Aureole etc.

Golden Age singers

Nimbus on-line

Faure songs
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano);

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor: Rob Barnett

Franz SCHUBERT (1797-1828)

Die schöne Müllerin, D.797
Edvard GRIEG (1843-1907)

To brune øjne (Two brown eyes) op. 5/1, Jeg elsker dig (I love thee) op. 5/3, Ved Ronderne (By the Rondane Mountains) op. 33/9, Våren (Spring) op. 33/2, Udfarten (The Voyage) op. 9/4
Aksel Schiøtz (tenor), Gerald Moore (piano, Schubert), Folmer Jensen (piano, Grieg)
Recorded in London, 1st, 5th and 6th November 1945 (Schubert), location not given, 17th February 1943 (Grieg)
Original HMV recordings transferred at the Abbey Road Studios by Andrew Walter


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Other volumes: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6][7] [8] [9] [10]


I refer readers to my review of Vol. 1 of this major series for a brief biographical sketch of the Danish tenor Aksel Schiøtz. Vol. 2 immediately goes to the heart of things with one of the major recordings on which Schiøtz’s reputation stands, the 1945 Müllerin with Gerald Moore.

A recording of this cycle was begun in 1939-40, accompanied by Herman D. Koppel who, being Jewish, fled to Sweden in 1940. Due to this and to the Danish people’s understandably strong feelings against the German language in those years the project, like Schiøtz’s own international career, was put on hold. Also in 1939, Schiøtz had recorded the first and eighth songs of the cycle in London with Gerald Moore so it was entirely apt that in 1945 he was rushed onto a military aeroplane and became the first singer to sing German lieder on the BBC after the war. The chosen work was Die schöne Müllerin, which he then recorded for HMV. The 1939-40 recordings comprise half the cycle (8 songs with Koppel plus the two with Moore) and are included in Vol. 4. I hope to compare the different versions in due course.

Detailed comment is hardly necessary at this stage. This recording has always represented an ideal for a certain type of interpretation. Firstly, for the use of a fresh-sounding, light tenor (the songs are all sung in the original keys), emphasising the youthful innocence of the protagonist. Secondly, for a basically non-interventionist approach. Non-interventionist is not a synonym for unimaginative, at least not in this case; it is sufficient to hear how the singer differentiates between the several stanzas in the first song. All the strophic songs, in fact, are worth studying as examples of just what can be done to vary such pieces by vocal colouring rather than by pulling them about. The young man’s progress from green innocence to a delusion and despair with which he cannot cope are charted by vocal and verbal colouring, without any hint of the hysterical ranting which interpreters of a different kind have seen fit to apply. The brook’s final lullaby, ironically assuaging in view of the fact that the damage has now been done, is moving in the extreme (as a concession to 78 side-lengths, the fourth stanza is omitted).

Moore for his part provides the ideal backdrop. The earlier songs are pervaded by the trickling waters of the brook, followed by apparent calm as the young man ceases his journeying to take employment at the mill, rising to drama as he realises the girl’s indifference and moves on again. There has been a tendency of late to take Gerald Moore too much for granted. He laboured long and well to have the profession of piano accompanist recognised on the same level of dignity as that of piano soloist, but more recently it has become common to prefer, for instance, to Fischer-Dieskau’s records with Moore, later ones using pianists who are primarily soloists or conductors. Let us remember that Moore was a great pianist in his own right, and let us reflect what an art it takes to accompany with equal success such very different interpreters of the same music as Schiøtz and Fischer-Dieskau. And let us also remember that the professional accompanist has to be able to play all this repertoire in a wide variety of keys (I know most songs are published in at least two keys, but many singers find themselves most comfortable in another key again). Has the solo pianist ever thought how much more complicated his life would be if he had to be able to transpose all his Beethoven sonatas up and down according to the occasion?

Reservations? These are the same as I expressed over the first volume. Among many high notes which are perfectly placed, there is an occasional sense of strain. Schiøtz’s vocal chords were by now compromised by cancer and the operation which would effectively end his career was only a year off. I shall compare the 1939-40 recordings from this point of view with great interest. Also, the slight trace of a downward portamento (hear the first phrase of the brook’s lullaby) continues not to be to my taste; again, I shall be interested to see whether this habit is present in his earlier recordings, and to what extent.

The Grieg songs, recorded for the composer’s centenary, are put across with much freshness. The op. 33 songs came my way recently in Vol. 4 of Monica Groop’s survey (BIS-CD-1257). While generally admiring her singing I queried her tendency to adopt at times a note-by-note approach where a more legato line might be expected. However, I made this comment with some diffidence, wondering whether the nature of the Norwegian language imposed this manner of singing. The notes here comment: "The Vinje poems are originally in the poet’s own characterful dialect. Schiøtz sings them in Danish softer grammar." So, while noting that Schiøtz provides the legato line I missed in Groop, I still do not know whether she has some linguistic justification for what she does.

The booklet not only provides much information about Schiøtz and the recordings, it also includes the singer’s own detailed comments on how to interpret the Schubert cycle, written in 1970. If you are not troubled by a recording which is obviously not recent – but the voice reproduces well and the piano, if lacking in range, is mellow – this recording still has claims to be a first choice. Certainly, all who care about Schubert and lieder singing should have it.

Christopher Howell


Gerard Hoffnung CDs

Advertising on

Donate and get a free CD

New Releases

Naxos Classical


Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
Cameo Classics
Northern Flowers
Toccata Classics

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.