> Beethoven - Violin Sonata No.9 [JW]: Classical CD Reviews- July2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)
Violin Sonata No 9 Kreutzer
Piano Concerto No 3
Andante Favori
Benno Moiseiwitsch, piano
Jascha Heifetz, violin
Philharmonia Orchestra
Malcolm Sargent
Recorded 1949-50
APR 5610 [73’50]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

I had no idea that Heifetz and Moiseiwitsch recorded the Kreutzer Sonata in 1949 two years before their famous commercially released collaboration. Bryan Crimp’s notes relate that the violinist was dissatisfied with the balance in the earlier attempt and consequently the recording remained unissued. The transfer uses Moiseiwitsch’s own surviving set of test pressings. June 1949 was a busy time for Heifetz. He made a European tour during which he recorded the Elgar Concerto on the 6th June and a week later he returned to the Abbey Road studios to make the recording which APR have now unearthed.

There is some fine declamatory chording from Moiseiwitsch in the opening of the Kreutzer and some delicious and entirely characteristic Heifetz slides at 2’47 immediately following the pianist’s provocatively pliant phrasing. The balance between the instruments is good and naturally so. We can hear a side join at 3’55 (it’s marked with a little thump) and also the pianist’s expressive freedom and beauty of tone. Heifetz plays with trenchant attacks, glorious finger position changes, and the pizzicato passage works extremely well with Moiseiwitsch a strongly supportive partner – one that the violinist may, in fact, have felt too strong as he is overpowered in some of the more chordally explosive passages. At 9’20 there is more succulent expressivity from Heifetz – maybe too much – and a really impressive close to the movement, especially by the rampant pianist. In the slow movement Heifetz begins rather nervously; a starved note at 0’45. Moiseiwitsch’s variations passage with the accompanying violin figuration is propulsive and luxuriant and the now on-form violinist makes a rather naughty slide at 5’40. One can also audibly hear the effect and effort of his passagework – the microphone placement fractionally too close – with close up detail of his bowing which can sometimes sound a bit "sticky." I suspect that some of Heifetz’s objections will have concerned technical detail, of some tiny slips of his own and microphone placement, as well as the besetting sin of outsize violin personalities, the question of the recorded balance between instruments. Heifetz does sound seriously off colour around 8’12 in this movement with some approximate playing. Again though he recovers and 10’02 his quicksilver electric trill is deployed to magnetic effect. His high lying playing is memorable but it’s equally true that little smudges from 12’34 intrude and he sounds distinctly unhappy at the movement’s close – intonation is wayward. Moiseiwitsch weights the opening chords of the finale with sensitivity – no climactic playing here. There is much dynamic variety from Heifetz, sharp attacks and more delicious slides. They are both masters of delicacy and vigour in this movement, even though Heifetz’s technique proves – whatever the myth – unreliable yet again at 4’51. Moiseiwitsch’s vertical dynamics are splendidly effected with some scintillating left hand from 6’30 to the triumphant close.

In the Concerto Sargent’s accents are not as abrupt as those Boult provided for Solomon a few years earlier in their famous 1944 traversal. The phrasing here is more homogenous, with dynamics more limited and self-contained, the rise and fall of the opening less fractious and vertiginous. At 6’45 the pianist’s descending run is elegant – not galvanic – with sure architectural reserves in store. There is some truly suave phrasing from the woodwind section shaped with decisive intensity by Sargent (and here he is keenly alert to dynamics). Moiseiwitsch points the ascending run towards the conclusion of the first movement, before the cadenza, with exemplary skill. He plays the Reinecke cadenza – fearsome and combustible. The slow movement is marked by inwardness, restraint, poetic elevation and superior imagination. Sargent succeeds in bringing out some exquisite orchestral writing, some string pizzicati, and the sense of harmonic questing is implicit in the syntax of their collective playing. The strong string replies to the pianist at 5’01 are truly admirable. All very impressive. In the finale Moiseiwitsch’s skill at articulating the left hand is invincible; this is not some treble orientated performance, as many are, with interplay between hands subsumed; this is a true elucidation of the text in which both hands are equally engaged and made to sound so. There is also an often-overlooked spruce humour here not least in the orchestral contributions that make this a most commanding and enviably all-embracing performance. The Andante Favori was a favourite of Moiseiwitsch’s and first recorded by him in 1930. He was later to record it again in 1960 for Brunswick, his last session. As ever he is alive to the moods and wanderings of this delightful piece with mobile and affectionate phrasing.

Bryan Crimp notes that the surviving test pressings of the Kreutzer were in somewhat battered condition. In which case he has effected a marvel of transfer because apart from one side join and a few clicks it is a more than pleasurable experience to listen to this previously unissued performance. His notes are judicious and analytical. A very strong recommendation.

Jonathan Woolf

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file