This is a re-issue of a recording made to mark the restoration of a modest but gorgeous example of mid-19th century village organ building. First built in 1860 by the original J.W. Walker for a private house, the organ ended up in the church of St Mongo, Simonburn, in Northumberland. It consists of 13 stops on 2 manuals and pedal:

GT: 8888442

SW: 88848 (Horn)

PED: 16

The quality is immediately evident; more unaltered examples of really good 19th century small-scale English organ building should be recorded I think. The sweet flutes, gentle principals and the rich Horn all contribute to a beautiful instrument.

A shame then, that the organist Henry Wallace FRCO (never list your qualifications on a CD cover!), a former student of Peter Hurford and David Sanger, plays not a note of 19th century English music and dedicates the better part of thirty minutes to music written before 1750. This serves neither the instrument, nor the music optimally. That said, Wallace's Bach playing is probably stylistically rather in the manner of the way Bach was performed in 1860; rather legato and rhythmically unyielding. The result is a strangely satisfying aesthetic match. The Sweelinck, Froberger and Fischer miss the mark. The rest of the literature works better, but the playing is musically rather naive. The Franck is too solid, the Mendelssohn doesn't take sufficient notice of the composer’s very exact tempo markings. The Dubois is in G, not in C as stated on the CD booklet. What a shame we hear no Wesley, Russell, even the marvellously constructed miniatures of Edward Elgar's op.14 Vesper Voluntaries would have been spot-on.

A nice piece of local history, and an undoubtedly first-rate instrument, but to satisfactorily fill nearly 70 minutes of CD with such a modest instrument requires far more cunning than Wallace can offer.

Chris Bragg

 

 

Advertising Rates
Visitor stats
MusicWeb International
has over 30,000 Classical CD reviews on offer

Gerard Hoffnung Concerts &
The Bricklayer Story

New Releases

New Releases

Musicweb
Special Offers

Google Ads - for information about privacy matters, click here.