> Scarlatti Keyboard Sonatas 1: Hantai[KM]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Domenico SCARLATTI (1685-1757)
Keyboard Sonatas 1

1. Sonata for keyboard in D major, K. 535 (L. 262)
2. Sonata for keyboard in A minor, K. 3 (L. 378)
3. Sonata for keyboard in A minor, K. 175 (L. 429)
4. Sonata for keyboard in A major, K. 208 (L. 238)
5. Sonata for keyboard in A minor, K. 54 (L. 241)
6. Sonata for keyboard in F minor, K. 185 (L. 173)
7. Sonata for keyboard in B flat major, K. 248 (L. S35)
8. Sonata for keyboard in B flat major, K. 249 (L. 39)
9. Sonata for keyboard in B flat major, K. 310 (L. 248)
10. Sonata for keyboard in D major, K. 299 (L. 210)
11. Sonata for keyboard in D major, K. 484 (L. 419)
12. Sonata for keyboard in E major, K. 162 (L. 21)
13. Sonata for keyboard in C major, K. 199 (L. 253)
14. Sonata for keyboard in D major, K. 145 (L. 369) (incomplete; poss spurious)
15. Sonata for keyboard in F sharp minor, K. 142 (incomplete; poss spurious)
16. Sonata for keyboard in E major, K. 531 (L. 430)
17. Sonata for keyboard in D major, K. 177 (L. 364)
18. Sonata for keyboard in D major, K. 492 (L. 14)
Pierre Hantaï, harpsichord
Rec: ? 2002, Haarlem, Netherlands.
Ambroisie MIRARE MIR 9918 [68.10]

Domenico Scarlatti, who was roughly a contemporary of Bach and Haendel, was born in Naples, and, around age 35, moved to Portugal, where he went to teach harpsichord to Princess Maria Barbara. When she married the future King of Spain in 1729, Scarlatti went with her to Spain, where he lived the rest of his life. While he may have written some of his harpsichord sonatas in Italy, it is likely that most of them were written in this later part of his life. The son of the famous composer Alessandro Scarlatti, his church music, written during the first part of his life, is largely unmemorable. But, something happened to Domenico when he left his native Italy - perhaps it was because he was no longer in the shadow of his father, but he went on to compose one of the greatest monuments of keyboard music in the world.

Scarlatti wrote 555 sonatas for harpsichord, and each of them stands out as a unique work. The term sonata here has nothing to do with the later, classical definition of a work with several movements. Scarlatti's sonatas are brief works, most just a few minutes long. They are all driven by an intense feeling of rhythm; they are all based on dance movements, as were most baroque harpsichord pieces, and Scarlatti rarely composed introspective music, slow sonatas that gave time to think. His leitmotif was energy, unrestrained verve and liveliness.

Now, I really wanted to like this disc; after all, everybody else does - from the classical press in France, where this disc was published, to listeners around the world. But I just canít. While I appreciate Pierre Hantaïís playing in other works - especially his Bach - I just cannot find much to like in his Scarlatti. First, he seems to be playing more to show off than to truly play the music. He begins with a wild, rapid sonata, which immediately gives a bad impression of his harpsichord - there is way too much reverb, and the sound is very unbalanced, with the treble being too sharp, and the bass offering little depth. This is intensified in the third work on the disc, K 175, with some very powerful chords that almost hurt the ears. This is more like listening to a performance artist than a harpsichordist.

Some of the sonatas, especially the slower ones, benefit from Hantaïís strong legato. K 208 is one of these; Hantaïís phrasing is delightful, but it sounds too much like Bach (specifically the 25th variation of the Goldberg Variations). K 310 is another sonata that is slow in tempo and liquid in melody. This works well, but the harpsichordís sound and reverb are just too annoying.

This disc is a disappointment - to me, not to the majority of critics. The poor balance and sound of the instrument and Hantaïís desire to show off more than play in the faster works are all negatives for me. His fluid way of playing the slower sonatas is delightful, however. Hantaï has been widely praised for this recording, but it just goes to show that there is no accounting for taste. Of course, one could easily skip some of the more frantic pieces when listening to this disc

Kirk McElhearn

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file