One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Anu Tali – Action Passion Illusion
Erkki-Sven TÜÜR (b.1959)
Zeitraum for orchestra (1992) [12:38]
Jean SIBELIUS (1865-1957)
The Wood Nymph, op.15 (1894) [10:18]
Melodrama for narrator, two horns, piano and strings
Erkki-Sven TÜÜR
Action Passion Illusion for string orchestra (1993) [17:17]
Sergey RACHMANINOV (1873-1943)
Three Russian Songs, op.41 (1927) [12:25]
Lasse Pöysti (narrator), Tanel Joamets (piano)
State Choir Latvja
Nordic Symphony Orchestra (Lev Klychkov, leader)/Anu Tali
Recorded: Estonia Concert Hall, 19th and 21stFebruary 2003 (Action Passion Illusion), 19th and 21st April, 2003 (Zeitraum, 3 Russian Songs), 3rd September 2004 (Wood Nymph orchestra) and 28th November 2004 (Wood Nymph narrator)
WARNER CLASSICS 2564 61992-2 [53:16]


Anu Tali’s previous disc, reviewed here back in 2002, was highly impressive, featuring well-known music by Sibelius and Debussy, but also works by her Estonian compatriot Veljo Tormis.  In this latest issue, she extends her repertoire to take in the younger generation of Estonian composers, represented by the very talented Erkki-Sven Tüür, still in his mid-forties.  The orchestra is the same as previously, but the Estonian-Finnish Symphony Orchestra has now been re-named, more snappily, as the Nordic Symphony Orchestra; it remains the creature of Tali and her sister Kadri, who is the orchestra’s manager.

Tüür’s Zeitraum (“Time-Space” might be an approximate translation) occupies the first track on the disc.  After a rather predictably snarling opening (how many recent European orchestral works project this sort of generalised dystopia?), it gradually establishes a real momentum gained from the opposition of different musical ‘movements’ – big slow-moving dissonant piles, glittering tuned percussion, energetic string music strongly reminiscent of Steve Reich. As so often with contemporary music, it proceeds by a series of striking gestures, but, although the work is too short to fully work these out, there is a sense of culmination, and a feeling that the composer really has something to say.

That same rather grim persona is present in parts of Action Passion Illusion, whose three movements occupy tracks three to five. But the more economical forces – strings only rather than the very large orchestra for Zeitraum – and the three-movement structure seem to have inspired the composer to give us more variety, and to reveal more of himself in the process.  Action is, as the title would lead you to expect, a dynamic, energetic movement, which owes much to Bartók, Stravinsky and other modern masters of string writing.  It is also clearly tonal, though the key-centres are often obscured by clusters of dissonance.  The ‘fade-out’ ending is cunningly achieved.

The opening of Passion seems anything but passionate – melodic phrases slowly unwinding out of mirky depths.  But Tüür is thinking long-term, and the music builds up inexorably, again establishing definite tonal centres, which appear regularly like landmarks through a dense mist.   As the climax is reached, the tightly controlled lines explode, or disintegrate into a teeming cloud, which then softly resolves.  A wonderful movement this, and a fine use of the infinite potential for texture that exists within the medium of the string orchestra. 

Illusion is more conventional, and listeners will no doubt, like me, discern influences from a variety of sources.  But that is no bad thing, indeed it’s refreshing to find a young (ish) composer with his own distinctive voice who is yet prepared to place himself firmly within a tradition.

The Sibelius is an early oddity about which there is little to say, except that it betrays a certain haste in its composition; there are long patches in the music where, frankly, very little happens.  Lovers of the Karelia Suite will instantly recognise the authentic voice of early Sibelius in the horn-calls of the opening, however odd the piano may sound in the background!  The music of the forest, though, as the hero Björn falls under the spell of the Wood Nymph, is genuinely magical.

The Rachmaninov choral songs are a rather different matter.  Written in the 1920s in the USA, they seem to reflect the composer’s unquenchable nostalgia for his native Russia.  The lush orchestration (listen to the echoes of Debussy’s Sirène at the start of number one) and rich harmonies are in reality completely at odds with the ingenuous and unremarkable folk verses which form the text.  The choral forces are peculiar; no sopranos or tenors, basses only in the first song, altos only in the second, while in the third, these two voices sing mostly in octaves.

The producers were probably right to select Action Passion Illusion as the title of this disc; it is the most engaging and interesting work here.  As a whole, though, I couldn’t shake off a sense of slight disappointment in the choice of music that makes up the programme.  Nonetheless, the standard of the performing is high – the strings of the Nordic Symphony Orchestra are particularly impressive in their piece – though the tone of the Latvian State Choir basses and altos does leave a little to be desired, as does their slight tendency to sing under the note.

Gwyn Parry-Jones




Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat



Recordings of the Month



From Ocean’s Floor


Conner Riddle Songs

Rodzinski Sibelius

Of Innocence and Experience


Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.