Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb.uk.net


Reviews from other months
GASTON LEROUX: The Phantom of the Opera.    Read by Jeremy Nicholas with Peter Yapp. Music by Berlioz, Franck, Massenet and Weber. Naxos Audiobooks NA211812 159m DDD

 


Crotchet




.

This intensely tragic French novel is an ideal candidate for the spoken word treatment. As we learn to explore the mythic realms of the Paris Opera underworld, all is made clearer by the ideal choice of music that ranges from Franck's romanticism to some chillingly harrowing organ music depicting the famous monster at work playing the sinister organ. One is made to feel pity for that hideous wretch who lies in wait in those wings and who made his underworld home in such an ingenious way.

Leroux's Gothic fascination is perhaps a bit too far-fetched at times (the chandelier episode is a case in point) but there is no denying the thrill and sense of imagination that one gets from listening to such tales in the middle of the night! Jan Fielden's excellent production does not leave a stone untouched and his selection and abridgement is well nigh ideal. Obviously the real hero of this outstanding production is Jeremy Nicholas', whose reading has a certain sense of tragic mystery daubed all over it.

In particular, one must single out the 'Box 5' chapter for haunting presence and the exciting escapades in the 'Barrels of the Opera' and the ubiquitous 'Torture Chamber' scenes. Peter Yapp's woeful enunciation in the final part of the story are also a singular contribution, he makes us feel all the more woebegone by Erik's sad past and hopeless future. Highly recommended to fans of the book but also a good way of exploring this fantastic tale for the newcomer.

Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Reading:

Effects:

Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Reading:

Effects:

Return to Index