One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

or Divine Art

Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750)
English Suite No 2 in A minor, BWV807
Partita No 1 in B flat major, BWV825
Chromatic Fantasia and Fugue in D minor, BWV903
Toccata in D major, BWV912
Jill Crossland (piano)
recorded in the Old Granary Studio, Norwich, 2 March 2003


This Bach recital may interest a collector who isn’t particularly wanting to have all the English Suites or Partitas - an expensive proposition - but is happy to ‘dip’ into this very extensive repertory. It may also be attractive to anyone who likes to track the progress of young artists, for Ms Crossland is, despite my misgivings, definitely a player to watch.

It may be a cliché to say so, but Bach is a difficult composer to play on the piano. Absolute control and dexterity is required for such ornate and exposed lines: left hand parts in particular require exceptional agility, of a sort one seldom encounters in the core Romantic repertory. It’s important to be aware of performance practice in Bach’s time, and to know how to steer a course between the resonance of the modern piano and the percussive sonority of the harpsichord, between overstatement and under-characterisation. Small wonder that celebrated Bach players (one thinks of Fischer, Lipatti, Gould, Richter, Gavrilov, Brendel, Argerich, Schiff, Perahia and Goode) often move into this repertory in their maturity, having previously explored more overtly virtuosic or demanding roles elsewhere - like serving an apprenticeship! Hewitt is the obvious exception here, having made her reputation in Bach, and now ‘progressing’ into Ravel and Chopin.

Jill Crossland was born in Yorkshire, and studied at Chethams and the Royal Northern College of Music in Manchester. Even as a student, it seems she inclined towards Bach, performing the entire ‘48’ from memory, winning the Pinsen Prize for her Bach playing, and reaching the semi-final stages of the 8th International Bach Competition in Leipzig. The CD liner doesn’t tell us how old she is.

I have no doubts concerning her abilities: her fingerwork is polished, her sense of phrase beyond question, and she is well able to characterise the different dance movements, or the many meanderings of the Chromatic Fantasia. The opening movements (the Prelude, Allemande and Courante) of the English Suite are stylish and secure, and confidently raise one’s expectations. But I have to say I found at least some of what follows less than convincing, and at times so artistically doubtful as to be baffling, even bizarre. The Sarabande of the same suite (which she takes slowly) finds her introducing rubato in such quantities, and in both voices, as to disturb the pulse: at first, it looked likely to be subtle, but it soon reached unnecessary and destructive proportions. But the singing quality of her playing encourages the listener to stay with her.

She plays the Præludium of the B flat Partita extraordinarily slowly: I’m open-minded about these things, but I’d be hard pressed to find any evidence that Bach intended it to go like this! And yet the Allemande and Corrente are beautifully fluid. In the Sarabande, again, very slow, the right hand semiquavers and demisemiquavers are so seldom left to speak for themselves, and so often distorted with little holdings-up and rushings (in the name of shaping?) as to spoil all sense of line: one almost loses one’s bearings. But again, she redeems herself with a mercurial Gigue.

This disc is the proverbial curate’s egg: very good in parts, and thought-provoking (make of that what you want) in others. I hope Ms Crossland will find a way of allowing Bach’s music to speak for itself, without undue interference: and yet much of this disc shows that she already knows this. I suggest that lessons with Angela Hewitt or Richard Goode (their CDs will surely suffice) are called for!

The recorded sound here is good: appropriately, for what the CD booklet tells us is an ‘Astounding Sounds’ recording. Annoying that both inner and outer pages of the notes list the items of this recital in a different sequence to that she actually adopts: so the D major Toccata is last, not first!

There shouldn’t be any problem obtaining this CD, which is distributed worldwide by the Divine Art Record Company in Northallerton: you can get full details from You’ll also find there details of Ms Crossland’s previous Calico Classics disc (CCCR101) of Mozart (K533/494 in F) and Beethoven (Op 31/2 in D minor & Op 101 in A flat) sonatas. She’s also recorded the Goldberg Variations for Apex - 0927 49979-2.

Peter J Lawson

see also

Johann Sebastian BACH (1685 - 1750) Goldberg Variations, BWV 988 Jill Crossland, piano Rec: April 1998, Vestry Hall Studios, Ealing, UK WARNER APEX 0927 49979 2 [73.11] [KM]

An idiosyncratic recording that may interest the curious


Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat



Recordings of the Month


From Ocean’s Floor


Conner Riddle Songs

Rodzinski Sibelius

Of Innocence and Experience


Symphonies 1, 2, 3

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.