Luigi CHERUBINI (1760-1842) Overtures
Eliza, ou Le voyage aux glaciers du Mont St-Bernard (1794) [7:24]
Médée (1797) [7:53]
L’Hôtelerie portugaise (1798) [9:43]
Les deux Journées, ou Le Porteur d’eau (1800) [8:46]
Anacréon, ou L’Amour fugitive (1803) [8:34]
Faniska (1806) [7:16]
Les Abencérages, ou L’Étendard de Grenade (1813) [6:13]
Concert Overture (1815) [10:27]
St. Martin in the Fields/Sir Neville Marriner
rec. May, 1991, Studio 1, Abbey Road, London EMI CLASSICS
the exception of Médée, the operas of Cherubini are
largely unknown territory these days. Even the overtures
feature only very occasionally in the concert hall. Since
they are works of more than passing interest, it is therefore
a pleasure to welcome this ArkivCD reissue of a 1991 programme
by the Academy of St. Martin in the Fields, conducted by
of Cherubini’s best work for the opera house was written
in Paris, under the influence of the Italian Giovanni Viotti
(1753-1824), well described by Basil Deane as a “violinist,
composer and musical entrepeneur”. It was at his prompting
that Cherubini came to live in Paris in 1788. Less than perfect
timing, of course, since it was the year before the revolution.
In the context of the real dangers of the situation and under
the political pressures – which prompted a concentration
on certain kinds of libretti – Cherubini had no choice but
to try to adapt himself to the new conventions. Operatically
that initially meant works, often known as ‘rescue’ operas,
in which the virtuous (and politically ‘correct’) were maltreated
and imprisoned by the evil (and politically ‘incorrect’)
before being eventually and triumphantly rescued. In Cherubini’s
operas this ‘rescue’ was often not from literal imprisonment
but by means of escape to an alternative place. This sense
of tension and release plays some part in a number of these
are many good things here. Eliza, ou Le voyage aux glaciers
du Mont St-Bernard is set, somewhat improbably, amidst
the snows of the Alps, and the final rescue is from an avalanche.
The overture has dignity, a pleasant pastoral theme and a
kind of picturesque grandeur (without any signs of the avalanche).
The overture to Anacréon is a work of some delicacy
and charm, music of real grace. The overture to Les Abencérages,
ou L’Étendard de Grenade shows off Cherubini’s skills
as an orchestrator to good effect, and entertainingly interweaves
themes from the main body of the opera. L’Hôtelerie portugaise is
a one-act comic opera – appealing to rather different tastes
and requirements after the traumatic experience of the Terror.
The music is sprightly and inventive, with echoes of ‘La
Folia’ at one point. The overture to Médée is more
familiar and, out by the side of the overture to L’Hôtelerie
portugaise effectively illustrates something of Cherubini’s
range. The dramatic qualities of the Médée overture
are, to a degree, echoed in the well-made overture to Faniska (another ‘rescue’ opera).
looks in vain for the overture to Lodoïska (1791)
which did much to create the vogue for the ‘rescue’ opera,
and the Concert Overture, written for the London Philharmonic
Society, is a little on the ponderous side, doing relatively
little with the material and ideas it contains. But, for
the most part, the music on this disc is rewarding, adroitly
constructed and full of attractive harmonic and melodic touches.
Orchestra and conductor are on good form, though now and
then a little more drive, a little more rhythmic bite wouldn’t
have gone amiss.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.