Search MusicWeb Here Custom Search     International mailing

Searching Musicweb Monthly index Recordings of the Year Label index Masterwork index Series index Search engines Review Archive Classical Downloads Jazz Concerts Nostalgia Books Film music Resources Composer pages National discographies Online books Piano Trio Survey Gerard Hoffnung Arthur Butterworth's columns Philip Scowcroft's British light music collection Interviews Programme notes Other material Articles Seen & Heard Jazz reviews Message Board Announcements About Musicweb About Musicweb Contact Musicweb Contributors What they say about us Visitor stats Site Map

Founder: Len Mullenger

Classical Editor in Chief: Rob Barnett

Organ Spectacular - Jean Guillou CD1 J.S. BACH Toccata and Fugue in D Minor BWV 565 [8'24] Nicolas DE GRIGNY Recit de Tierce en Taille [6'09] Wolfgang Amadeus MOZART Fantasy in F minor K 608 [9'56] Jean GUILLOU Hyperion or The Rhetoric of Fire; Hermes [4'23], The Fires of Silence [4'56], The Inflamed Soul [10'54], Agni-Ignis [5'13] Charles-Marie WIDOR Allegro Vivace from Symphony No 5 [10'35] Franz LISZT Fantasy and Fugue on BACH [13'32] CD2 J.S. BACH Sinfonia from Cantata 29 "Wir danken dir Gott, wir danken dir" [3'51] Choral, "Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme" BWV645 [4'25] Badinerie, from Suite No 2 in B minor BWV 1067 [1'27] John STANLEY Voluntary in A minor [4'16] Henry PURCELL Trumpet Tune in D major [2'21] Frei JACINTO Toccata in D minor [2'07] Carlos SEIXAS Toccata in F minor [2'05]; Toccata in G minor [3'10] George Frideric HANDEL Allegro from Organ Concerto op7/10 in D minor [5'30] J.S. BACH Sarabande BWV 977 [2'56] Louis-Nicolas CLERAMBAULT Basse et dessus de Trompette [2'01] J.S. BACH Fugue in G major BWV 577 [2'58] G.F. HANDEL Hornpipe from Water Music [4'10] Joseph HAYDN Flotenuhrstucke in D major [0'58] Flotenuhrstucke in G major [1'42] Robert SCHUMANN Canon in A-flat major [3'41]; Canon in B minor [2'45] Franz LISZT Valse Oubliée No 1 [3'47] Serge PROKOFIEV March from "Love of the 3 Oranges" [1'43] Jean GUILLOU Hautbois d'Amour from "Jeux d'Orgue" [1'58]; Tutti Ostinati from "Jeux d'Orgue" [2'34]; Improvisation on 'Greensleeves' [6'30] CD3 Joseph JONGEN Symphonie Concertante for Organ and Orchestra op 81; Allegro, molto moderato (in the Dorian mode) [7'35], Divertimento, molto vivo [8'18], Molto Lento, misterioso [12'00], Toccata (moto perpetuo), allegro moderato [5'09] Camille SAINT-SAENS Symphony No 3 in C Minor ‘Organ’ (Adagio [9'37], Poco Adagio [9'53], Allegro Moderato [7'38], Maestoso [7'18]) Jean Guillou, organ Dallas Symphony Orchestra/Eduardo Mata (CD 3) Rec: St Eustache, Paris (CD 1), Notre Dame des Neiges, Alpe D'Huez, France, (CD 2), Meyerson Center, Dallas (CD 3) between 1987 and 1994. DDD BRILLIANT CLASSICS 92386 [75'11 + 70'04 + 68'44]

Jean Guillou is perhaps the greatest of all the organ world's ‘Enfants Térribles’. Here is a selection of re-released Dorian recordings of his 'art', recorded on two of his own creations, the screaming Van den Heuvel in his own church of St Eustache, and the comical Kleuker at Alpe d'Huez. The third CD is recorded on an organ inestimably more important, the Fisk at Dallas's Meyerson Symphony Center, an organ which literally changed the face of concert-hall organ building. However in contrast with the information given about the world's first 'Hautbois en Chamade' at Alpe d'Huez (a Guillou invention that sounds like a duck on amphetamines), and Guillou himself telling us that the St Eustache monster has "all the possibilities that a contemporary musician could wish for from a 20th century organ", nothing is told about the Dallas instrument. Literally nothing. Guillou is an organist for whom organ music is clearly dull. This is evident in his desire to re-invent all the literature using his own registrational world, (strange mutations and a menagerie-like collection of reeds especially important) and adding cadenzas, (those in Handel pieces on CD2 are especially banal). Other typical Guillou-isms include replacing the flute in the famous Bach Badinerie with a Trompette en chamade, tasteful stuff. Even when one could really expect something interesting, such as when Guillou plays his own compositions, one is let down here; nearly 25 minutes of Hyperion's pseudo-apocalyptic nonsense (CD1) left me with a headache and little else. The one area perhaps where Guillou could have a reasonable claim to have enriched the organ world is with his spectacular transcriptions of non-organ music. However even here it must be said that, almost without exception, his students play these better than he does. Guillou's rhythm is so weak throughout these recordings - the booklet euphemistically refers to his "highly personal approach to rhythm"- as to madden the listener. This is most clearly demonstrated in the third CD when his poor rhythm and wild tempi collide with the Dallas Symphony Orchestra. This is catastrophic from the outset of the Jongen. The tempo at which Guillou begins the final Toccata is beyond ridiculous. While I'm about it, we badly need a good recording of the Jongen, surely the finest Organ Concerto ever written. Wouldn't Debussy have been proud of the slow movement? Michael Murray's mid-1980s recording for Telarc with the excellent San Francisco Symphony Orchestra, is let down by the poor organ in that city's Davies Hall. In a more recent Solstice release, Pierre Pincemaille playing the lovely early Cavaillé-Coll in Perpignan, is badly let down by a woeful orchestra. The saddest element of this gruesome Guillou box is that it will be very inexpensive. Presumably it was intended to find new followers for our instrument. I can barely think of a more inappropriate introduction. Chris Bragg   Gerard Hoffnung CDs Advertising on Musicweb Donate and get a free CD   New Releases   Musicweb sells the following labels Acte Préalable (THE Polish label) Altus 10% off Arcodiva Atoll 10% off CDAccord CRD 10% off Hallé 10% off Hortus Lyrita 10% off Nimbus 10% off Nimbus Alliance Prima voce 10% off Red Priest 10% off Retrospective 10% off Saydisc 10% off Sheva £2 off Sheva Contemporary Sterling 10% off Toccata Classics Follow us on Twitter Subscribe to our free weekly review listing sample Sample: See what you will get Editorial Board MusicWeb International Founding Editor    Rob Barnett Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus    Bill Kenny Editor in Chief    Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster    David Barker MusicWeb Founder    Len Mullenger

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.