Classical Editor Rob Barnett Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Stan Metzger MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
George FridericHANDEL (1685-1759)
Chaconne in G Major, HWV 435 (by 1733) [7:09]
Suite in D Minor, HWV 436 (by 1733) [12:51]
Suite in E Minor, HWV 438 (by 1733) [7:39]
Suite in B Flat Major, HWV 434 (by 1733) [7:53]
Suite in G Major, HWV 441 (by 1733) [15:22] Trevor
Pinnock (harpsichord) ARCHIV 410
Trevor Pinnock’s reputation as one of the world’s greatest
harpsichordists was done no harm when this CD was originally
released nearly 25 years ago. It’s another in the Arkiv series
in which you get a record company-authorised CD-R at a cheaper
than usual price, a reproduction of the original booklet’s
front and back, but not the original liner-notes.
There are four contrasting Suites from one of the high
Baroque’s ablest hands: Handel was in his element with the
keyboard suite; these are clearly examples of a musical style
and genre which he loved and in which he had so much to communicate.
As one might expect, each comprises from three to half a
dozen or so dance movements. None is much longer than a quarter
of an hour in total. Yet each has something different to
recommend it; almost every movement makes you want to return
to it immediately in order to squeeze more from it each time
There are gentle moments: the courante of the G Major (HWV
441 – actually from a set published earlier than the others
here) is a lesson in unselfconscious peace and stasis. And
there are furious moments: listen to the animated but taut
opening of the B Flat Major (HWV 434) Prelude… it could be
Bach! Pinnock, on the other hand, doesn’t break sweat. Amazing
playing. The Sonata that follows, is just as hardy. The Air
with Variations that conclude the Suite is redolent of
the ‘Harmonious Blacksmith’ (or the Air and Variations as
well, from HWV 430)… also measured, insistent yet melodious.
And again, this is propelled with style and lightness of
touch by Pinnock.
Other recordings of this repertoire have brought
more modern – and perhaps more personal, individual - interpretations:
Sophie Yates’ Chandos Chaconne series
(644, 669, 688) has much to recommend it, but doesn’t really
bring the music more alive than Pinnock does here.
The instrument that Pinnock plays was over a hundred years
old when Handel wrote this music… a Ruckers of 1612 – and
very fine and stately it sounds too. It’s likely to be the
kind of harpsichord which found greatest favour with Handel
himself. Rounded and warm, yet precise and reverberant, it’s
a delight to hear.
So this is something of a sampler – certainly not the only
way to group these pleasant pieces. But it’s a programme
that works and which will give repeated and prolongued pleasure:
Pinnock’s playing is well up to its usually high standard.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.