One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Gillian Weir - five Decca Eloquence CDs
(Recorded between 1974 and 1980. Organs of St Laurens, Rotterdam; Clare College Cambridge; Royal Festival Hall, London; Hexham Abbey; St Leonhardskirche, Basel; St Maximin Thionville. ADD)

J.S. BACH (1685-1750)
Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in C BWV 564 [16’05]
Fantasia in G BWV 572 [9’07]
Trio Sonata no 1 in E-flat BWV 525 [9’18]
Passacaglia in c BWV 582 [13’39]
Louis MARCHAND (1669-1732)

Pièces d’Orgue:
From Premier Livre: Dialogue sur les grands jeux [2’47]; Recit de tierce en taille [4’16]; Basse et dessus de Trompette et de Cornet [2’19]; Recit de Voix Humaine [5’20]
From Cinquième Livre: Basse de Cromorne ou de Trompette [1’20]; Duo [0’42]; Récit [1’39]; Plein-Jeu [1’23]; Fugue [2’13]; Basse de Trompette ou de Cromorne [1’38]; Récit de tierce en taille [3’26]
John BULL (1562-1628)

Dr Bull’s Mt Selfe [1’15]
Dr Bull’s Jewell [1’58]
Gillian Weir (organ)
DECCA ELOQUENCE 460 1862 [79’09]
Louis Nicholas CLERAMBAULT (1676-1749)
Suite du Premier Ton (complete) [21’24]
Suite du deuxième ton [20’39]
Nikolaus BRUHNS (1665-1697)

Praeludium No 1 in G [7’03]
Praeludium No 2 in e (larger) [8’39]
Praeludium No 3 in e (smaller) [4’20]
Gillian Weir (organ)
DECCA ELOQUENCE 460 1872 [75’36]

François ROBERDAY (1624-1680)
Fugues et Caprices pour orgue [61’09]
Jean LANGLAIS (1907-1991)

Dialogue sur les Mixtures [3’09]
Samuel SCHEIDT (1587-1654)

Passamezzo (Variations 1-12) [14’22]
Gillian Weir (organ)
DECCA ELOQUENCE 460 1882 [78’55]
Jean-François DANDRIEU (1682-1738)
Pièces en A. Mi La [11’05]
Magnificat [10’57]
Pièces in G Re sol mineur [14’13]
Magnificat [10’19]
Louis MARCHAND (1669-1732)

Pièces d’orgue:
From Troisième Livre: Dialogue sur les grands jeux [9’35]
From Quatrième Livre: Duo [0’47]; Fugue [2’09]; Trio [0’46]; Récit [1’03]; Duo [1’29]; Basse de Trompette [1’19]; Récit de tierce en taille [2’57]
Nicholas DE GRIGNY (1672-1703)

Tierce en Taille [5’58]
Henri MULET (1878-1967)

Toccata: Te es Petrus
Gillian Weir (organ)
DECCA ELOQUENCE 460 1892 [77’04]
Charles CAMILLERI (b. 1931)
Missa Mundi (1972) [45’12]
Charles-Marie WIDOR (1844-1937)

From Symphony 6: Allegro [8’24]
Louis VIERNE (1870-1937)

Impromptu [2’59]
Louis Claude DAQUIN (1694-1772)

Noël Suisse [3’22]
Marcel DUPRÉ (1886-1971)

From Suite Bretonne: La Fileuse [3’17]
Thomas TOMKINS (1572-1656)

Worster Braules [1’15]
Jan Pieterszoon SWEELINCK (1562-1621)

Mein junges Leben hat ein End [7’21]
Théodore DUBOIS (1837-1924)

Toccata [5’47]
Gillian Weir (organ)
DECCA ELOQUENCE 460 1902 [78’08]


The contribution made to the world of the organ by Dame Gillian Weir is almost incalculable. Our instrument has hardly had such a skilled ambassador in modern times - not just as a remarkable performer, but also through her radio and television appearances, and her many recordings. It is therefore interesting to reflect on these recordings, made mostly around thirty years ago, and containing predominantly baroque music. Gillian Weir notes in volume 1 that the recordings will be seen in context. This is of course true, but even if many attitudes towards performance of some of this music have changed, it is fascinating to consider the impact they must have had.

Weir’s teaching and performing of much of the music here shaped, in a sense, the attitude of a whole generation of British organists toward early repertoire. Its not hard to see why in those days, when Britain was still under the heady spell of the first wave of reformists, (both players and organ builders) why her playing of pre-1750 literature, much of it then little known compared to the situation today, was so inspirational. Her Bruhns for instance on Volume 2 is remarkable for its sheer sense of drama, even if elements such as organ choice, tempo relationships, rhetoric and registration are now considered within different parameters. It should be remembered that Gillian Weir was an ambassador in Britain for reformist thinking abroad; perhaps her most inspirational mentor was the redoubtable Anton Heiller.

One area where changing tastes have in no way diminished Weir’s recorded achievements is in the area of French Classical music. "French Classical music is my passion" she writes in Volume 4. Her atmospheric, dramatic and intense readings have stood the test of time remarkably well. Perhaps my favourite example is her recording of the Fugues and Caprices of Roberday on Volume 3. What an astonishing body of work this is, all but unknown to me I am ashamed to say, and the composer’s only surviving opus, published in 1660. Weir plays here on the marvellous sounding 1718 Andreas Silbermann organ in the Leonhardkirche in Basel. Her admission that "I spent an evening playing through a pile of little-known music I had brought alone ..... and decided to record it then and there" is scarcely believable, these are among the most profound recordings of the whole series. Her Clérambault on Volume 2 is perhaps a close second – Weir plays the same organ.

Another area where Gillian Weir has surpassed her British colleagues is in the championing of unpopular 20th century literature. She famously won the St Albans competition in 1964 playing Messiaen at a time when Messiaen was, in the UK at least not mainstream organ repertoire. Perhaps the most important recording here then is her performance of the Maltese composer, Charles Camilleri’s Missa Mundi, (Volume 5). What a terrifying work this is, with extended fortissimo atonal repeated chordal passages, Messiaenic monophony contrasting with the stillness of the concluding ‘Prayer’. This work was composed in 1972 and, it must be said, has never really caught on. In fact I know of just one other recording, perhaps inevitably by the completist’s completist, Kevin Bowyer. Did Dame Gillian in a sense back the wrong horse? I think actually, whatever one’s feeling about the piece, and it is an acquired taste, that the demands made on the player are simply too extreme for all but a handful of organists to take on. Weir’s incredibly virtuosic playing here, in the ultra-dry Royal Festival Hall reminds us that she came to Britain from her native New Zealand in the first instance to study piano. It is fitting therefore that this has been re-issued.

In terms of mainstream repertoire, certain performances, mostly of French music remain, more or less, cutting edge. The dazzling Dubois, Vierne, Mulet and especially Dupré have scarcely, if ever been beaten. Perhaps this is the literature for which Gillian Weir will be most remembered by players and listeners of future generations. I can’t help feeling though, as a result of my hypothesis, that the present recordings therefore, with their focus on pre-1750 literature, don’t necessarily represent the very best of Weir’s recorded oeuvre. Her complete Messiaen cycle for instance has, for my money, never been bettered, even by the spectacular Latry/Notre Dame combination on DG. I am also a huge admirer of her Franck recordings; she captures an other-worldliness in his music which few others manage, but never falls into the category who would seek, in the footsteps of Tournemire, to re-incarnate a fantastical Père Angélique through sentimental, slow and often boring interpretations.

The organs featured on the present discs make up an interesting collection. In terms of the baroque and pre-baroque repertoire at least, they are symptomatic of a previous generation of players and ideals. Some, like that already mentioned in Basel, are fabulous and play the part well. Others are now seen in a different, not necessarily negative, but certainly contextual light. The sterile Marcussen in Rotterdam, strikes me, even in 1977, as a curious choice for the Bach, (volume 1). Yes, it was brand spanking new, and then the biggest organ in the Netherlands. But just 20 minutes away on the train is a far more beautiful example of that generation of organ building, the Metzler in the Grote Kerk in The Hague. Playing on a modern instrument in the Netherlands at all is curious given the 900-odd historical organs to be found throughout the land. Interestingly Gillian Weir’s most recent Bach recording is on a historical reconstruction in Leipzig. The Beckerath organ in Cambridge, (Bruhns volume 2, Scheidt volume 3), is of a better quality than the Rotterdam organ, but the equal temperament and rock-steady wind again become tiring on the ear after a while. The organ of Hexham Abbey, designed and built by Weir’s late husband, is used in a huge variety of contexts, from Bull to Widor; again the temperament and wind issues in Cambridge work against the early music, and the high mixtures work against the Widor.

But probably I’m missing the point. Gillian Weir’s musical ideals of the time are tied up with her views of the instruments. One should bear this in mind I think, and revel in these re-issues for what they are, a portrait of a hugely influential artist at a certain period in her career.

Some gripes must be aired. Firstly, what a shame that Gillian Weir herself didn’t contribute more of the liner notes, she is so eloquent! Mr RJ Stove writes adequate notes but these contain such inaccuracies as "pedals were not nearly so common [in the mid 18th century] in France as in….England or Italy". Ouch. Secondly, there is nothing at all about the organs. A photo of the astonishing Thionville case at least should have been included together with some histories and stop-lists. Thirdly the weird composition of the discs that has two of them consisting of 95 % baroque music with one track of 20th century French repertoire used as a filler.

I would recommend especially Volume 2 for the Clérambault, 3 for the Roberday, and 5 for the Camilleri and the deliciously played French miniatures from Hexham.

Chris Bragg



Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

All Chandos reviews

All Hyperion reviews

All Foghorn reviews

All Troubadisc reviews

Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews

All Eloquence reviews

All Lyrita Reviews


Obtain 10% discount

Recordings of the Month


Donizetti - Le Convenienze ed Inconvenienze Teatrali

Chamber Symphonies 2 & 4

French Cello Concertos





Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.