Antonín DVOŘÁK (1841-1904) Requiem Op.89 B165 (1890)
Gabriela Beňačková (soprano)
Ida Kirilová (alto)
Josef Protscka (tenor)
Luděk Vele (bass)
Prague Philharmonic Chorus
Czech Philharmonic Orchestra/Václav Neumann
rec. St. Vitus Cathedral, Prague, 1988
Sound Format; PCM stereo: languages; GB, D, F, SP: Subtitles; GB, D, F, SP: picture
Format; 4:3: Region Code; 0 (worldwide): DVD 9 NTSC ARTHAUS
102 063 [97:00]
applause in church of course. So when Václav Neumann steps
up to the rostrum in St Vitus Cathedral he bows to the audience,
the totality of which we never see, with a pleasant but distant
look. The camera angles are initially disconcerting. Close,
tight shots of the principal cellist’s cello, shots of the
drumsticks on the drumhead, a close shot of a small section
of the sopranos. It makes for a rather claustrophobic start
to the Requiem aeternam. After a while it dawned on
me that the director was establishing the polyphonic heartland
of the work and setting it in immediate motion; the ear,
as it were, directed by the eye. These layers of visual polyphony,
once established, don’t recur to anything like the same extent
and the point, once made, is a good one. The other camera
angles are in the main gimmick-free, apart from a camera
shot from the side, and slightly to the back of the soloists,
which proved a little queasy.
The soloists are a homogeneous though not entirely convincing unit. Beňačková is
the pick of the quartet, powerful, imperious but also suitably yielding and good
in ensembles. Her Slovak colleague Ida Kirilová makes for a rather florid partner.
Her singing in the Tuba mirum is intensely dramatic but will be, for some,
compromised by a big vibrato and an overtly operatic sense of projection. Josef
Protscka, sporting his vaguely nineteenth century facial topiary, is an involving
and attractive tenor. His bass colleague Luděk Vele is also noted as a bass-baritone
and it’s the lighter voice that best describes him I feel. Though he has a solid
downward extension he’s heard at his best in the upper reaches of the baritone
register, where things sit comfortably for him.
Neumann directs with impressive and only occasionally impassive control. He sculpts
the fugal passages with incision, though the long delay and decay of the cathedral
acoustic sometimes blunts his better intentions. The Offertorium is a
particularly telling example of his choral control. The orchestra plays well;
there are numerous shots of the winds and rightly so given their important commentaries.
This visual documentation of Neumann’s Requiem is only very generally dated to
1988 but is nevertheless a valuable one.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.