MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2023
Approaching 60,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs
 

Presto Music CD retailer
 
Founder: Len Mullenger (1942-2025)                          Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

 

alternatively   AmazonUK  

 

Roby Lakatos and Ensemble – Klezmer Karma
Ferenc JAVORI/Roby LAKATOS (b.1965)
Klezmer Suite No.1 [3:07]
Klezmer Suite No.2 [5:37]
Jack YELLEN/Lew POLLACK
Yiddishe Mame [7:23]
Leo FULD (1912-1997)
Glick [5:22]
Roby LAKATOS (b.1965)
A-10450 [4:16]
Empty Pictures [3:29]
Dizzy Fingers [3:50]
Klezmer Csardas [4:03]
TRADITIONAL
Neshumele [4:39]
Budapest [2:38]
Ani Maamin [4:31]
YABLEKON
Papirossen Suite [5:29]
Aaron LEBEDEFF
Romania [5:10]
Yiddishe Hassene [6:41]
EREZ
Hatikvah [5:10]
Roby Lakatos and Ensemble
Franz Liszt Chamber Orchestra
Myriam Fuks (vocals); Aldo Granato (accordion)
rec. Budapest Operetta Theatre, March 2006
AVANTICLASSIC 10242 [70:58]
  		Error processing SSI file


Increasingly prolific Roby Lakatos here explores the affinities, cross-currents and musical symbioses of Gypsy and Jewish music. He joins with the singer and actress Myriam Fuks, to whom Lakatos pays fulsome tribute, and who was responsible for promoting the newly arrived violinist when he appeared in Brussels as a seventeen year old. Aldo Granato also plays a powerful part and his accordion playing exerts its own evocative spell. The Lakatos ensemble, now finely honed, naturally join them as does less predictably the Franz Liszt Chamber Orchestra and its leader János Rolla.
 
There is a deal of variety here. Lakatos plays a poignant obbligato to Fuks’s vocal on Yiddishe Mame alongside some tenser harmonic material before they edge toward an unbridled tango that suits the accordion perfectly. Tango and a certain Parisian feel warmly enclose Neshumele. And if anything demonstrates the coalescence of musics and traditions it’s the Papirossen Suite, a supposedly Jewish song but one that all the gypsies and Hungarians know as their own. They play it thus as well, a kind of bipartite arrangement with Lakatos first laying on Jewish ardour, followed by a kind of bridge passage from the chamber orchestra and then a gypsy ferment to end.
 
One of Laktos’s most impressive moments comes in his own Klezmer Suite No.2, a co-composition with Ferenc Javori and full of some burnished attaca playing. The violinist’s own Empty Pictures is a wistful oasis, quiet and limpid. The jazziest track is Hatikvah, an intriguing playground for the guitarist Attila Ronto to stretch out. And Fuks’s most vital vocal moments come in Budapest. Disappointment comes in the shape of funk guitar in Yiddishe Hassene, an aberration of some magnitude.
 
Throughout in fact I felt the chamber orchestral support merely added a tissue of refinement and not much else. And to be blunt this is not Lakatos’s most inspiring moment on disc, nor that of his band, which sounds oddly subdued. The Gypsy-Jewish nexus might have proved rather more fruitful had an arranger really got to grips with the material and produced something viably alive. Treating songs episodically, gypsy-style then Jewish-style, is not really the most creative answer. Extending things to include Tango diffuses the focus still further and veers dangerously close to Piazzolla. The funk guitar is an embarrassment. No one wants to box Lakatos into a stylistic corner but here he is only variably convincing.
 
Jonathan Woolf
 

 


Return to Index

Error processing SSI file