> Galina Ustvolskaya - Symphony No.2,3,4,5 [HC]: Classical CD Reviews- July2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Galina USTVOLSKAYA (born 1919)
Symphony No.2 "True and Eternal Bliss" (1979)a
Symphony No.3 "Jesus Messiah, Save Us" (1983)b
Symphony No.4 "Prayer" (1985/7)c
Symphony No.5 "Amen" (1989/90)d
Oleg Malov (piano)abc; Pavel Nemytov (voice)ab; Elena Popova (contralto)c; Ural Philharmonic Orchestraab; Dmitri Lissab; St Petersburg Soloistscd
Recorded: Yekaterinenburg Philharmonia, August and September 1999ab; and St Petersburg Radio House, October and November 1994cd
MEGADISC MDC 7854 [50:07]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

All but the First of Ustvolskaya’s symphonies have a religious subtitle although the composer always firmly emphasised that these works were in no way to be experienced as religious works. Moreover, Ustvolskaya chose some texts which she found in an anthology of medieval Latin literature published in Moscow in 1972. She appears to have been drawn by the writings of a Benedictine monk, Hermanus Contractus von Reichenau, who was renowned for his wide-ranging knowledge in many fields, ranging from mathematics and astronomy to pietistic poetry and music. But – as will be seen later – this has very little relevance, if any, to the actual content of the symphonies.

The Symphony No.2 "True and Eternal Bliss", completed in 1979, is scored for voice and orchestra, but the layout of the orchestral forces is quite unusual: 6 flutes, 6 oboes, 6 trumpets, trombone, tuba, piano and percussion. The vocal part, if such there really is, sets just three isolated words ("Lord", "Eternity" and "Truth") repeated in a rather bland manner at various stages in the course of the work.

The Symphony No.3 "Jesus Messiah, Save Us", completed in 1983, is also for voice and orchestra (this time, 5 oboes, trumpets, double basses, 3 tubas, trombone, piano and percussion). It sets an astonishingly banal prayer of little religious meaning.

In the Symphony No.4 "Prayer" of 1985/7, the instrumental forces are pared down to a bare minimum: contralto (should be dressed in black and must not wear any jewels, dixit the composer), trumpet, piano and percussion (i.e. a large-size wooden cube hit with a hammer). The contralto sings (or rather declaims) the same banal text already used in the preceding symphony. This short, monolithic works plays for a little over six minutes!

The last symphony, Symphony No.5 "Amen", was composed in 1990. It is scored for very limited forces again : oboe, trumpet, tuba, violin, percussion (i.e. a wooden cube) and narrator. The text (actually The Lord’s Prayer) is merely declaimed throughout the work.

These works have much in common: religious subtitles though with little religious intent; texts of little theological or philosophical relevance; unusual orchestral layout. Moreover, they all share the same ritualistic character achieved by relentless repetition of often massive sound blocks hammered-out fortissimo throughout. As Frans Lemaire rightly observes in his excellent notes, the music abounds in crescendos, but there are no decrescendos whatsoever. The music is abruptly cut short before regaining dynamic volume. The music is bleak, pessimistic from first to last, with little relief and with no final consolation. "The listeners ... will only find the plaintive sighs of terror and pain" (Frans Lemaire). Religious music, you said?

These utterly idiosyncratic works are given carefully prepared and committed readings, well recorded and well produced. Again, excellent notes by Frans Lemaire.

Ustvolskaya’s music is like nothing else; and there is no denying the almost visceral intensity of her "rituals of despair".

Hubert Culot

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file