One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

Domenico SCARLATTI (1685-1757)
Sonata K 126 in C minor; Sonata K 450 in G minor; Sonata K 108 in G minor; Sonata K 384 in C major; Sonata K 406 in C major; Sonata K 69 in F minor; Sonata K 518 in F major; Sonata K 519 in F minor; Sonata K 434 in F major; Sonata K 278 in D major; Sonata K 402 in E minor; Sonata K 403 in E major; Sonata K 202 in E major Christian Zacharias (piano)
Rec. 10/11 June 2002, Fürstliche Reitbahn Bad Arolsen. DDD
SACD Hybrid MDG 940 1162-6 [61'51]


Crotchet   AmazonUK  AmazonUS


In recent years, Christian Zacharias has become as well known a conductor as a pianist. Fortunately for us, this highly respected artist continues to apply himself to the instrument. With one or two exceptions, his extensive discography as a pianist has focused on the Austro-German repertoire: Beethoven, Schubert, Schumann and, particularly, Mozart, performances of whose solo works and concertos have earned excellent reviews. The major exception is Scarlatti. Zacharias features in a documentary film Domenico Scarlatti in Seville and recorded two volumes of sonatas for EMI before this one for his current label, MDG.

I have to confess that, in spite of all the great pianists who have recorded Scarlatti, with Horowitz leading the pack, I still generally prefer to hear the sonatas played on a harpsichord. Only the harpsichord can give full value to the crunching discords, the coruscating scales, the guitar effects, etc. Having said that, I further need to confess that I have myself played certain sonatas on the piano, not to mention in arrangements for recorder ensemble. With that admission, I had better keep any ‘authenticity’ arguments to myself and get on with discussing this CD.

And highly enjoyable it is, with Zacharias giving tasteful, clear and unexaggerated performances of a well-chosen selection of sonatas. One of the great things about not being a Scarlatti specialist is that every new CD brings fresh treasures and almost all the sonatas on this disc were new to me. K 126 is galant in style and receives an appropriately poised performance. In contrast, K 450 in the same key of C minor has the flavour of Spanish dances. K 108 is powerful, quite pianistic in fact. The serenity of K 384 contrasts with the almost Beethoven-like quirkiness of K 406.

And so it goes on, with Zacharias meeting all the diverse musical and technical challenges with equanimity. In K 518, he employs a subtle rubato, crisp articulation and well-pointed ornamentation. In the restless agitato of K 519, Mendelssohn of all people came to mind; how easy it would be to give characteristic ‘songs-without-words’ titles to these sonatas! Zacharias is adept at handling Scarlatti’s frequent abrupt changes of mood, such as in K 434 where a quiet melancholy suddenly gives way to strength and power.

When I reached the end of this CD, I had forgotten that the harpsichord existed. These are rewarding performances of deeply-felt music and, however many Scarlatti recordings you have, you could beneficially add this one to your collection.

Roger Blackburn


Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.