|     
            
 
               
                Support 
                    us financially by purchasing this disc from  | 
               
               
                 | 
                 | 
               
               
                 | 
                 | 
               
               
                
               
              | 
         
       
      
        Viktor ULLMANN (1898-1944) 
          Piano Sonata No.4, op.38 [20:06] 
          Piano Sonata No.5, op.45 [17:53] 
          Piano Sonata No.6, op.49 [13:47] 
          Piano sonata No.7 [24:33] (Á mes enfants Max, Jean, Felice) 
          Maria Garzón (piano) 
          rec. Wyastone Concert Hall, Monmouth, UK, October 2012. 
          HÉRITAGE HTGCD 246 [76:28] 
         
        It is extremely pleasing to note the increasing number of records being 
        released in recent years that have showcased music by that lost generation 
        of composers who perished at the hands of the Nazis; Viktor Ullmann was 
        numbered amongst them. Whilst much of what he wrote has been lost a goodly 
        amount has survived including most of the 23 works he wrote while incarcerated 
        in Terezin (Theresienstadt) the transit camp from whence he was dispatched 
        to the gas chambers in Aushwitz. Sonatas 5, 6 and 7 were all composed 
        in Terezin while the fourth was composed the year before he was sent there. 
          
        The more music by Viktor Ullmann I hear the more I am struck by a feeling 
        of loss at the thought of such a talent being extinguished. Alice Herz-Sommer, 
        a Prague-based Jewish pianist, who was also sent to Terezin, and who miraculously 
        survived the holocaust, has appeared in several documentaries about those 
        fearful times. She is the dedicatee of the fourth piano sonata and has 
        always been a champion of Ullmann’s music. The sonata’s first movement 
        is dominated by spiky rhythms reminiscent of Bartók but despite this there 
        is an overall sense of gentle playfulness that at times is quite dreamy, 
        particularly in its closing passages. The second movement also opens in 
        a similar vein before taking on a more serious note which is hardly surprising 
        given that it was composed in 1941 when good news was in extremely short 
        supply. The music becomes increasingly anxious as the movement continues. 
        It ends on a sad note. The third movement begins in classical style that 
        is almost Bachian and this element dominates throughout. The sonata finishes 
        with a flourish. 
          
        The fifth sonata Ullmann dedicated to his wife Elizabeth who died soon 
        after their arrival in the camp. It is hard to imagine the despair this 
        little family must have experienced with Ullmann trying desperately to 
        keep busy composing while looking after and consoling his four young children 
        who were with him in such appalling circumstances. There is no especial 
        feeling of sadness expressed in this sonata’s opening movement - on the 
        contrary it is quite gay in spirit. The second movement, however, is considerably 
        darker in mood and this intense emotion is fully explored though he refuses 
        to remain this way. He pulls himself up from the depths of despair with 
        a brisk and humorous Toccatina whose delightful little tune bubbles 
        along for its all too brief 47 seconds. This then leads to a Serenade 
        which mixes caprice with a tinge of sad reflection. Some moments sound 
        very like Debussy. The sonata finishes with a busy Fugato that 
        ends on an upbeat note. 
          
        Ullmann’s sixth piano sonata is an example of his exploration of jazz. 
        This was a common feature among composers at the time. It was written 
        for Edith Kraus who played it many times in the camp and who became another 
        champion of his music. She also managed to survive the horrors that befell 
        them all. It is charming and delightful and while the first movement has 
        an extremely poignant ending the overriding atmosphere is one of joy and 
        fun. Given its birthplace, this is further testimony to the huge resolve 
        Ullmann had. It enabled him to control his emotions and subjugate them 
        to serve his music. 
          
        The seventh and last of Ullmann’s piano sonatas is the longest of his 
        compositions in this genre. It is almost akin to a musical autobiography 
        in which he quotes his obvious loves in the shape of quotations and allusions 
        to such composers as Bach, Mahler, Schoenberg and Wagner. Into this mix 
        he adds echoes of Slovak hymns, Lutheran chorales and even a Hebrew folksong 
        that informs the final movement. The booklet notes correctly attribute 
        Ullmann’s dedication of this sonata to three of his children Max, Jean 
        and Felice (Pavel, born in 1940 had already died in the camp). The track 
        listings mistakenly give it as being for the 5th. Jean and 
        Felice were sent to England via Sweden on one of the kindertransports 
        and survived. Max died in Auschwitz along with his father. The sonata 
        is a wonderful tribute to life and its final movement cleverly fuses a 
        Hebrew song with strains of the Slovak National anthem, a Hussite song, 
        J. Cruger’s hymn “Now thank we all our God”, the name of B-A-C-H and even 
        an allusion to Wagner’s Tristan and Isolde in its glorious closing 
        bars. What a final declaration on life this last composition is. It so 
        eloquently illustrates Ullmann’s statement concerning his time in Terezin 
        that "By no means did we sit weeping on the banks of the waters of 
        Babylon. Our endeavour with respect to arts was commensurate with our 
        will to live." It is all the more heartrending to listen to when 
        you know the back-story. 
          
        Spanish pianist Maria Garzón dedicated the disc to Alice Herz-Sommer and 
        Edith Kraus. It also carries an in memoriam to Jeanne Mckintosh, a member 
        of the resistance tortured and murdered by the Nazis. Garzón plays all 
        four of these valuable works with obvious reverence allowing the music 
        to sing out and weave its spell. It’s a fitting tribute to a man who found, 
        even in the direst circumstances of life in Terezin, a spirit that refused 
        to be extinguished. Somehow he managed to harness the strictures of camp 
        life to his creative will. I commend this disc to any admirer of Ullmann 
        and the other composers who perished in the holocaust. 
          
        Steve Arloff 
       |