(The Creation) - oratorio for
solo voices, choir and orchestra, Hob. XXI:2 (1798) [101:17]
rec. live. 19-20 December 2013, Herkulessaal, Munich, Germany
It’s always gratifying hearing a new recording
of Haydn’s
The Creation and this new one under the eighty-four
year old Bernard Haitink was recorded live. He has selected a splendidly
blended trio of soloists: Swedish soprano Camilla Tilling, Mark Padmore,
the English tenor and German bass-baritone, Hanno Müller-Brachmann.
Haydn visited London in 1791-92 and heard a series of Handel concerts, including
Messiah at Westminster Abbey. These made a tremendous impression
on him. During his second visit to London in 1794-95 he received from Johann
Peter Salomon a draft English libretto of the story of
The Creation.
This had been adapted from parts of the
Book of Genesis and John
Milton’s
Paradise Lost. It was Gottfried van Swieten who
was largely responsible for arranging the English libretto into a German
translation:
Die Schöpfung. Haydn in his mid-sixties was nearing
the end of his life when he composed the work which he approached with religious
zeal.
The Creation had its public premiere at the Burgtheater Vienna
in March 1799. It scored a remarkable success and up to 1810 was performed
some forty times just in Vienna. Many commentators consider it Haydn’s
greatest masterpiece. Beethoven said of it that he would “
kneel
before Haydn’s grave.” Eminent musicologist David Ewen
described it marvellously: “
This is a tone poem (
more
than half a century before Liszt devised the form)
describing chaos
being resolved into order, darkness into light.” (The Complete
Book of Classical Music, pub. Robert Hale, London, 1965)
.
One of the numerous highlights of the present recording is the Orchestral
Prelude:
Die Vorstellung des Chaos (The Representation of Chaos)
so spiritedly and atmospherically played. Following on is the Chorus,
Und
der Geist Gottes (And the Spirit of God) which is sung with expertise
and commitment by the Chor des Bayerischen. Initially soft and tender, the
vocal episode ends abruptly at 1:02 with a near explosion of orchestral
power. Mark Padmore excels as Uriel in the tenor arias with chorus
Nun
schwanden vor dem heiligen Strahle (Now vanish before the holy beams)
and the celebrated
Mit Würd' und Hoheit angetan (In
native worth and honour clad) demonstrates his facility for polished expression.
Padmore couples his crystal clear diction and agreeable tone with a rare
sensitivity for the texts. Maintaining that same level of excellence is
Camilla Tilling who shines in Gabriel’s arias: the renowned
Nun
beut die Flur das frische Grün (With verdure clad the fields appear)
and
Auf starkem Fittiche schwinget sich der Adler stolz (On mighty
wings uplifted soars the eagle aloft). Although comfortable all through
her range Tilling’s bright and appealing soprano slides easily up
to the high register. Müller-Brachmann is splendidly cast in the dual
roles of Raphael and Adam. In Raphael’s arias
Rollend in schäumenden
Wellen (Rolling in foaming billows) and
Nun scheint in vollem Glanze
der Himmel (Now shines heaven in the brightest glory) Müller-Brachmann,
displays his rich, lustily sonorous tone to excellent effect. I was captivated
by the trio
In holder Anmut stehn (Most beautiful appear) where
the expressive yet respectful voices combining arrestingly with the orchestral
playing. As I expected, the highpoint of the release is Adam and Eve’s
beautiful, heart-rending love duet
Holde Gattin! Dir zur Seite
(Graceful consort! At thy side). The contrasting voices of Müller-Brachmann
and Camilla Tilling come together with sublime tenderness. One of the most
celebrated passages is the mighty
Die Himmel erzählen die Ehre
Gottes (The heavens are telling the glory of God) for soloists and
chorus. This generates a glorious full-blooded sound.
There are a number of excellent recordings of
The Creation in the
catalogues and the two that I play most often are from Herbert von Karajan
and Nikolaus Harnoncourt. In 1966-69 Herbert von Karajan made his outstanding
recording with a well chosen team of soloists: Fritz Wunderlich, Werner
Krenn, Gundula Janowitz, Christa Ludwig, Walter Berry, Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau
with the Wiener Singverein and Berliner Philharmoniker on Deutsche Grammophon.
I remain an admirer of Nikolaus Harnoncourt’s persuasive live 2003
Vienna account performed on period instruments. It offers an abundance of
precision and vitality with soloists Dorothea Röschmann, Michael Schade
and Christian Gerhaher, the Arnold Schoenberg Choir and Concentus musicus
Wien. It's on
Deutsche
Harmonia Mundi.
The present excellent live account of
The Creation with impeccable
Bavarian forces under Haitink is beautifully shaped and vividly radiates
a fitting sense of reverence. It is undoubtedly a match for the finest in
the catalogue. It has the benefit of excellent recorded sound, clear and
most satisfactorily balanced. The impressively designed booklet includes
full texts in German with English translations.
Michael Cookson