CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]


Reviewers: Tony Augarde [Editor], Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, Don Mather, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf



BUY NOW
AmazonUK   AmazonUS

GENE KRUPA

Four Classic Albums

Avid AMSC 1134

 

 

CD1

Sing, Sing, Sing

1. Don't Be That Way

2. How High The Moon

3. Sing, Sing, Sing

4. Love For Sale

5. Booted

6. This Can't Be Love

7. Harmonica Shu Boogie

8. September Song

Gene Krupa – Drums

Eddie Shu – Trumpet, clarinet, tenor sax, alto sax, harmonica

Teddy Napoleon – Piano

Gene Krupa Quartet

9. Makin' Whoopee

10. All Of Me

11. Sleepy Lagoon

12. Little White Lies

13. Strike Up The Band

14. Bach's Blues

Gene Krupa – Drums

Eddie Shu – Alto sax, tenor sax

Bobby Scott – Piano, vocals

Milt Hinton – Bass (probably tracks 9, 10, 13, 14)

John Drew – Bass (tracks 11, 12)

Krupa Rocks

15. I Only Have Eyes For You

Gene Krupa – Drums

Gail Curtis – Clarinet

Teddy Napoleon – Piano

Mort Herbert – Bass

CD2

Krupa Rocks

1. The Gang That Sang Heart Of My Heart

2. Gone With The Wind

3. Pick Yourself Up

4. Fire Place Blues

5. But Not For Me

6. Memories Of You

7. Three Little Words

8. Avalon

9. Indiana (Back Home Again In Indiana)

Personnel as on CD1, track 15

The Jazz Rhythms Of Gene Krupa

10. Tenderly

11. Tepee

12. 'S Wonderful

13. Hippdeebip

14. Krupa's Wail

15. Strike Up The Band

16. Undecided

17. Gene's Bass Blues

Gene Krupa – Drums

Eddie Shu – Clarinet, tenor sax, alto sax

Bobby Scott - Piano (tracks 10-15)

Teddy Napoleon - Piano (tracks 16, 17)

Milt Hinton – Bass (probably tracks 10, 11)

John Drew – Bass (tracks 12-15)

Drummer Gene Krupa has often been described as a showman – a label which can be considered pejorative. But I like Krupa for his showmanship. He used it to help him bring the drums to people’s attention as a possible source of excitement and brilliance. Gene was particularly aware that the stimulating effect of the drums could be increased when they were part of a small group of three or four musicians. Hence he created the Gene Krupa Trio and Quartet, some of whose sterling work is illustrated on this double CD. The album contains four LPs from the mid-fifties.

On many tracks he is joined by Eddie Shu, a multi-instrumentalist who has seldom been given the credit for his versatile talents. His versatility may be gauged from the number of his instruments listed above, but they hardly give the full story about a man who had also learnt the guitar and violin as well as performing as a ventriloquist! His main instrument was the saxophone, but he plays the clarinet and trumpet as well in Sing, Sing, Sing and the harmonica in September Song. On tenor sax Eddie had a satisfyingly deep tone rather like Charlie Ventura, Shu’s predecessor in the Gene Krupa trio. One might expect an “entertainer” like Eddie to be a less-than-good jazzman, but he supplies some excellent solos. For example, his tenor solo on Tenderly is delicate and sensitive, with touches of Lester Young.

On the LP Krupa Rocks, Shu was replaced by clarinettist Gail Curtis, a reed player who appeared with the bands of Tommy Dorsey and Glenn Miller. He had a rather classical tone on clarinet and was a less rousing musician than Eddie Shu. This makes the LP more meditative than the other three in this compilation.

The pianist on most of these LPs is Teddy Napoleon, a gifted player who knew how to fill the gaps in these small ensembles. He can be flowery or bluesy: like Eddie Shu, a versatile musician. In The Gang That Sang Heart Of My Heart, he even sounds a bit like Erroll Garner.

The star of the show is indubitably Gene Krupa. His technique was not as advanced as (say) that of Buddy Rich or some later drummers, but he wisely chose to stick within his limitations and exhibit simple techniques which appealed directly to audiences. This was apparent in his classic performance of Sing, Sing, Sing at Benny Goodman’s famous 1938 Carnegie Hall concert. It is equally clear in the version of the same piece on this album. Lasting ten minutes, it opens with characteristic tomtoms and then the clarinet imitates Goodman. Teddy Napoleon contributes a glittering solo, and eventually we are back with the drums full-on.

Like Max Roach, Krupa’s breaks used basic patterns but were commanding in their simplicity. Several tracks in this collection include thrilling drum breaks which keep the temperature high. In some tunes Gene starts things off with forceful brushwork or hi-hat introductions which entice the listener into Krupa’s swinging, good-natured world.

Some critics have under-rated Gene but he was a driving force in Benny Goodman’s band and small groups, as well as being the leader of a very popular big band plus small groups such as we hear on this double album. With his trios and quartets, Krupa stripped things down to essentials, with a very talented reedman and pianist, plus occasionally a bassist to reinforce the beat. I think the results were marvellous.

Tony Augarde
www.augardebooks.co.uk

Error processing SSI file


Return to Index


You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: