
- the dry rattle of side drums and the vaunting brass are the
hard outer shell, the sustained, string-led lyricism the soft
kernel. Schwarz certainly points up the latter most beautifully;
and while the long, singing lines of the third movement are
ravishing, the more trenchant moments are just as gripping.
What a glorious, elegantly proportioned piece this is, the steady
beat of the last two movements - cue that big bass drum - underpinning
music of surprising impact and energy. And, as I’ve found
with the other discs in this series, the orchestra are very
well recorded. They’re joined in the remaining works by
the Seattle Chorale, a choir that impressed me greatly in The
Lament for Beowulf (review).
The women certainly don’t disappoint in the light-filled
loveliness of Lumen in Christo, whose opening verses
from Genesis point to Haydn as a source of inspiration.
Whereas The Creation is a series of declamatory/descriptive
passages interspersed with solos, Hanson’s score is a
blend of bold but nicely scaled orchestral statements - just
listen to the imposing start - and fine, cloistered singing.
There’s a hint of Orffian ostinati as well - tastefully
done - and a discreet peal of bells; as for the singing, it’s
firmly focused and resolute in its reach. The end of the first
section is a good example of Hanson’s talent for spinning
the most radiant and memorable tunes from the simplest flax.
Lumen in Christo is full of such epiphanies, with perhaps
a genuflection towards Bruckner in the chorale-like passages
of the second part.
The concluding ‘Lux aeterna’ is intensely moving
- how like beams of rubied light in a serene, votive space -
and it makes a perfect prelude to the Seventh Symphony. Comparisons
with Vaughan Williams’ Sea Symphony are unavoidable
- including the use of lines from Whitman’s Leaves
of Grass - but Hanson’s version is much more austere.
Grand gestures are kept to a minimum, and dynamics are more
finely shaded. As so often with this composer there’s
an abiding sense of a very private persona - like Britten’s,
perhaps - given to writing of simplicity, strength and quiet
Another rewarding addition to this fine cycle, celebrated as
much for the composer’s gentle spirit as for Schwarz’s
inspired direction. The original Delos engineers also deserve
praise for their superb recording, which adds so much to one’s
enjoyment of these engaging scores.
Works of distinction and delight, winningly played.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.