> Tchaikovsky - Shostakovich: violin concertos [JP]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Pyotr Il’yich TCHAIKOVSKY (1840 - 1893)
Violin Concerto in D major, Op. 35 - (1878)
Dmitri SHOSTAKOVICH (1906 - 1975)
Violin Concerto No 1, in A minor, Op. 77 - (1948)
Ilya Gringolts (violin),with the Israel
Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Itzhak Perlman.
recorded in the Frederic R. Mann Auditorium, Tel Aviv, December 2001. DDD
DG 471 616-2 [72.39]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

I had high hopes for this issue, as we could do with a really good modern recording of Shostakovich’s masterpiece, falling back as I have, on David Oistrakh’s recordings either with Mravinsky / Leningrad P.O., or with the Mitropoulos / N.Y.P.O. This disc is no competition I am afraid, for two main reasons.

Firstly, both performances should be renamed "Concerto for Violin and Nose," disfigured as both performances are with sniffing, presumably from the soloist as he seeks to add feeling to the playing. Not for this listener I am afraid – why do soloists allow personal distractions like this on to disc? I found it so frustrating, that I probably will not listen to this disc ever again. And that is a pity, as the actual performances are quite, no, very good.

The second idiosyncrasy, particularly evident in the Tchaikovsky is the speeding up for loud passages, and slowing down, almost whenever the playing level is low. This is probably another example of the soloist adding expressive nuance to the playing. I find every bit as much expression in this concerto when it is played straight – the expression was written in by the composer – it is not necessary to add any more.

The sad part of the enterprise is doubly disappointing, as the DG engineers seem at last to have cracked the problems of the acoustic in the Tel Aviv venue. In the past, record companies, including DG seem to have had enormous problems trying to tame the strident sound which the Israel Philharmonic produce in their home. (Think of the various Bernstein issues from DG). This time, the sound is really quite acceptable, and Perlman’s direction of both scores is good. Such a pity that this disc is totally spoiled (for me) by the factors mentioned above.

DG’s notes are as good as you get nowadays, with descriptions of the composers, how the works were developed, the soloist and his progress to where he is at present in the musical world. The only omission is notes on the conductor and the orchestra, but I suppose that when it is the first release of a new artist, the support team will probably take a back seat.

So what about the performances excepting the comments I have made before. The Tchaikovsky (placed first on the disc gets off to a very promising start with Gringolts playing very well with not much vibrato, which I appreciate. Too often it seems that violinists who have to play with wide vibrato to maybe hide the fact that they have difficulty finding the actual note. There is absolutely no evidence of this here. The middle of the movement cadenza is played with absolute authority, and apart from the speed fluctuations, this movement progresses to its conclusion very well. The slow movement is played simply, and apart from the disfigurations goes very well. The finale breaks upon us, with both conductor, orchestra and soloist in perfect accord.

The Shostakovich concerto has a much wider span of emotions to express, given the conditions under which it was composed, with the composer living in constant fear of being removed to exile for un-Soviet activities. The kernel of this work is the central passacaglia, and this is played with restrained emotion which to me is just right. Unfortunately due to what has been covered earlier, the distractions are too great to overcome the good points. A great shame.

John Phillips

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file