The recorded history
of Szymanowski's pre-eminent opera (the
other one is his Straussian shocker
Hagith - a Salome ‘look-alike’)
has not exactly been thronged with versions.
It has however done better than other
20th century ‘one-offs’ such as Enescu's
Oedip (2 versions EMI and a Roumanian
Electrecord LP set) or Bloch's Macbeth
(2 versions, both recentish, Capriccio
and Actes-Sud).
In writing this review
I have had access to the following sets:-
Roger - Andrzej Hiolski (bar)
Roxana - Hanna Rumowska (sop)
Shepherd - Kazimierz Pustelak (ten)
Teatr Wielki/Mieczyslaw Mierzejewski
Sept 1965
c/w Harnasie - extracts
Olympia OCD 303 [80:56]
Roger - Florian Skulski
(bar)
Roxana - Barbara Zagorzanka (sop)
Shepherd - Stanislaw Kowalski (ten)
Teatr Wielki/Robert Satanowski
1988
c/w none
Koch-Schwann Musica Mundi CD 314 014
K2 [80:11]
Roger - Andrzej Hiolski
(bar)
Roxana - Barbara Zagorzanka (sop)
Shepherd - Wieslaw Ochman (ten)
Polish State Philharmonic/Karol Stryja
April 1990
c/w Prince Potemkin
Naxos 8.660062-63 [83:23]
Roger - Robert Hampson
(bar)
Roxana - Elzbieta Smytka (sop)
Shepherd - Ryszard Minkiewicz (ten)
City of Birmingham Symphony Chorus and
Orchestra/Simon Rattle
July 1998
c/w Symphony No. 4
EMI Classics 7243 5 56823 2 1 [82.40
+ appendix - Roxana's aria with concert
ending: 4.50]
The AAD Mierzejewski
on Olympia was long ago deleted but
it still sounds splendidly atmospheric,
clear yet not so analytical that it
eliminates the mystery. Sadly it is
allocated only one track per Act and
is split across two CDs - the norm.
Regrettably it is coupled with Wodiczko's
mangled and much cut Harnasie. No libretto
provided.
The Koch-Schwann is
accommodated in a double-width case
and is without a coupling. It has a
good booklet with