2020 54,416 reviews and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here You can also use this FreeFind              International mailing

Searching Musicweb Monthly index Recordings of the Year Label index Masterwork index Series index Search engines Review Archive Classical Downloads Jazz Concerts Nostalgia Books Film music Resources Composer pages Tony Duggan's Mahler survey National discographies Mark Morris's Guide to Twentieth Century Composers Ralph Moore's Surveys Online books Piano Trio Survey Cello Concerto Project Pot Pourri - Early MusicWeb Gerard Hoffnung Arthur Butterworth's columns Philip Scowcroft's British light music collection Interviews Programme notes MusicWeb Listening Studio Other material Articles Seen & Heard Message Board Announcements About Musicweb About Musicweb Contact Musicweb Contributors What they say about us Visitor stats Site Map

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn

BUY NOW  AmazonUK   AmazonUS

CD Premieres: Leopold Stokowski and the Philadelphia Orchestra (all except symphonies arr. Stokowski, or as noted) Antonio VIVALDI (1675-1741) Concerto Grosso Op. 11 No. 3 [12.43] rec. 12 November 1934 Giovanni de PALESTRINA (c.1525-1594) Adoramus Te [3.12] rec. 12 November 1934 Girolamo FRESCOBALDI (1583-1643) Gagliarda [3.25] rec. 22 October 1934 Jean-Bapriste LULLY (1632-1687) Le Triomphe de l’Amour (1681): Nocturne [4.48]; Alceste (1674): Prelude [1.25]; Thésée (1675): March [1.00] rec. 30 April 1930 William BYRD (1543-1623) Pavane and Gigue [4.40] rec. 19 April 1937 George Frideric HANDEL (1685-1759) Chandos Anthem No. 2 (1717): Overture [6.25] rec. 10 December 1935 Messiah (1744): Pastorale Symphony [4.17] rec. 15 March 1930 Water Music: Suite (arr. Harty, arr. Stokowski) [16.36] rec. 12 November 1934 Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750) Toccata and Fugue in d, BWV 565 (1708) [9.28] rec. 26 November 1934 Ich ruf’ zu dir, Herr Jesu Christ, BWV 639 () [4.17] St. John Passion, BWV 245 (1725): Es ist vollbracht [8.01] Ein Feste Burg, BWV 80: Chorale [1.47] Passacaglia and Fugue in c, BWV 582 [14.19] rec. 1 May 1929 Luigi BOCCHERINI (1743-1805) String Quartet, Op. 13 No. 5: Minuet [2.37] rec. 4 May 1929 Franz Joseph HAYDN attr. (1732-1809) String Quartet Op. 3 No. 5 (1777): andante cantabile [3.31] rec. 4 May 1929 Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827) Symphony No. 5 in c, Op 67 (1808) [31.47] rec. 15 July 1931 Cesar FRANCK (1822-1890) Symphony in d, Op (1888) [39.41] {prefaced by spoken outline of themes, accompanied by Artur Rodzinsky at the piano [2.56]} rec. 11 October 1927 Claude DEBUSSY (1862-1918) Nocturnes (1899): Nuages [9.06] rec. 2 May 1929 Nocturnes (1899): Fêtes [5.54] rec. 11 October 1927 Suite Bergamasque (1905): Clair de lune [5.14] rec. 5 April 1937 Prélude à l’Après-Midi d’un Faun (1894) [10.30] rec. 8 December 1940 Carl Maria von WEBER (1786-1826) Invitation to the Dance (1819/61) (orch. Berlioz, arr. Stokowski) [8.01] rec. 19 April 1937 Johannes BRAHMS (1831-1897) Symphony No. 4 in e, Op. 98 (1885) [38.42] rec. 18 April 1934 except side 1 only, 4 March 1933. Hungarian Dance No. 1 (1873) [3.25] rec. 17 March 1934 Johann STRAUSS II (1825-1899) On the Beautiful Blue Danube (1867) [4.28] Tales from the Vienna Woods (1868) [4.48] rec. 9 April 1939 Richard STRAUSS (1864-1949) Salome (1905): Dance of the Seven Veils [9.41] rec. 1 May 1929 John Philip SOUSA (1854-1932) El Capitan (1896) [2.16] Stars and Stripes Forever (1896) [3.22] rec. 27 September 1929 Philadelphia Orchestra/Leopold Stokowski rec. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and Camden, New Jersey, USA, 1926-37 Notes in English, photos of conductor, matrix numbers. MUSIC AND ARTS PRODUCTIONS OF AMERICA CD1173 [58.42 + 75.54 + 73.27 + 74.52]

Comparison recordings: Leopold Stokovsky [sic] The Great Philadelphia Wagner Recordings [ADD] Andromeda ANDRCD 5030 These transfers by Mark Obert-Thorn are good but not perfect and suffer in comparison with the spectacularly good anonymous transfers presented on the noted recent Andromeda release. We have subtle but audible hiss/crackle and at least five occasions where a thump or click could have been removed but wasn’t. Apart from these slight noises, the transfers are clear, wide range, and quite musical. I am aware that some persons prefer a slightly ragged sound to old recordings for reasons of nostalgia, and no-one ought to try to argue with taste. The Vivaldi is presented here in the full orchestra version commonly encountered at the time of the recording; for Stokowski’s later recording in stereo he used a more up-to-date version using smaller forces. Lully ballet excerpts were also familiar in an orchestral suite arrangement for modern orchestra credited to conductor Felix Mottl, but I recall that some of the actual selections in that suite were different from the ones recorded here. Stokowski recordings of the great Brahms and Beethoven Symphonies were generally no more exaggerated in their phrasing and dynamics that those by other conductors of the period, sometimes less so. His recordings with the Philadelphia Orchestra of the Sousa marches were famous in their time as patriotic gestures, but are hardly any more vigorous than other symphonic band versions. It was in the extremely slow versions of old melodies, most notoriously Bach’s Komm Süsser Tod, not recorded in this set, that the Stokowski trademark showed most vividly. Byrd, Handel, and Frescobaldi would hardly recognize their own music! On scratchy old 78s, or even scratchy old LPs, they were unendurable, but CD transfers allow us to try to enjoy them now for the first time. At the time, I believe, most persons bought the recordings, as they bought most symphonic recordings, to recall to them an experience of hearing the music live in the concert hall. It is a pleasure to have these classic recordings available, to listen to the Philadelphia Orchestra strings sliding unabashedly from note to note, to hear the barely post-adolescent fifty-year-old Stokowski pouring his "youthful" energy into his work. Only now, with these and other really good transfers available, can I see what some other critics have said, that Stokowski may not have lost very much of his special abilities in his doting old age, but he had a little more fun in the early years. On the other hand, it would be difficult to really enjoy these recordings if one didn’t have the later ones to compare, and to return to, for it is difficult in any instance here to say that the old recording is really better, really a more satisfactory listening experience. A case is the Franck Symphony. Many disparage the Decca stereo version, in fact Decca even declined at first to re-issue it on CD, but I can’t see any advantage over it in the earlier recordings, or even in the recorded broadcast performance contemporary with the recording sessions. For all its slightly tinkered-with sound, it carries more of the music in it, and is, for better or worse, how Stokowski wanted us to hear it. A real collector will appreciate that the photos of Stokowski in the booklet are mostly new to me and I thought I had them all. Paul Shoemaker see also review by Jonathan Woolf   Advertising on Musicweb Donate and keep us afloat   New Releases All Naxos reviews All Chandos reviews All Hyperion reviews All Foghorn reviews All Troubadisc reviews all Bridge reviews all cpo reviews Click to see New Releases Get 10% off using code musicweb10 All Divine Art reviews All Eloquence reviews All Lyrita Reviews   Obtain 10% discount Recordings of the Month August 2022 Louis Caix d'Hervelois orchestral songs   String Quartets   July 2022 John Luther Adams Houses of the Wind Horneman Alladin Piano Concertos 1 & 2 Yi Lin Jiang - Dualis I

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.