Conductors who composed or composers who conducted. The choice 
                  depends on the vagaries of history and taste. It is difficult 
                  to be both, as least when viewed from the benches of the music 
                  critic. CPO among others has carried the banner for more than 
                  a few conductor-composers, including Bruno 
                  Walter who wrote a stunning First Symphony in D, Otto 
                  Klemperer and Felix 
                  Weingartner. Guild entered the fray some years ago with 
                  a whole series of the compositions of Volkmar Andreae who for 
                  me will forever be locked into memories of the Turnabout, Candide 
                  and Vox LP labels. More recently we have seen his recordings 
                  of the Bruckner symphonies (Music 
                  & Arts) and of the Othmar Schoeck Violin Concerto (Jecklin). 
                  If that association remains true after hearing this disc it 
                  will be down to a failure in imagination.
                   
                  These four works are conducted by the composer’s grandson and 
                  funded by the Andreae family with the blessed Czeslaw Marek 
                  Foundation. They are triumphantly vibrant examples of the late-romantic 
                  movement and here appear in their first-ever commercial recordings. 
                  The spirit of adventure is well and truly alive.
                   
                  The three-movement Piano Concerto is a tempestuous Tchaikovskian 
                  foray with golden splendour flowing through its veins and arteries. 
                  This should not be missed by adherents of the Hyperion romantic 
                  piano concerto series, especially of the concerto niche also 
                  occupied by Bortkiewicz, Arensky and Scriabin. I hasten to emphasise 
                  that this work runs with the Tchaikovskian current rather than 
                  the Brahmsian one. After a dreamy middle movement the finale 
                  gallops along in optimistic vein but pulls itself together for 
                  a conventional buffeting storm with which to end. Those moody 
                  coal-black clouds gradually lighten for the Konzertstück 
                  and take us into a more Schumann-inflected style. The dying 
                  bars emphasise the irrepressibly reverberant acoustic of The 
                  Lighthouse.
                   
                  Then comes the compact Violin Concerto which opens in 
                  slowly pulsating film noir gloom. The violin enters 
                  high and slender in a finery that blends Berg and Delius. The 
                  music develops temperaments that dance and sing. All in all 
                  this is a triumph of variegated yet predominantly lambent writing. 
                  The ‘sweet tooth’ finale is reminiscent of both Saint-Saens 
                  and Korngold. A Mephisto darkness builds towards the end but 
                  soon changes tack for a cheery final wave. Encircling shadows 
                  hang over the Rhapsodie but once the music finds 
                  its feet this proves to be another exuberant feel-good effort. 
                  Again the work is in the concentrated, tunefully catchy style 
                  established by Saint-Saens in his short violin pieces such as 
                  Havanaise and Caprice Andalou.
                   
                  The agreeably detailed notes are by Robert Matthew-Walker and 
                  are no token contribution. The research shows and is put across 
                  with a light but not condescending hand.
                   
                  Well worth the investment for those who are curious about Andreae 
                  the composer and for adherents of catchily romantic concertos.
                    
                Rob Barnett
                   
                  
                    Volkmar Andreae on Guild:-
                  
                  Symphony GMCD 
                  7377
                  Songs GMCD 
                  7237
                  Piano Trios GMCD 
                  7307
                  String and Flute Quartets GMCD 
                  7328 
 
                
                   
                    Support 
                        us financially by purchasing this disc from:  | 
                  
                   
                     | 
                     | 
                  
                   
                     | 
                     |