> Sibelius Symphonies 2, 7 Ormandy SBK53509 [RB]: Classical Reviews- May2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Jean SIBELIUS (1865-1957)
Symphony No. 2 [43.38]
Symphony No. 7 [22.31]
Philadelphia Orchestra/Eugene Ormandy
rec Broadwood Hotel, Philadelphia, 17 Mar 1957 (2); 1 May 1960 (7)
SONY CLASSICAL SBK 53509 [66.25]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS


Ormandy is no mean Sibelian as many of us who developed our interest in classical music discovered when his 1979 EMI LP of the Lemminkainen Legends was issued. This was, and is, perhaps the best performance on record or at least the best I have heard so far.

He tackled the Second Symphony several times. His final sally was on RCA in a surround-sound effort (circa 1975) later reissued in 'ordinary' stereo on an RCA Gold Seal LP and then on a now deleted RCA Navigator CD at bargain price. This earlier CBS (now Sony) version recorded in the year of Sibelius's death and not long after Ormandy's pilgrimage to Järvenpää, sounds frankly wonderful. String tone (one of my obsessions) is very good - generous, open, natural. His woodwind often sound very idiosyncratic - at 2.20 in the tempo andante it has harmonium overtones suggestive of the instrument for which several of the composer's domestic juvenilia were written.

This is a very good and extremely imaginative version which has more high profile spark about it than Ormandy had in his 1940s First Symphony (Biddulph). The orchestra are on great form - try little details like the ever-entwining flutes at the end of the Vivacissimo. I have never heard the flutes played with such seeming defiance of the human limitations of breath and this comes into play again at 10.35 in the allegro moderato.

Ormandy, when compared with Maazel (VPO/Decca), is regal where the Viennese partnership is extremely exciting in much the same way that Mravinsky and the Leningrad PO might have been had they recorded the Second in the same Deutsche Grammophon London sessions as those dedicated to the last three Tchaikovsky symphonies.

The Seventh Symphony is a much tauter and more intense document than the contemporaneous EMI Beecham recording. Ormandy dives into the work holding up to the light so much more drama, skirmish and chilly seduction than one often finds in approaches to this work. The symphony is very prone to soft-contoured unemphatic exegesis. That way lies the routine and the ordinary. Ormandy is having none of that. What we get is a performance that could easily have been the model, in many places, for Mravinsky's Melodiya in Moscow in 1965. The trombone is more couth of tone and the strings do not have that balsamic tight-throated desperate tone that the Leningraders have but otherwise there are surprisingly many similarities between two recordings looking at each other across the gulf of the Cold War.

Hiss - that legacy of analogue origins - is evident. Not wanting to sound too much like an enthusiast of hiss, but when heard with concentration, it is not as even-sounding as the hiss to be found on the 1964 Decca recording of the Second Symphony (VPO/Maazel). Perhaps there had been some degradation in storage or the original tape stock was of a different quality to that of the early 1960s Decca material. It is no big deal just noticeably different.

I have been hearing a lot of Sibelius recently but I will want to return to this disc again and I will do this with pleasure. I hope you will be encouraged to buy this.

Rob Barnett


Return to Index

Error processing SSI file