Classical Editor Rob Barnett Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Stan Metzger MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
us financially by purchasing this disc from
Franz SCHUBERT(1797-1828) Four-Hand Piano Works
Deux marches caractéristiques, D886 Op.121 (968B) (1826) [15:57]
Eight Variations on a French Song in E minor, D624 Op.10 (1818) [14:01]
Fantasie in F minor, D940 Op.103 (1828) [19:56]
Allegro in A minor, D947 Op.144 Lebensstürme (1828) [16:56]
Soave-Baccolo Piano Duo: Chiara Soave, Cecilia Baccolo (piano 4 hands)
rec. 18/19 May 2012, Liceo Musicale Varese, Italy. DDD DYNAMIC CDS 734 [66:54]
Franz Schubert has left us a large library of 4-hands piano works,
but only one of them, the incomparable Fantasie in F minor,
became a “hit”. Out of the rest, each recording duo usually selects
a few that are closer to their taste. The Italian duo of Chiara Soave
and Cecilia Baccolo completed the “main course” with three other works
of relatively equal length and different character. In this they have
created a balanced and stimulating program.
Oddly, the Two Characteristic Marches are not characteristically
march-like, but are closer to happy, energetic gallops. The second
is more dancing and less straight-lined than the first; it has a few
episodes of different character and resembles Schubert’s middle-period
sonata movements. Both pieces are quite repetitive, but the performers
apparently know how to play Schubert’s “heavenly lengths” to advantage.
In their hands, the music sprints forward. The dynamics are varied,
which adds another degree of liveliness. The rubato is switched
off - there is not a single slightly uneven note in a thousand; each
stitch has the same length and slant.
The Eight Variations on a French Song are actually more march-like
than the Marches. The minor-key theme is somber and concentrated.
The first few variations are not especially Schubertian, and sometimes
sound like academic exercises – not boring but not exciting either,
with echoes of Beethoven’s German Dances. The variations
are not very adventurous, yet one should not forget that this is exactly
the composition that Schubert decided to show to Beethoven at their
unsuccessful meeting. All goes quite march-like until Variation V,
where we finally hear Schubert’s magic silver bells. Variation VI
is dramatic. Variation VII is High Schubert, Impromptu-like;
it goes from subdued to very expressive. The closing variation marches
again in a free, vigorous pace, and resembles the finales of some
of Schubert’s sonatas. The performers really do the music full justice.
They imbue the first variations with enough expressivity to make them
enjoyable listening. They bring out the magic of Variation VII, and
their finale is bright and gentle like the morning. Fantasie in F minor is for me the greatest 4-hands piano
work ever written. In a free four-part structure, episodes flow one
into another connected by the main melody of the refrain. We hear
a poignant and dramatic journey through the storms of life. This music
deserves to be stunning, and this is what it receives in this performance.
Though Soave-Baccolo do not fully match my personal favorite, Perahia-Lupu
(Sony) in suppleness of touch and wistful tenderness, they also leave
a profound musical impression, though in a different way. In their
version, this music comes from Earth, not from Heaven. It does not
sing of the Romantic blows of fate; rather it speaks of our life with
its toils and troubles. The pianists bring martial qualities to the
music; this version has more staccato and hits without soft gloves.
The piano sound is often hard and at times attains organ-like grandeur.
This is especially to ne heard in the last fugal section - dark and
colossal. Their quiet places are not too hushed, so the contrasts
of this music are reduced. Yet the tension is right, the energy is
there, the structure never “hangs”, and all inner voices are clearly
heard. The result is haunting.
The title “Lebensstürme” was coined by Schubert’s editor
Diabelli, who had occasional problems with good taste. The work is
as long as Fantasie, but less eventful, and so it seems to
be overlong. Also, following immediately after Fantasie on
the disc, it sounds shallow by comparison. Still, it is Schubert,
and it does include a lot of beautiful music. The first subject is
highly dramatic, Beethoven-style music. The soothing second subject
has a hushed cathedral air, with little bells ringing above. The duo
does not bang the loud parts, while the quiet parts possess gentle
restraint. The music has grace and beauty; yet I feel that the performance
is too staccato: it’s like suddenly getting an energetic beating instead
of that relaxing massage you had expected.
Overall, the disc leaves a coherent impression. The recording is clear
but a little remote, which reduces the directness of impact in Lebensstürme.
The piano sound is typical Steinway, a little unyielding at times.
Together with the staccato-rich manner of playing this creates a singular
sound-space, which is not the most apt for the two big works. The
performances are energetic and vigorous. Lebensstürme would
benefit from more persuasive advocacy … and this work really does
need advocacy. As for the Fantasie, it would benefit from
a softer touch in places. All that said the enduring impression left
by this disc is of something big and beautiful – the right thing to
feel after listening to a Schubert album. Oleg Ledeniov