> Josef Suk - Asrael [RB]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Josef SUK (1874-1905)
Asrael Symphony (1905)
Orchestre Philharmonique de Montpellier Languedoc-Roussillon/Peter Schneider
rec live-Radio France, 15 Nov 1996, Opéra Berlioz-Le Corum, DDD
ACTES SUD AT34105 [59.11]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Josef Suk's Asrael, a Symphony in five movements, is not merely monumental in duration but also in emotional reach. It forms part of a tetralogy of works of which it is the first. The others are: A Summer's Tale (1907-9, idyllic but with summer lightning), Ripening (1912-17, warm and dramatic) and Epilogue (1920-29, a philosophical summation - for three soloists, chorus and orchestra). None of the other works are as lengthy as Asrael. All should be heard but the most potent charge is to be found in Asrael.

Asrael is a work borne out of tragedy - the deaths of Dvořák and of Suk’s wife. I dare to say that it would have been a work of gentler emotional potency if it had been completed before the death of his young wife. As it is, Asrael is a laceratingly tragic statement and a revolutionary Mahlerian stride away from say Brahms' Tragic Overture. It is dedicated "to the dear memory of Antonín Dvořák and to his daughter, my wife, Otilie".

There are various fine interpretations in circulation. Staunch champions for the symphony must get Talich's pioneering mono recording from 1950. You will find that on Supraphon. More accessible is Pesek's Liverpool version on Virgin and also on HMV Classics (only available from HMV shops in the UK and from the HMV UK website. Strongest of all are the Kubelik and Bĕlohlávek versions, the latter on Chandos; the former on Panton.

This disc does not upset that hierarchy although you do begin to wonder as things progress - especially in the central movements. After an overly accented, deliberate first movement, ponderous rather than portentous, things do warm up. The fantasy-weave of the third movement (and for that matter of the epilogue in the fifth movement) is luminously put across in its ghoulish moonlit blending of Delius, Strauss and Prokofiev. In the fifth movement moments of lassitude are offset by some dazzling playing. Schneider's is a live recording in front of an audience afflicted with sporadic though infrequent coughing.

The links between French orchestras and their brethren in the Czech Republic are of long standing. Fournet, Pedrotti and Baudo have all recorded extensively with the Czechs. Especially in the woodwind tone this orchestra sounds authentically Czech (i.e. similar to Talich's orchestra although Talich projects a more macabre depth than Schneider and the Montpellier orchestra). The solo violinist, who plays with sweetly imaginative restraint, is the orchestra's leader, Jacques Prat.

The presentation of this disc is handsome. There is no jewel case. Instead there is a card-fold cover with a stem for the CD and an integral six page booklet in French only.

This disc is part of an enterprising series from the Montpellier orchestra. In the event of difficulty in tracking this down you can place an order direct with Actes Sud via the orchestra's website. In the UK the label is distributed by Harmonia Mundi.

The orchestra, founded in 1979, does not sleep on anyone's conventional laurels. It has an enviable record of presenting rarities at the annual Radio France/Montpellier Festival. These have included: Verdi, Giovanna d'Arco, Magnard Bérénice, Bizet Ivan IV, Wagner Rienzi, Franchetti Christophe Colomb, Montemezzi L'Amour de Tre Rei, Schoeck Penthesilea, Bloch Macbeth, Donizetti Exiles of Siberia and Mascagni Parisina. The last three have been issued by Actes Sud. Other recordings in the series include the Koechlin Livre du Jongle cycle and a John Adams orchestral collection.

The present recording is natural with a slight tendency towards the bass end of the spectrum.

This disc does not unseat Kubelik, Bĕlohlávek or Talich but admirers of Asrael will find many fresh facets in this interpretation.

Rob Barnett

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file