Antal Doráti’s Minneapolis recordings were notable for their
vitality,
grandeur and technical excellence. The three under review demonstrate the
point
triumphantly, even when they may seem stylistically somewhat at odds with
the
music.
The main event is Tchaikovsky’s Fifth Symphony which was recorded
over
three days in April 1952 for Mercury. Doráti takes a decisive
series
of tempo decisions pretty much throughout, and this is a fleet and tensile
reading.
Pristine’s XR work on this mono recording has given depth to the
sound
spectrum, and the ambient stereo brings the advantage of warmth.
I’ve
not had the opportunity to listen to the original LP, so can’t
comment
on the nature of the work in any useful detail, but can say that it sounds
attractive.
I do wonder, however, to what extent the brass and, say, the lower string
pizzicati
have been boosted. Those whose experience of the symphony ranges in its
earlier
recordings from Alexander Kitschin, Rodzinski, Stokowski, Mengelberg,
Koussevitzky,
Lambert, Stock and Beecham may find Doráti unyielding and
over-metrical
but I happen to find him driving and exciting and cumulatively powerful.
He also recorded Enrique Fernández Arbós’s
orchestration
of Albéniz’s Iberia a few years later, this time in
stereo.
Fortunately there’s a benchmark, which is the orchestrator himself
in
his 1928 recording of El corpus en Sevilla, Triana and El
Puerto,
made with the Madrid Symphony Orchestra [Dutton CDBP 9782]. The grandiose,
magnificently
ebullient and assertive Minneapolis performances of the complete set only
very
seldom sounds remotely Spanish. In fact for some of the time it cleaves
close
to Tchaikovsky - more like a ballet waltz in Evocación, and
in
its grandiloquence and bravura sounding strangely like a symphonic finale
in
El Corpus en Sevilla. When Doráti slows down he can make his
points
well, but he hustles Triana too much. As an example of orchestral
panache
and discipline, as well as rhythmic tenacity, this can’t be faulted.
As
an example of fidelity to idiom, it leaves a great deal to be desired. The
Interlude
and Dance from Falla’s La Vida Breve was made at the same
time
and makes for a pleasing envoi.
If the reckoning here is the Tchaikovsky, and it’s likely to be,
then
this vital and energising account makes a most exciting impact.
Jonathan Woolf
Masterwork Index: Tchaikovsky
5
Minneapolis Symphony Orchestra/Antal Doráti
