One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,514 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Some items
to consider


paid for


100th birthday of Mieczyslaw Weinberg on December 8, 2019.
Renate Eggbrecht has recorded all 3 violin Sonatas

FOGHORN Classics

Mozart Brahms
Clarinet Quintets

New Releases

Naxos Classical

Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10

Nimbus Podcast

Obtain 10% discount

Special offer 50% off
15CDs £83 incl. postage

Musicweb sells the following labels

Altus 10% off
Atoll 10% off
CRD 10% off
Hallé 10% off
Lyrita 10% off
Nimbus 10% off
Nimbus Alliance
Prima voce 10% off
Red Priest 10% off
Retrospective 10% off
Saydisc 10% off
Sterling 10% off

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Seen & Heard
Editor Emeritus
   Bill Kenny
MusicWeb Webmaster
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger


Support us financially by purchasing this from

The Book of Lovers - Ottoman Classical Music of the 15th-19th centuries
Lāmekan Ensemble (Rıdvan Aydınlı (vocals, ney); Ruben Tenenbaum (violin); Muhittin Kemal Temel (kanun); Simon Leleux (bendir, daire, darbuka); Robbe Kieckens (kudunm; riqq, daire))/Tristan Driessens (oud, conductor)
Derya Türkan (kemenēe); Murat Aydemir (tanbur); Burcu Karadag (ney); Serdar Bisiren; Yusuf Tarik Günaydin
rec. Istanbul and Paris, 2014
CYPRES CYP1677 [77:18 + 76:04]

This exploration of what for many of us will be terra incognita is presented in a three-way fold out digipack. This holds two discs - more than 2½ hours of music across 37 tracks. There's an 80-page booklet, the back page of which fits into a ribbon set into the digipack. The whole is gathered under the title: The Book of Lovers. The set is complemented by scholarly notes. Tristan Driessens, who founded the Lamekan Ensemble, is the mover and shaker behind this concept which is a successor to the same group's Garden of Fidelity recording issued in 2014 by the Turkish label M&MT Records.

The first disc brings out classical singing from the heyday of the Ottoman Empire. Here the leading figures are Meraghi, Cantemir and Ufki. The notes claim "Persian resonances and … an apparent bridge towards the European Renaissance". The second disc is said to reveal Istanbul’s historical place amid the great tradition of the makam (a set of rules for composing and performing) which charted its zenith to the 19th century. The figures celebrated here are Aga, Arif Bey and Cemil Bey.

Much of this set is taken up with the solo voice which has been closely recorded in a lively acoustic. Often the voice sounds out in ululation and drumming - a mystery invoked. Instrumentals are sitar-like - harplike sounds but with very short resonance. Other tracks chart a grand and courtly cortčge - a leisurely march. Some of these pieces are densely active with a sensuous dance. Time after time there is evidence of eloquent and thoughtful placing of instruments by the Cyprčs engineers. Stereo effects and the illusion of front-to-back depth are very well executed.

The booklet essay is by Kudsi Erguner, ney grandmaster and musicologist. It is in French, English and Turkish. The words of the sung segments are printed side by side in the same three languages.

CPO and Naxos have opened the doorway to Turkish concert music from the 1910 onwards but these older Ottoman traditions have been hidden away except to specialists. This set, which reflects traditions and sounds largely uncontaminated by mainstream European concert music, is unusual. If your Western traditional tastes ache for some iconoclasm then try this luxuriously appointed set.

Rob Barnett


Abdülkadir MERAGHI (†1435); Dimitrie CANTEMIR (1673-1723); Ali UFKI (1610-1675), Numan AGA (1750-1834), Haci Arif BEY (1831-1885); Tanburī Cemil BEY (1871-1916)


CD 1
1. Hūzī Tesbih-i Arabī - Lāmekān Ensemble [2:51]
2. Uşşāk Tevşīh “Bu cān teşne visāl-i hazretine” - Lāmekān Ensemble [3:33]
3. Derviş Ali Şirügānī - Murat Aydemir [1:42]
4. Uşşāk Beste “Bahar geldi dahi seyr-i gülşen eylemedik” - Lāmekān Ensemble [6:28]
5. Acem Peşrev - Lāmekān Ensemble [4:42]
6. Acem - Nişābur Taksīm (kanun) - Muhittin Kemal Temel [2:10]
7. Nişābur Semāī “Ey şeh-i melek cefā vü cevr ile inletme beni” - Lāmekān Ensemble [2:42]
8. Nişābur Saz Semāī - Lāmekān Ensemble [5:51]
9. Nikrīz Gazel - Rıdvan Aydınlı [4:46]
10. Nikrīz Peşrev - Lāmekān Ensemble [3:19]
11. Nikrīz Taksīm ('ūd) - Tristan Driessens [1:26]
12. Nikrīz Beste “Erbāb-ı sūz eylese de hande bir zemān” - Lāmekān Ensemble [4:32]
13. Nikrīz Ağır Semāī - Lāmekān Ensemble [6:20]
14. Nikrīz - Nihavend Taksīm - Derya Türkan [2:41]
15. Nihāvend Peşrev - Lāmekān Ensemble [5:38]
16. Nihāvend-i Kebīr Kār “Güzeşt ü arzu ez hād be pāy-i bū-i tū mānā” - Lāmekān Ensemble [5:59]
17. Būselik Kārēe “Sünbülī sünbülī sünbülī siyeh” - Lāmekān Ensemble [4:54]
18. Būselik Semāī “Ey gönül aşkın sarayın yıktı bir nā-mihribān” - Lāmekān Ensemble [1:50]
19. Būselikaşīrān Semāī-i Lenk - Lāmekān Ensemble [3:44]

CD 2
20. Būselikaşīrān Semāī - Lāmekān Ensemble [2:21]
21. Şevkefzā peşrev (2 hāne) - Lāmekān Ensemble [2:58]
22. Şevkefzā şarkı “Ey serv-i gülzār-ı vefā” - Lāmekān Ensemble [4:27]
23. Ney taksīmi - Rıdvan Aydınlı [2:22]
24. Evcārā beste “Kāmet-i mevzūnu kim bir mısrā‘-i bercestedir” - various artists [4:05]
25. Evcārā saz semāī - Lāmekān Ensemble [5:44]
26. Kemenēe taksīmi - Derya Türkan [2:39]
27. Hisarbūselik beste “Kim olur zor ile maksūduna reh-yāb-ı zafer” - Lāmekā Ensemble [4:52]
28. Hisarbūselik şarkı “Yine bezm-i ‘iş-i vuslat dil-i bī-karāre düştü…” - Lāmekān Ensemble [3:58]
29. Ud taksīmi - Tristan Driessens [3:11]
30. Uşşak peşrev - Lāmekān Ensemble [7:28]
31. Uşşak şarkı “Aşkın ile bülbül gibi artmaktadır āhım” - Lāmekān Ensemble [3:31]
32. Keman taksīmi - Ruben Tenenbaum [3:18]
33. Hicazkār peşrev (2 hāne) - Lāmekān Ensemble [3:01]
34. Kürdīlihicazkār şarkı “Geēti zahm-ı tīr-i hicrin tā dil-ī nāşādıma” - Lāmekān Ensemble [5:02]
35. Kürdīlihicazkār şarkı “Ehl-i aşkın neşvegāhı kūşe-i mey-hānedir” /... - Lāmekān Ensemble [6:30]
36. Kanun taksīmi - Muhittin Kemal Temel [3:11]
37. Karcığar Köēekēeler - Lāmekān Ensemble [9:35]



Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat



Recordings of the Month


From Ocean’s Floor


Conner Riddle Songs

Rodzinski Sibelius

Of Innocence and Experience


Symphonies 1, 2, 3