> HANDEL Deborah 8554785-87 [PJL]: Classical Reviews- April2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

George Frideric HANDEL (1685-1759)

Deborah, Elizabeth Scholl (soprano)
Jael, Natacha Ducret (soprano)
Barak, Lawrence Zazzo (countertenor)
Sisera, Ewa Wolak (contralto)
Herald, Knut Schoch (tenor)
Abinoam, Jelle S. Draijer (baritone)
Junge Kantorei; Barokorchester Frankfurt/Joachim Carlos Martini
Recorded live May 1999 in the Kloster Eberbach, Germany
NAXOS 8.554785.87 3 CDs [162:24]


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

You may have read or heard bad reports about Deborah. But tread carefully, and be warned: if you give this modestly-priced issue a miss, you’ll be depriving yourself of some truly wonderful music, expertly executed.

Deborah was Handel’s second oratorio, a failure (Winton Dean famously but misleadingly declares) sandwiched between two successes, Esther and Athalia. Composed at a critical turning point in Handel’s career, when he had all manner of problems to contend with on the operatic front and the new genre of oratorio looked likely to be a much better prospect for him, Deborah was written (or rather put together) at an incredible pace, even by Handel’s amazing standards: the whole project (from inception to public performance) was despatched in a couple of months. I say ‘put together’ because the score relies heavily on earlier compositions: Handel lovers will have a field day tracking down three of the Chandos Anthems (most notably O praise the Lord with one consent), parts of the solo cantata Tu fedel? tu constante?, Dixit Dominus, the Brockes Passion and Music for the Royal Fireworks, not to mention ‘borrowings’ from Tolomeo, Athalia, Israel in Egypt and Belshazzar. Samuel Humphreys (who also provided texts for Esther and Athalia) was responsible for the hastily-concocted libretto, which makes a rather feeble drama out of the (skeletal, and hardly promising) story of Deborah in Chapter 5 of the Book of Judges; and he does himself no favours with his unintentionally humorous rhyming couplets.

As often as not, then, Deborah has been described (or dismissed) as a pasticcio, with little musical or dramatic integrity. But it’s nevertheless full to the brim of the grandest and most memorable Handel: the sum of its parts may be nothing to shout about, but many of its parts are fashioned from pure gold!

This Naxos team has already given us admirable versions of Athalia and Il Trionfo del Tempo e della Veritè. It’s very obviously recorded at a (single and more or less unedited?) public performance: so you’ll have to forgive a certain amount of stage and audience noise, one or two blemishes of ensemble – seldom serious, it is true – and (in Part III especially) some strained and tired-sounding voices, most especially in the chorus.

Joachim Carlos Martini is obviously a conscientious and intelligent musician. Like Robert King before him (in the only other recording currently available, on Hyperion CDA66841/2), he opts for the overture used in the 1744 revival, as only a continuo part survives of the original overture. Acknowledging that we cannot be certain of what the first performance did or did not include, he also picks and chooses items from the various editions and texts (among them Chrysander, Bernd Baselt and Robert King himself) available to him.

Without exception, the soloists sing with conviction, clarity and style. Scholl and Zazzo deserve a particular mention for their presence and conviction: Schoch is marginally less secure, and evidently less certain of his English pronunciation. The orchestra uses original or copied instruments, and seem completely at home in this music, playing as they do for the most part with polish and dexterity. Only the chorus seem in any way tested or stretched by this music, but their flair and obvious enjoyment go some way to making up for their rough edges. And it has to be said that there is some exceptionally elaborate music for them to sing here, including some complex eight-part and antiphonal material in the very best Handelian choral tradition.

The sound is bright, weighty and spacious: despite the reverberation, textures are mostly clear and words usually discernible. The CDs are extensively indexed, and the booklet includes a full text.

If you’re a Messiah lover who’s curious about Handel’s other oratorios, this might seem an odd choice for branching out: but you’ll not be disappointed if you do so. The same goes for serious collectors of Handel’s oratorios: buy this, and hear for yourself just how good Handel’s ‘failures’ are!

Peter J Lawson

See also review by Roy Brewer

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.