> Mozart - Les Noces de Figaro [RJF]: Classical CD Reviews- July2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Wolfgang Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791)
Les Noces De Figaro

Figaro, Nicolas Cavalier, (bass).
Suzanne, Anne-Sophie Schmidt, (sop).
Le Comte Almaviva, Philippe Le Chevalier, (bar).
La Comtesse Almaviva, Sophie Fournier, (sop).
Chérubin, Dominique Ploteau, (tenor).
Bartholo, Christien Tréguier, (bass-bar).
Chorus, 'Ensemble Mille E Tre',
Orchestra De Chambre De L'Opéra D'État/Jerome Pillement.
Recorded live: Théâtre Impérial de Compiègne, October 1997
Le Conseil General de I'Oise, la Ville de Compiègne.
EDITIONS TFM (without number) [3CDs: 176.55]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Compiègne, to the North-East of Paris is a town of around seventy thousand people, and is the site of one of the major Bourbon Royal Palaces of France. Not of the size of Fontainebleau or Versailles, it was greatly favoured in the 'Second Empire' by Napoleon III and the Empress Eugénie who used it extensively for entertaining foreign royalty and the famous, particularly for hunting parties in the neighbouring extensive forest. In the same forest, in an evocative clearing, is located the railway carriage in which Maréchal Foch signed the Armistice of November 1918 thus ending the slaughter of the Great War.

In 1867 after extensive restoration and re-furnishing of the palace, the Emperor embarked on the building of the theatre, but due to the onset of the Franco-Prussian War, in 1870, it was never finished. In 1987 an association was formed to rehabilitate it and put on productions. Currently under the artistic direction of Pierre Jourdan, the attractiveness of the theatre, and its location, draws performances of quality, some of which have appeared on the 'Chant du Monde' label. (See review of Auber's Manon Lescaut on the site)

As is often the case in France, with a wish to relate culture closely with the people, performances are given in French and, as here, new translations are commissioned. Also, other, what some might consider rather idiosyncratic practices are adopted so as not to undermine dramatic credibility. In this case, a first for me, Cherubino (for ease I will use the Italian standard) is sung by a tenor! None of the foregoing will be gleaned from the booklet, which limits itself to a cast list, exposition of the plot and a libretto, all in French. The booklet layout of the disc contents is somewhat unusual, and would have benefited by cross-referencing of the track points. The recording is clear and well balanced in a pleasant airy acoustic, with little stage noise and the audience applause only intruding in the final bars at the end of each act'

All the singers give well-studied, vocally satisfying, performances. At first I thought the Figaro a little gruff, but by 'Se vuol ballare' he is well into his stride with a pleasant well-rounded bass tone. The Susanna is suitably spunky. The baritone of the Count, while being smooth and characterful in his own right, sounds a little wimpish compared to the Figaro. The Countess has a full toned voice, but not the clearest diction, in which most of the cast excel. Of course good diction and expression is much easier in a small theatre and when the conductor gives space for phrasing and breath. Indeed the pace here is too languorous at times and sparkle missed. That being said, the pace is never so slow as to cause the singers difficulty with legato or the chamber ensemble to lose its vitality or composure. The work is given complete with all the 'lesser' characters getting their arias. As for a tenor Cherubino - with a sweet head voice, Ploteau makes a better case in his first aria than his second, whilst in the recitatives and dialogue he sounds far too old for a pubescent adolescent. I will continue to prefer a lyric mezzo, preferably with a shapely leg in her 'trousers' role.

For any French speakers, or those like me who have visited the sights of Compiègne, this is a pleasant memento; delightful to listen to and enjoy.

Robert J Farr


Return to Index

Error processing SSI file