Franz SCHUBERT (1797-1828)
Fantasie in C Major, D. 934 [22:58]
Sonata in A Major, D. 574 [21:25]
Rondo Brilliant in b minor [13:11]
Isabelle Faust (violin)
Alexander Melnikov (piano)
rec. September 2004, Teldex Studio, Berlin HARMONIA MUNDI HMC
For a composer
as prolific as Schubert, it is strange that his output of works
for violin and piano is so small: six works in all. This is
all the more odd given that his brother Ferdinand was a gifted
violinist. The old excuse that Schubert was intimidated at
every turn by the still very much living Beethoven might hold
some water. However, given the quality of the few solo violin
works that he did leave us, we canít help but be a bit saddened
by what might have been.
I confess that
I was not terribly familiar with this repertoire until I sat
down to listen to this disc. What a pleasant surprise it was!
The C Major Fantasie is a through-composed work, but it has
four distinct sections. It opens with a slow introduction,
moves into a serious quasi-exposition in the minor mode, continues
with a delightful set of variations and closes with a rollicking
and joyous finale. It is as tuneful as one could expect from
the composer of so many fine songs, and its serene mood and
youthful exuberance are truly captivating.
Faust and Melnikov
are a sensitive team, at one with the music and with each other.
Faust plays with a warm tone, not overwrought with vibrato,
and yet clean and sinuous. Melnikovís piano is at once clear
and mellow. There is a good deal of reverberation in the recording,
and given that it was made in a studio and not a concert venue,
one cannot help but wonder if this is artificial. Regardless,
it is not at all off-putting, and the ambience is most welcoming
The A Major Sonata,
also known as the Grand Duo is far more formal in structure
than the Fantasie. Cast in four movements it is a serious work
in spite of its brimming tunefulness. It does not belie Schubertís
oft-found difficulty with larger forms. At just over twenty
minutes, it is compact without being abrupt and contains music
as fine as found anywhere else in the literature. Of particular
merit are the joyful scherzo and the lovely third movement
marked andantino. There is no shortage of virtuosity
in the writing, but it is solely at the service of the music,
never to be trotted out in ostentatious display. Again, the
performances are taut, and our teamís ability to bring off
a slow movement with sincerity but with out self-indulgence
is welcome indeed.
The recital closes
with the Rondo Brilliant in b minor, which is a horse of a
different color indeed. Far more dramatic and showy than the
other works, this stormy little work stands up on its hind
legs and demands attention.† It is an exhilarating ending to
a lovely recital.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.