Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


Reviews from other months
ARIEL'S MUSIC. Music for clarinet and orchestra. DEAN, Brett: Ariel's Music; PISTON, Walter: Clarinet Concerto; VEALE, John: Clarinet Concerto; LUTOSLAWSKI Witold: Dance Preludes; SABIN, Nigel: An Australian Holiday.     Paul Dean (clarinet), Queensland Symphony Orchestra, Richard Mills. ABC Classics 456 678-2 [DDD] [69' 37"].

 


Crotchet




This is both an enterprising and most welcome disc.

It remains a mystery to me why the Clarinet Concerto of the British composer, John Veale, has had to wait fifty years for a commercial recording ... and, when that does eventually happen, for which we are grateful, it does not take place in Britain, but in Australia. It is such a good piece ... instantly and endearingly fresh and so totally likeable that it should have been available, and remained available, on a commercial recording since its first appearance. It is in one movement and is monothematic. It has a wonderful contrast of energy and exquisite lyricism; it is always melodic and beautifully coloured. Added to that is the fact that it is so gloriously English with its therapeutic qualities. It is nostalgic but not of the wallowing kind although I think the soloist does tend to take the last slow section slightly too slow ... the nature of the music is to display all its beauty and to demonstrate the soloist's warm and secure tone.

This and the Dance Preludes of Lutoslawski are, without doubt, the finest works on this disc. The Preludes are five delightful short pieces but they are not miniatures or trite. They are superbly written and exceptionally well played. They are a perfect model to both justify and prove a point I often make. One expects an allegro to be quick and lively throughout and yet some composers call a movement allegro and it isn't. If it begins allegro and then has expanses of slow music in it, it is not an allegro. Great and lesser composers from Shostakovitch and Sibelius to Elgar have designated music as allegro when it is predominantly slow or, at least, easy paced. Lutoslawski's three allegro movements are just the thing ... quick and lively. We don't have to always refer to Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven for real allegros. Consider the finale of Arthur Butterworth's Symphony No 1. In the noble classical tradition it is quick and lively throughout and not infuriating 'stop and start' music. By contrast, Lutoslawski's two slow preludes are full of interest and never dull.

And the soloist and the orchestra do them proud.

The Clarinet Concerto of Walter Piston seems to be the work of a tired composer. It is simply four variations and lasts just over twelve minutes, and one gets the impression that Piston could not face the prospect of writing an extended, elaborate or conventional piece. More's the pity since his Viola Concerto, written ten years earlier in 1957, is a superb work following logical constructional methods. About 87 percent of the Clarinet Concerto is slowish and rather ordinary with a final Vivo eventually injecting some life into it. It is well written, competent and pleasant but it lacks contrast in tempi and rhythmic interest.

Nigel Sabin is an Australian composer who was born in 1960. An Australian Holiday was written in a hurry, through no fault of the composer, and is resultantly brief. It fulfils its intentions well enough.

The most extensive work is by the soloist's brother, Brett Dean who was born in 1961. It is, in effect, a concerto and in two parts. The Ariel of the title refers to a seven-year-old American girl who died of the AIDS virus in 1988. Her mother, Elisabeth, who was married to the actor Paul Michael Glaser until her own death in 1994, had been given some contaminated blood during the later stages of her pregnancy. This concerto is a document of human tragedy, grief and desolation rather than, primarily, being a musical work. Because of its very nature, it is uneasy music and may need application of the mind and the understanding of the circumstances that lie behind this work. Incidentally, the second movement is called Circumstances and the first, Elegy.

Those who can fully identify with the subject matter of this substantial work will be those who value it. I can since my first girlfriend, who was Vietnamese and a superb cellist, died from contracting a virus in a swimming pool in 1967. AIDS is also a virus and I contend that it could be contracted in a swimming pool and I am sickened by medical and scientific 'experts' who tell me that no virus can be contracted in this way or lead to any fatality. I intend to publish my findings since, like Brett Dean, I bitterly lament innocent deaths caused by the failures, lifestyles and dismissive attitudes of others. Unnecessary deaths are the greatest crimes against humanity.

[ See extracts from David Wrights autobiography - LM]

The performances, recording and sound are very good. It is certainly a disc to buy.

Reviewer

David Wright

Performances

Recording

Reviewer

David Wright

Performances

Recording

Return to Index