One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Frank Ezra LEVY (b. 1930)
A Summer Overture (1997) [8:39]
Cello Concerto No. 2 (2002) [20:12]
Rondo Tarantella (2003) [15:53]
Symphony No. 3 (1977) [20:10]
Scott Ballantyne (Cello)
RTÉ National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland/Takuo Yuasa
rec. 27-28 September 2004 at Dublin Concert Hall, Dublin, Ireland
NAXOS 8.559234 [64:53]

Not much of Frank Ezra Levyís musical output has been committed to disc ó in looking at what is currently available on various web sites, I have found a cello concerto (his first) and his fourth symphony. Here, then, is a special contribution towards the wider distribution of this composerís music.

A Summer Overture manages to sound like an American overture without also sounding like Copland or Bernstein, which, by other examples out there, is no mean feat. It has moments both exciting and sinister. The work is based on the tune "Sumer is icumen in," which is reduced to fragments that are treated contrapuntally. This is an easily accessible piece that will appeal both to early music enthusiasts as well as to those that enjoy dynamic, extrovert music.

The Second Cello Concerto, a work of 2002 performed by its dedicatee, begins on the same note A Summer Overture returned to so insistently in its coda. In his notes, the composer refers to a process of "kaleidoscopic variation" as the basis for this composition. Indeed, the movements focus on broad variations that change guise. The first movement ends seemingly in mid-sentence, with the contrasting narrative of the second movement as a sudden change of heart. Reminiscent of Shostakovich, this movement has the solo instrument and orchestral forces trading the narrative line and, rather often, in conflict with each other for dominance. The Allegro is a manic, driving force in the orchestra, with the solo instrument acting almost as a retarding agent, tempering the outbursts of the collected ensemble. Though Shostakovich comes to mind, this is a work that has none of the mind-spinning Shostakovich cadenzas; instead it seems to focus on pitting the orchestra against the solo instrument.

Rondo Tarantella of 2003 begins ominously with low winds, then transfers its unease, its syncopated jig-like theme, to the strings and upper woodwinds. This work has been incorporated into the opera Motherís Day as the finale to Act 2, where, in an effort to gain entry to a womenís political movement, the Presidentís husband disguises himself as a woman to infiltrate a demonstration. It is a piece of tension and anticipation.

The Third Symphony of 1977 is a much earlier work than the others presented here. It is a weightier example of the basic method employed by Levy, which consists of an initial basic narration of a theme from which variations arise. Some of the mutations are more radical than others before the original statement returns. Odd elements and figures at the end foreshadow the second movement, which continues from the first without a break; a steady building of the material that has been presented. With a restrained gong blow, the movement is driven back to a taut quiet section before the ensemble takes courage behind the hornís restatement. From there, the orchestral forces gather finally to a military force that ends abruptly with a flurry of woodwinds. The side-drum motif that heralds this last movement and takes us through to the end is a recurrence of the same figure that reminds one of Shostakovich in the cello concerto.

The sound quality of this disc fits in well with the overall quality of the Naxos releases. In the cello concerto, the solo instrument is warmly presented, well-balanced with the orchestra, and exceedingly well-played by Ballantyne.

David Blomenberg



Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.