> Ethel Smyth - Chamber Music Vols. 1, 2, 3 [WH]: Classical CD Reviews- Aug 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,928 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Ethel SMYTH (1858-1944)
Chamber Music Vols. 1 and 2

Violin Sonata in A minor, Op. 7 (1887)
String Quintet in E major, Op. 1 (1883)
Cello Sonata in A minor, Op. 5 (1887)
String Quartet in E minor (1902/12)
Renate Eggebrecht-Kupsa, violin; Friedemann Kupsa, cello; Céline Dutilly, piano; Fanny Mendelssohn Quartet; Johanna Varner, cello (Op. 1)
Recorded in 1990 at Studio 3 of the Bavarian Radio, Munich, Germany
TROUBADISC TRI-CD 03 (two discs) [54.33] [59.20]



Chamber Music and Songs Vol. 3
Four Songs for mezzo soprano and chamber ensemble (1907)
Three Songs for mezzo soprano and piano (1913)
Double Concerto in A for violin, horn and piano (1926)
Melinda Paulsen, mezzo soprano; Angela Gassenhuber, piano (songs); Renate Eggebrecht-Kupsa, violin; Franz Draxinger, horn; Céline Dutilly, piano (concerto)
Recorded in 1992 at Bauer Studios, Ludwigsburg, Germany
TROUBADISC TRO-CD 01405 [61.37]


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Dame Ethel Smyth’s father was an army officer who, perhaps predictably, did not take kindly to his daughter’s wish to be a professional musician. Her musical training took place almost totally in Germany, so it is not surprising if her music carries from time to time a certain German accent, nor, perhaps, that a largely German team decided to carry the flag for her on these recordings. Once established in the profession she seems to have suffered her fair share of prejudice, but was sufficiently forceful to be able not only to combat this but to use it to her advantage. Her own memoirs, plus published letters written to Adrian Boult and others show her to be a tireless promoter of her own works, and the short passage about her in Bernard Shore’s celebrated book The Orchestra Speaks leaves no doubt about her strength of character and single-mindedness.

The earliest work here is the String Quintet of 1883 in which the Fanny Mendelssohn Quartet is joined by cellist Johanna Varner. Two substantial movements frame three shorter ones in a structure lasting a little under half an hour. The German accent already alluded to is in evidence here, but the musical language is for the most part conventionally diatonic, with nothing of the harmonic complexity or variety of Brahms, for example, whose Piano Concerto No. 2 is more or less contemporary with this work. The first two movements are very ordinary, but the piece warms up a bit from the third movement scherzo onwards and leads to an arresting close. The finale has a second theme in that lyrical pastoral vein familiar to all lovers of modern English music, but it is the fourth, slow movement which is by far the most successful and deeply felt. The work as a whole is well crafted but not particularly individual, even allowing for the fact that the composer was only twenty-five.

The language rarely deviates from the conventional in the Cello Sonata too, but the music, at least in the first two movements, is perhaps more consistently individual than the earlier Quintet. There is a certain darkness here, which is affecting, but the problem is that the musical ideas themselves are rarely very memorable, so much so that after listening to the work for the third time I still had difficulty remembering what the first two movements were like beyond a certain yearning quality in the first movement and a somewhat sombre character in the second. The finale falls back on a rather formulaic main theme which is frankly of little interest but which suddenly comes alive in a passionately lyrical passage shortly before the end. In spite of its strengths I can hear little evidence in this music of the composer dealing with major issues, nor any feeling that the musical material has been moulded into the only formal shape possible for it.

The four movements which make up the A minor Violin Sonata amount to almost half and hour and the work was clearly an ambitious undertaking. The first movement alone lasts an imposing nine minutes and is fairly lively for most of its length but ends again in darkness, an effect which is both surprising and affecting. The scherzo which follows, at two and a half minutes, seems to end almost before it has begun. The long slow movement is a kind of Sicilienne and the finale is dramatic and excitable by turns. The work is well enough written for the two instruments, but the problem, as elsewhere, is that although the composer is successful in establishing mood and at controlling the ebb and flow of the music, the actual musical material itself is neither very individual nor very memorable.

The first two movements of the E minor Quartet were completed in 1902 and the two remaining movements ten years later. Even in 1902 there is clear evidence that the musical language has evolved beyond the rather conventional tonality of the earlier works, and this is even more in evidence in the second half of the work. The slow movement is again the most attractive, perhaps, ghostly and with an insistent rhythm to it, but there is much of interest in each of the four movements of this forty minute work. But how one longs for the music to blossom into something more lyrical, a striking turn of phrase, a tune to sing on the way home!

The single disc opens with the Four Songs of 1907. Whether they were ever intended to be performed as a group of four is unclear from the booklet notes, but the fourth of these songs to French texts certainly received its first performance after the other three and is the only one not to a poem by Henri de Régnier. The first song, Odelette, is a surprisingly dramatic setting of a poem telling of love misunderstood and gone wrong. The second, Danse, is a collection of reflections by the poet as he contemplates his loved one dancing. The music makes use of some rather obvious triple time dance rhythms with a tambourine marking the off-beats. The third, Chrysilla seems to me the most successful, a moving reflection on approaching death which manages totally to avoid lachrymose tendencies. The fourth, Ode Anacréontique, is, to my mind, an almost totally unsuccessful attempt at a drinking song, where any notion of intoxication is quite disappointingly absent. There is some idiosyncratic percussion writing in these songs, particularly for the side drum, the reasons for which are not always immediately obvious from the texts. The composer establishes atmosphere in each one of these four songs, but again, to my ears at least, melodic interest and originality is almost totally lacking.

Melinda Paulsen makes the best possible case for the Three Songs of 1913, but even her committed advocacy can’t save them. The texts pose a major problem: compared to these the Edwardian lyrics set by Elgar in his Sea Pictures (including one by his wife) are poetic masterpieces. The first of Smyth’s songs, The Clown, has the distinction of having as its text possibly the worst poem – by one Maurice Baring – I have ever read:

"O clown, silly clown, O why do you dance?

You know you can never be free.

You are tied by the leg to the strings of chance,

Yet you dance like a captive flea."

The musical response to the idea of the clown’s dance is conventionally rhythmic, melodically inert. The tragedy of the clown’s situation is revealed in the final lines: "My soul is a house of foam without reins/That dances on deathless sands" and clearly these lines inspired the composer because she repeats them endlessly. In the second song, Possession, the poet realises that giving freedom to her friend will bring greater joy than restricting her, this lesson learned after discouraging experiences with a rose and a caged linnet. Thank goodness that here the composer manages to surpass this twaddle with music of an affecting quality, but the text of the final song, On the Road, is a truly terrible piece of pseudo-political doggerel – "O to fight to the death with a hope through the strife/That the freedom we seek shall be ours" and Smyth’s admittedly forthright music does nothing to redeem it.

The Double Concerto with which the disc ends is the composer’s own transcription of a work for violin, horn and orchestra first performed in 1927 and conducted by its dedicatee "… the best friend of English music, Henry Wood." In this work, more than all the others on these three discs, we hear the essentially muscular character of Smyth’s music. There is nothing shy or retiring about the violin writing here, though the horn is much more modest and discreet, and is, by consequence, more easily hidden by the accompaniment. The slow movement creates a powerful atmosphere and the rather inflated close is preceded by a long cadenza for the two instruments. There are one or two strange noises from the horn in the cadenza which I can’t identify, but which only add to the generally mysterious atmosphere.

These three discs serve, then, as a good introduction to the composer, though of course only the chamber music is featured, and you would have to look elsewhere for examples of Smyth’s choral and operatic output. Renate Eggebrecht-Kupsa, the first violinist of the Fanny Mendelssohn Quartet, was perhaps the instigating force behind these issues as she has written an apparently learned article of some eleven pages about the composer which accompanies the two disc set, apparently, because the article is in German only. Notes on the actual works recorded are very short and confined to the inside back cover of the booklet. The single disc is accompanied by a booklet which is rather confusingly laid out and presents an uneasy mixture of German and English, but which does include the texts of the songs.

The performances are variable. The American mezzo Melinda Paulsen deserves enormous credit for her efforts in respect of the songs and with her vocal quality and intelligent singing she sometimes almost succeeds in convincing me. Friedemann Kupsa delivers an excellent performance of the Cello Sonata, and her accompanist, Céline Dutilly, brings distinction to every work in which she participates. Moments of imperfect intonation mar the contribution of the Fanny Mendelssohn Quartet, though they fare better in the rather meatier E minor Quartet than in the earlier Quintet. Renate Eggebrecht-Kupsa does not emerge unscathed from the more challenging passages of her solo works, though she is partnered in the Concerto by the excellent horn player Franz Draxinger.

The sound is very good for the most part, though there is what sounds like a clumsy edit in the slow movement of the E minor Quartet.

Many commentators have written high praise about the music of Ethel Smyth, and the musicians on these discs are certainly convinced by it. I have never found it particularly satisfying, however, and though I was also left unmoved by most of the music here I can only urge those with an interest in twentieth century English music to try these performances for themselves.

William Hedley

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.