CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]

Reviewers: Tony Augarde [Editor], Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, Don Mather, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf

AmazonUK   AmazonUS



ECM 2307 3728782



  1. Bygone

  2. Blussy

  3. Alfie

  4. Rossetti

  5. Reparate

  6. Raijin

  7. Le Saleya

  8. Kangiten

  9. Mira

  10. Eight And More


Arild Andersen - Double bass, electronics

Paulo Vinaccia - Drums

Tommy Smith - Tenor saxophone, shakuhachi


The Norwegian Arild Andersen has long been one of the finest bass players around (some of his earliest work was with Jan Garbarek's trios and quartets, from 1967 until 1973). Immensely experienced, he has played with a galaxy of American stars as well as with some of the finest European musicians. Norwegian folk music has been a significant influence on his writing. His partnership with Tommy Smith, that maestro of the Scottish jazz scene, and Paulo Vinaccia who, though Italian, has lived in Norway since 1979, is fairly recent. Their first album together was Independency in 2005. This is the third album they've made as a trio - the critically acclaimed Live at Belleville was released in 2007. The majority of the tunes here are Andersen compositions. Burt Bacharach's Alfie is the only standard on the disc.

So, what of the album? Bygone has some moody tenor from Smith, discreet drumming by Vinaccia and sonorous, articulate bass from Andersen. Blussy features a percussive beginning, taken up by Andersen who nimbly shows, in the course of the track, his mastery of his instrument. Smith plays with real passion on this one, blowing up a storm. The musicians, in their interplay, reveal the quality of their understanding of one another. Alfie has a lush performance from Tommy Smith which Ben Webster would have been glad to own: very mellow, full register, never departing radically from the melody but with a satisfying jazz inflection throughout. Arild Andersen's deep rich tone is again in evidence before Smith plays the number out in style. Rossetti is an attractive, if melancholy, piece with a smooth tenor sound gradually taking on more urgency and an extended bass solo from Andersen where his typically adroit musicianship is on show. A repetition by Smith of the theme leads into a sudden ending. There is restrained drumming from Vinaccia to savour, too. Reparate, the longest track at just over eight and a half minutes, is played in by Andersen, Smith joining in delicately (he is reminiscent of Garbarek here). There is then a gear shift, however, as the piece steadily becomes more robust and the somewhat mournful, even mysterious, theme develops. The drums are again unobtrusive but effective with Andersen allowed plenty of scope on bass.

Raijin is a short composition by Smith and Vinaccia and it is the drummer who begins the piece, joined by Tommy Smith playing with wistful fervour the shakuhachi, a Japanese bamboo end-blown flute, used, I believe, by a sect of Zen to assist in the practice of seated meditation. Le Saleya offers a meandering melody featuring a blend of tenor with bass plus admirable accompaniment from Paulo Vinaccia. Tommy Smith makes a typically supple contribution. Kangiten is an elegiac short piece from the pen of Tommy Smith with the shakuhachi, again, his instrument of choice. Mira has resonant bass throughout on an engaging theme. Vinaccia gives reliable, almost stately, support and the strength of the writing offers Smith the chance to go through his paces. This was probably my favourite track very easy on the ear and a great tune. Eight And More has a slow beginning but gathers momentum. There is some busy interaction with Paulo Vinaccia prominent. This track has a mysterious quality about it. Stevtone is a sombre but interesting listen with, in particular, high-register playing by Smith.

This is a CD featuring musicians near the top of their game. My admiration for Andersen should be apparent and Vinaccia is an accomplished drummer but Tommy Smith really makes his mark. The man seems to have absorbed the entire tradition of modern jazz and can effortlessly switch from one style to another, without losing his identity. Bravo!

James Poore


Gerard Hoffnung CDs

Advertising on

Donate and get a free CD

New Releases

Naxos Classical


Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
Cameo Classics
Northern Flowers
Toccata Classics

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Return to Index

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: