These are arrangements
by the composers themselves. Both symphonies
are very popular and one is probably
a masterpiece.
Composers of the time
often made arrangements for piano duet
of their works since this would introduce
such works to a wider audience since
not everyone could get to orchestral
concerts.
Hearing these symphonies
in this form brings out some detail
and it also shows how some orchestral
effects cannot be successfully reproduced
on the piano such as, for example, timpani
rolls.
For
those who are interested Anthony Goldstone,
probably in one of his fascinating and
eccentric waistcoats, takes the top
part of the piano. Caroline Clemmow
takes the bottom part.
I cannot praise this
duo too highly. They both have a wonderful
sense of musicianship and I have enjoyed
their performances over many years.
As with all Divine
Arts CDs I have, the sound and presentation
is good.
Why should you buy
this disc? Let me list some of the many
reasons
1. It brings out detail
which may not always be clear in orchestral
performances
2. It is well played
3. It is comparatively
unusual.
4. It might encourage
pianists to take up these arrangements
and, as a result, they will receive
much enjoyment from so doing and so
will their audiences.
5. Both symphonies
are given the most satisfactory performances
which are full of life, verve and great
sensitivity.
6. Performances in
this form are a very valuable service
to music lovers.
7. It will prove invaluable
to music teachers, music colleges and
seminaries in the study of these two
works and symphonic works in general.
On
another note this disc shows up, no
doubt unintentionally, how superior
the Mendelssohn is. I have no desire
to put down the Dvořák although,
as I say in my biography of this composer,
available
on this website, the finale of the
New World symphony is nothing
more than a pot-pourri of tunes and
the glorious slow movement loses something
in the four hand transcription but that
must not deter you from examining this
disc.
Mendelssohn's symphony
is a far better work and, incidentally,
it works better in the four hand version
than the Dvořák.
I revelled in the abundance of detail
revealed in this performance and was
reminded of what a truly great composer
Mendelssohn is. There is a lovely and
infectious tripping style in this choice
playing and the atmosphere is caught
to perfection. It has real charm
and the performance is a real joy to
listen to. One may not often use the
word inspiring to describe Mendelssohn
but, on the basis on this performance,
the word must be used.
You should acquire
this disc even if you only play it once.
It is a real joy. But do not treat it
as a novelty. It is too good for that.
Recommended. One does
not have to say more. The disc recommends
itself.
David Wright
Anthony Goldstone and Caroline Clemmow (piano
duet)
