rec. live, Barbican, London, October 2013
This disc was a lovely surprise and reminded me a little
of the
LSO
Live Fauré Requiem, which took a smaller band of musicians and used
them to explore an unusual pairing of works. It worked brilliantly there,
and does so here, too.
Tchaikovsky’s evergreen Serenade sounds wonderful on this disc, with
a sense of rich, luxuriant beauty to the strings in full flow. What makes
it special, though, is the variety and care with which this sound is deployed.
The opening C major rush, for example, is refulgent and lush, but the band
then immediately pulls back and gives the subsequent statement a much less
fat, more textured sound. It is that contrast of the rich and the well observed
that marks out this reading, but never at the expense of musical attractiveness.
Listen, for example, to the sound at the beginning of the Elegy, which is
heart-stoppingly beautiful, full of tenderness, comfort and persuasive rhythms.
As for the Waltz it chugs along with just the right sense of welcoming familiarity.
The high-wire acrobatics of the finale then scamper along with relish before
the end with its recall of the opening which sets the whole thing off beautifully.
The Bartók Divertimento is also extremely well done. There is a tremendous
sense of “off we go” to the opening bars, and the rhythmic vitality
of the finale is stunning, some aspects sounding so wired as to come very
close to science fiction music. Furthermore, the whole thing is beautifully
played, treating it with sensitivity and seriousness. That’s true
in the outer movements. Even when the spidery, angular lines of the first
movement begin to creep forwards, they always do so with a sense of beauty
and fullness to the string sound. This is most triumphant in the slow movement,
however, which here comes across as one of Bartók’s most soulful,
poetic creations. The LSO strings clearly love this music, too, and they
endow their sound with a sense of fullness and wealth that makes the whole
thing a joy.
In both works, it’s difficult to know exactly what the role of Roman
Simovic was as, while he is named, he isn’t credited as either leader
or conductor, so I imagine was directing from his seat. He must have had
a guiding hand in the sound, though, and if he did then he certainly did
a very good job. He is one of the reasons why this is a disc well worth
seeking out: an unusual coupling, but a highly successful one. Superb recorded
sound helps to complete the package.
Simon Thompson