These are the famous 
                – or if you’re a piano student, notorious 
                - Kuhlau Sonatinas. They do tend to 
                be churned out come examination time 
                though that’s not to say that they’re 
                arid examples, though it is to say that 
                contemporary publishers did have more 
                than one eye on the market for instructional 
                material. They have plenty of up and 
                down scalar writing and they do make 
                demands on the technique though less 
                so on matters of interpretive intimacy. 
                Kulhau showed in his vocal works that 
                he’d lent an ear to Schubert and there 
                are hints that those influences had 
                seeped into his piano writing. That 
                said, it’s true to say that if they 
                had it’s more like the piano writing 
                of the Violin Sonatas (or Sonatinas) 
                than the bigger solo piano works. 
              
 
              
The abiding influence 
                however is Mozart’s. There are some 
                surprises along the way, such as the 
                lively clop of the Allegro Scherzando 
                that ends the G major, Op.20 No.2 and 
                the Alla Polacca that gives such free 
                rein for display in the F major from 
                the same set. It also gives opportunities 
                to impress with pomposo left hand articulation 
                though I doubt any student could begin 
                to match Erik Fessel at such points. 
                The Andantino of Op.88 No.1 is explicitly 
                and attractively vocal, with its strong 
                right hand melody line and simple, supportive 
                left. The Alla Polacca finale (again) 
                of the F major Op.55 No.4 has a sprightly 
                strut and tests accurate rhythm. The 
                Op.60 Sonatinas use variations on themes 
                from Rossini’s Armida – like 
                Beethoven, Rossini was a definite influence 
                on Kuhlau but neither influence is really 
                evident in these Sonatinas. 
              
 
              
Fessel plays them adroitly 
                and with simplicity; the recording level 
                is not over scaled and the acoustic 
                is warm. There’s certainly some charm 
                in these miniatures though the music 
                is deliberately circumscribed to suit 
                its market. 
              
 
              
Jonathan Woolf