One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


  AmazonUK   AmazonUS

AntonŪn DVOŘŃK (1841-1904)
Symphonic Poems and Overtures

Czech Suite op. 39
My Home Overture op. 62
Husitska Overture op. 67
In Natureís Realm Overture op. 91
Otello op. 93
Symphonic Variations op. 78
Carnival Overture op. 92
Water Goblin op. 107
Noon-Day Witch op. 108
Golden Spinning Wheel, op. 109
Wood Dove, op. 110
A Heroīs Song, op. 111
JanŠček Philharmonic Orchestra/Theodore Kuchar

Recorded 20-28 August 2004, Ostrava
BRILLIANT CLASSICS 92297 [3 CDs: 71'37 + 63'12 + 66'14]


This is a handy box because some of the symphonic poems and overtures are, frankly, works more honoured in the breach than in the hearing. The programmatic ballads are very tricky to programme in concert Ė too long with a concerto in the first half and unwieldy in the second where one would expect a symphony. Ideally one needs an old Proms concert, maybe even a three-part concert with two intervals where The Golden Spinning Wheel, say, would fit more comfortably. When did you last hear it in concert?

On disc itís a different matter. Kudos then to the Kuchar-Brilliant team, though geographical homework is necessary for this Dutch company; the resident JanŠček Philharmonic Orchestra will be amazed to find that their hometown, Ostrava, is in Slovenia. Mind you itís one better than the American company that located Prague in the Balkans. Trivia aside this is a thoroughly engaging and spry set. Kuchar has shown in his Russian repertoire that he is a thoroughly sensitive musician and when he goes further afield (e.g. Roy Harris, on Naxos) the results have been splendid. If his DvořŠk isnít quite so special then thatís probably because there are a raft of recordings, present and, particularly, past against which these performances must be measured.

Here are a few pointers to Kucharís way with this body of work. He tends to be brisk; not businesslike, if that implies superficiality and a lack of warmth and detail, but certainly fast-ish. My Home is despatched in 8.57, which is by no means remorseless but when Kertesz and, especially, Krombholc take that bit longer (the latter 9.40 and heís only slightly broader than the Hungarian) the result tells in weight and stirring peroration. In truth Kuchar does sound just that bit lightweight alongside the Czech conductor, who scores in gravity and depth. In the same vein the Hussite Overture lacks that vein of sprung rhythm that gives such life to Kerteszís disc - and the brass drowning the strings doesnít help much either. In Natureís Realm is inscribed with real sensitivity and burnishing life by Krombholc and Kucharís worthy performance does rather pale. That there are a wide variety of approaches can be shown by the 1948 Talich; the great conductor is considerably slower than almost everyone on record. As indeed he is in Othello Ė where he takes sixteen and a half minutes to Kucharís fourteen Ė the sagacious Krombholc is somewhere in the middle. Here Kucharís linear approach scores in cohesion but somewhat undercooks the drama, the brooding intensity of which Talich elongates to intense effect.

It would be rather wearying to delve too deeply into the specificities of these performances but I should add that Carnival is fast, and a tiny bit slick if one compares him with Ančerl. Kucharís Water Goblin takes Talichís spriteliness (in both 1949, where heís fast and 1954 whereís he slows considerably but is in poorer and live sound). The Noon-Day Witch is perfectly serviceable but listen to Talich or Kertesz and youíll hear a greater weight of string tone and a caressing intimacy of phrasing and a degree of rhythmic intensity that rather elude Kuchar and his team. Talich shows the way with the Wood Dove, sometimes called Wild Dove [Holoubek] Ė heís a shade quicker and more insidious and mocking. The Golden Spinning Wheel has a good sense of rustic drama and the Symphonic Variations is generally well shaped.

Those looking for a handy introduction should go to someone Iíve not yet mentioned Ė Kubelíkís Bavarian recordings re-released on DG Trio - supplemented by the Kertesz Deccas (Iím not always an uncritical admirer of his symphonic cycle but the "fillers" are good) and then the Talich and Ancerl recordings. Youíll find the old Krombholc a bit tricky to track down but you wonít regret the effort.

Jonathan Woolf

Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical

Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10


Obtain 10% discount

Recordings of the Month


Symphonic Works

Frederico Mompou

Extraordinary Music for Organ


Gunnar Kristinsson Moonbow

Mozart and Contemporaries


La clarinette Parisienne


Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.