> Van de Vate Peacock etc [DW]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

A Peacock southwest flew, concerto for pipa and orchestra;
Western Front;
Harp Concerto;
Choral Suite from Nemo

Vojtech Dyk (boy soprano)
Ars Brunensis Chorus
Gao Hong (pipa)
Adriana Antalova (harp)
Moravian Philharmonic Orchestra/Toshiyuki Shimada
Rec. 2000? DDD


Vienna Modern Masters


Nancy van de Vate was born in Plainfield, New Jersey but now lives in Vienna having dual Austrian and American citizenship. Her works are about 150 in number and in all genres. She studied at first at the Eastman School of Music and, among her other studies, were those in electronic music at Dartmouth College. As with the late Vivian Fine she is a feminist and founded the International League of Women Composers. She has received many awards and lectured on musical topics all over the world. She is well-known in Asia and this is obviously the impetus behind her concerto for pipa and orchestra. I have always wondered why Asians have such long-winded and inane sayings used as titles or subtitles in music. The ancient Chinese story of the title is really banal. I cannot see that the peacock is an erotic bird, either!

The pipa is a four stringed Chinese lute which has been known for some 1800 years. Its range is A a tenth below middle C to three Es above.

This concerto is interesting but not impressive. The instrument's sound is so limited and just plinks and plonks. The work is hindered by balance problems. As far as I can say the soloist is very good but 22 minutes of this uneventful music is too much for me.

Western Front is a different kettle of fish. As you may have gathered it is based on the First World War story ‘All Quiet on the Western Front’. It was premiered in Czechoslovakia in June 1998 by the artists on this CD. This is a good piece which juxtaposes the tragedy and futility of war in the trenches and the power and brutality of war itself. The orchestration is admirable.

Harp concertos are notoriously difficult to compose largely because of the limitations of the instrument and its being trammelled by its diatonic nature. You cannot write freely or chromatically for this instrument. Therefore a modern sounding harp concerto is rare. Only Ginastera has come anywhere near to writing a concerto for the harp with a contemporary sound. And that is a very fine work indeed! Van de Vate tries to be novel and uses the Phrygian mode. There are moments of impact but as with all this music I am left with the dilemma that it could have been composed by any of fifty composers. There is no original voice, no innovation.

The soloist, Adriana Antalova, deserves mention. She graduated from Bratislava Music Academy in 1993 and is now the principal harpist with the Slovak Radio Symphony Orchestra. She has made two previous recordings on this label with music by Nancy Van de Vate and a concerto by one Aaron Rabushka.

Recently two new British symphonies were broadcast and, again, one was left with this one impression that they could have been written by anyone in the last 20 years!

The Choral Suite from Nemo comes from the opera Nemo: Jensits von Vulkania based on the sequel to Jules Verne's ‘Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Sea’.

It is pleasant enough and often colourful but , again, it is not music that is arresting.

And why the expression boy soprano? Why not treble? [see footnote]

I enjoyed much of this disc but I fear it is unlikely that I will listen to it again ... or, if I do, it will be from necessity.

David Wright

[Footnote] Ms Van de Vate comments that since "treble" can mean either a male or female voice, the word is not sufficiently precise in this context. Treble is the correct expression in American English.

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file