York was an important city to the Romans – Eboracum.
York Minster, the seat of the Archbishop of York and one of the largest
Gothic churches in northern Europe, boasts a long and distinguished musical
tradition going back beyond the present building to the time of St Paulinus,
one of those who brought Christianity to the north of England. A previous
disc entitled
Masters of the Music (York CD 164) contained an interesting
variety of music by Directors of Music at the Minster from the sixteenth
century John Thorne to Philip Moore. The present disc also includes much
music with York connections by Edwin Monk, George Dyson and Philip Moore,
all “Masters of the Music”, and adds the name of Richard Shephard, one-time
Headmaster of York Minster School and Chamberlain of the Minster and now
its Director of Development.
Like the majority of the music here, the works by these composers was written
for specific purposes, and, as is so often the case, those specific demands
have proved both a straitjacket and an inspiration. Dyson’s familiar setting
of the Evensong canticles exudes Edwardian confidence and vigour, especially
as performed here. Shephard’s setting, written in 2008 for an American university,
is less obviously confident but shares the same delight in word-setting
and in choral sound. The works by Philip Moore and Edwin Monk are more obviously
gebrauchsmusik for the church. All do their job admirably and sensitively
although I do not expect to listen to these tracks as often as to the larger
works.
The largest and longest work on the disc is the Widor Mass for two choirs
and two organs. This has often been recorded before but seldom has it made
as much impact as it does here. It was written in 1878 for performance at
Saint-Sulpice in Paris where Widor was organist from 1870 to 1933. The “first
choir” consists of massed unison baritones and was intended for the ordinands
of the Paris seminary adjacent to Saint-Sulpice. Right from the dramatic
opening contrasting the two organs and two choirs in the
Kyrie
to the quiet and gentle end of the
Dona nobis pacem the listener’s
interest is maintained. In a less persuasive performance and recording doubts
can arise as to whether the commonplace could be said to creep in at times,
but not here. I found it riveting from start to finish, all the more refreshing
as the demands of the service restrict its length to under fifteen minutes
– for a composer whose organ works can perhaps tend at times to outstay
their welcome this discipline was no bad thing.
The layout of the disc into music for the Eucharist, Matins and Evensong
on Epiphany Sunday is more purposeful than is the case with the more miscellaneous
collections that many Cathedral choir discs contain. Other highlights include
Richard Shephard’s ingenious if not altogether convincing Strauss arrangement
and Jonathan Dove’s fine setting of a poem by Dorothy Sayers. The Collegium
Regale
Te Deum of Howells ensures that the disc ends with music
of real quality.
Regent have added to the listener’s enjoyment by providing excellent notes
and full texts, as well as a recording whose quality immediately took me
back to those occasions when I have been fortunate enough to attend services
in York Minster. Discs by English Cathedral Choirs have been issued in apparently
increasing numbers in the last few years but few are of the quality and
imagination
of this disc.
John Sheppard
Few discs by English Cathedral Choirs are of the quality and imagination
of this one.