£16 post free World-wide   555 sonatas 9Cds mp3 files Only £22   Benjamin: Written on Skin £16

BUY NOW  Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Giuseppe VERDI (1813-1901) Rigoletto Duke of Mantua – Gino Sarri (tenor) Rigoletto – Ivan Petrov (baritone) Gilda – Orlandina Orlandini (soprano) Sparafucile – Mario Frosini (bass) Maddalena – Lidia Melani (mezzo soprano) Count Monterone – Edio Peruzzi (bass) Marullo – Giulio Mastrangelo (baritone) Giovanna – Rina Benucci (soprano) Chorus of the Teatro Communale, Florence Orchestra of the Maggio Musicale Fiorentino/Erasmo Ghiglia Recorded 1951 Plus arias sung by Ivan Petrov ROSSINI Il Barbiere di Siviglia; Largo al factotum BELLINI I Puritani; Ah! Per sempre Gaetano DONIZETTI La Favorita; Vien, Leonora Giuseppe VERDI Macbeth; Pieta, rispetto amore LEONCAVALLO I Pagliacci; Si può The Orchestra of the Maggio Fiorentino/Erasmo Ghiglia Recorded 1951 PREISER 20017 [67.36 + 67.48]

AVAILABILITY www.preiserrecords.at It’s easy to overlook the many recordings made by smaller companies in Europe in the early 1950s. One, Remington, was active especially in Austria and Italy and Preiser’s retrieval of this Rigoletto was a Remington set recorded in Florence in 1951. It didn’t have a particularly long shelf-life nor did it ever make much of an impression on the international market and the reasons are twofold; firstly the recording is subfusc and secondly the cast is uneven. That said, let’s get the demerits out of the way. As the brief note admits – Preiser provides just a cast list and track listing with a producer’s paragraph outlining the recording details – the original Remington tapes were seemingly defective. Two such tapes, in fact, threw up the same problems. The sound is very constricted and there is a raw, brazen quality to it that is especially noticeable with the desiccated violin tone. There also seems to have been some damage to the master tape on track ten (Già da tre) where there’s intermittent squawking and there’s pitch slippage on track 15 (Zitti, ziti moviamo a vendetta) and a small but unavoidable (it’s the end of Act I after all) complete break up of the sound. So it’s not an easy listen and given the vagaries of casting - only Petrov is really a headliner – this is without question an acquisition for specialists. Petrov proves characterful and strong – not over projected. Sarri is considerably less subtle, indeed one dimensional and of the women Orlandini shows flair and projection but is brittle sounding (the recording doesn’t help at all). Ghiglia has no remarkable or ear-catching insights into the score and sounds happy to pretty much follow the leads. Preiser has issued an all-Petrov disc, which is well worth acquiring, and they supplement it here with some arias from his repertoire, again Remingtons and made at the same time one assumes. His Rossini is hardly Tibbett like in its lasered centre but it is attractively done and his Macbeth is possibly the pick of the bunch of five, with the Pagliacci extract showing almost the same kind of intensity. I would urge caution here to all but inveterate Verdians. Petrov enthusiasts will want it but the recording problems are such that this is really for specialist interest only. Jonathan Woolf Gerard Hoffnung CDs Advertising on Musicweb Help us with a donation? New Releases Musicweb sells the following labels Acte Préalable Arcodiva Avie British Music Soc. CDAccord Hallé Hortus Lyrita Nimbus Northern Flowers Redcliffe Sheva Tactus Talent Toccata Classics Follow us on Twitter Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter

Return to Index

Reviews from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.