> Mendelssohn - The Complete Symphonies [TB]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2023
Approaching 60,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             



Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS


Felix MENDELSSOHN (1809-1847)
The Complete Symphonies
String Symphonies, Nos. 1-12 (1821-23)
Symphony No. 8 in D major (version with wind instruments) (1822)

Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra/Kurt Masur
Rec licensed from Edel Classics GmbH, Germany
Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Opus 11 (1824)
Symphony No. 4 in A major, Opus 90 'Italian' (1833)

Radio Chamber Orchestra, Hilversum/Franz Brüggen
Rec 27 November 1992, Studio MCO 1, Hilversum, The Netherlands
Symphony No. 2 in B flat major, Opus 51 'Lobgesang' (1840)

Annegeer Stumphius (soprano), Young-Hee Kim (soprano), Matthias Bleidorn (tenor)
Radio Philharmonic Chorus and Orchestra, Hilversum/Edo de Waart
Rec 8 February 2001, Musickcentrum Vredenburg Utrecht, The Netherlands
Symphony No. 3 in A minor, Opus 56 'Scottish' (1842)
Symphony No. 5 in D major, Opus 107 'Reformation' (c1840)

Radio Chamber Orchestra, Hilversum/Arnold Oestman (No. 3); Jos van Immerseel (No. 5)
Rec 5 March 1993 (No. 3), Studio MCO 1, Hilversum; 8 February 1997 (No. 5), Musickcentrum Vredenburg Utrecht
BRILLIANT CLASSICS 99761, 1-7 [7CDs: 62.15, 67.10, 59.29,54.40, 63.27, 69.44, 64.46]

This bargain-priced collection of the Mendelssohn symphonies has much to commend it. To begin with, it is inclusive of the apprentice symphonies for strings, composed when Mendelssohn was barely a teenager; and beyond that, all the performances are lively and stylish. The seven discs have individual cases, but come together in a card box.

Mendelssohn's family background was sufficiently wealthy to allow him the luxury of hearing his earliest compositions performed to a high standard, and this enabled him to develop rapidly, so much so that in his teens he wrote music - such as the Octet (1825) and the Midsummer Night's Dream Overture (1826) which remain central to the repertory to this day. This creative apprenticeship centred upon the composition of twelve symphonies (and one individual movement) for string orchestra, all of which he had completed by the age of fourteen.

The performance of these works were intended to be given within the Mendelssohn family circle, but the music is none the worse for that. There is some skilfully contrived string writing, including, for example, subtleties such as divided violas, which the boy evidently learned from Mozart. But as a child prodigy, Mendelssohn is the more remarkable phenomenon. These early pieces are stylish and full of vitality; but they hardly rank as great music. Rather they can be seen as urbane music composed with an astonishing grasp of string techniques and artistic artifice, though derived from existing models. The numbering of the later symphonies makes a clear and useful differentiation between the two standards Mendelssohn achieved.

The performances of the string symphonies are all given by the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra under Kurt Masur, and very good they are too. In fact all that needs to be done to gauge the standard is to listen to the opening of the very first of the set. The music is immensely fresh and appealing, and so too is the recorded sound. The supporting documentation, however, is relatively thin, and in the case of these early symphonies does not tell us the exact provenance of the recordings. This is a real pity because the sound is excellent and so are the performances. An added bonus is the inclusion of the revised version of Symphony No. 8, including wind instruments also, which makes for some fascinating comparisons with the original. They are both contained on the same disc.

The formal title Symphony no. 1 for full orchestra was given to the C minor symphony composed in 1824. In fact the manuscript bears the title 'Symphony no. 13', but this was altered ten years later, when the work was published. The numbered sequence of Mendelssohn's five mature symphonies makes no real sense, but has become so firmly embedded in the repertory that a chronological re-ordering will likely never happen.

In the C minor Symphony the command of string techniques and textures which had been displayed in those earlier 'string symphonies' was now extended to the full orchestra of the classical period, and the writing for woodwind is particularly successful. But above all this music shows how Mendelssohn had absorbed contemporary trends: the first movement Allegro, for instance, contains many echoes of Weber and Beethoven. The finale contains a wide range of moods contained in a skilfully contrived structure, and as such is the finest movement. Franz Brüggen's performance is well judged in matters of tempo and phrasing, and captures just the right balance between momentum and shaping of detail. The recorded sound is clear and truthful.

Brüggen is a reliable guide also in the famous Italian Symphony, No. 4. The crisp articulation of the woodwind rhythm at a spanking tempo sets the tone, and when the strings enter with the theme, the music takes flight. The sound is good but not in the demonstration class, and the string music in the slow movement does not have quite the glow that some other recordings achieve (Abbado and the LSO on DG, for instance). But this is still an interesting performance, more than acceptable technically and artistically.

If the Italian is the best known of the symphonies, No. 2, otherwise known as the Hymn of Praise, is perhaps at the opposite extreme of popularity. It is not hard to understand why, since it is a hybrid of symphony and oratorio, lasting well in excess of an hour. It was commissioned in 1840 for the celebrations surrounding the four hundredth anniversary of the invention of printing, and the first performance was given in Bach's church, St Thomas's, Leipzig.

A three-movement opening Sinfonia leads to an extended choral finale in a sequence of nine parts. Mendelssohn was aware of the precedent set by Beethoven's Ninth Symphony in having a choral finale after three instrumental movements; but here the balance is quite different, since the finale tends to dominate the work. Even though the earlier sections are not insubstantial, they form a prologue, rather than the greater proportion of the work demanding a symphonic resolution, as was the case in Beethoven's masterpiece.

The Hymn of Praise became enormously popular with Victorian choral societies, but it has only been in recent years that the music's value has once more been appreciated. After the first performance, his friend Robert Schumann praised Mendelssohn in terms which amplify the work's noble intentions: 'One must confess that in Leipzig German music blooms to such a degree that, without arrogance, it can compare with the richest and largest flower gardens of any city. What an abundance of great works of art have been produced here!'

This performance, recorded live in Utrecht with Edo de Waart conducting, is particularly well shaped and controlled. The recorded sound offers a good sense of the occasion, with depth and atmosphere, although the balancing of the three solo voices is not always entirely comfortable. However, anyone wanting to experience the work will not be disappointed, and again the presence is felt from the very first bar. For this is a fine work, fully worthy of Mendelssohn's genius, and this performance deserves to bring that to a wider currency.

The remaining disc couples the remaining two symphonies: the Scottish and the Reformation. Although the performances took place several years apart, the same orchestra features each time. The Hilversum Radio Chamber Orchestra is skilful ensemble, well equipped in each department, but in each of these symphonies Mendelssohn's romantic expression surely demands a richer string sound, more full-bodied than is found here. Since this issue is raised in each performance, it seems fair to link it with the size of the string body rather than the recordings themselves. It is not an overwhelming issue, but it is a factor.

The Scottish Symphony has a complex history. First conceived during Mendelssohn's first visit to Britain in 1829, it was left aside for many years and not completed until 1842, when it was published with a dedication to Queen Victoria. Despite the clearly programmatic associations, there is no attempt at musical narrative or description, though the composer undoubtedly strove to create atmosphere from the inspiration of time and place. The general structure is probably the most ambitious to be found in any of his symphonies, since the four movements are designed to be played continuously and ideas are inter-related between them. The instrumentation is always colourful and imaginative, thereby enhancing the music's range of mood. All these strengths are felt in this performance conducted by Arnold Oestman (best known for his excellent work in Mozart operas at Drottningholm), though the performance does tend towards the classical rather than the romantic. The broad closing gesture is somewhat under-stated, very much in keeping with this conception. This is a valid interpretation, but it is also worth hearing a more full-blooded romantic performance (such as Abbado's).

Mendelssohn's Symphony no. 5 actually came second in order of composition. It was only published in 1868, more than twenty years after his death, under its present title, Reformation Symphony. He conceived the idea of celebrating the tercentenary of the Augsburg Confession, the signing of which on 25th June 1530 defined the doctrine of the Lutheran Church, and was therefore one of the most important events of the German Reformation.

The symphony was therefore written during the winter of 1829-30, after Mendelssohn had returned to Berlin from his visit to Britain. But the religious festival, for which it had been intended, was then cancelled as a result of the political instability that swept across Europe that year. The first performance eventually took place in November 1832 in Berlin, but thereafter the work seems to have disappeared from the repertory. It has only been in recent years that its true value has been appreciated, for the music has strong symphonic credentials as well as using music with potent religious overtones. For example, the 'Dresden Aman', employed by Wagner in Parsifal, is important here, and so too Luther's chorale 'Eine feste Burg'.

Jos van Immerseel conducts a lively and dramatic performance of this marvellous symphony, and the recording communicates the sense of occasion at the live performance. Many of the issues which pertain to the Scottish Symphony resurface here, but they do not detract from the excitement or the symphonic momentum. The more poetic aspects of the work are beautifully managed, with some distinguished playing by the wind principals in particular.

Although the documentation of this set is restricted in scale, there are some interesting introductions by David Doughty. At this bargain price there can surely be no better way for the discerning collector to acquire this repertoire. Mendelssohn is one of those composers whose range is wider, whose achievement is greater, than is commonly supposed, and his cause is well served here.

The slow introduction to the opening movement is extensive and has a brooding character inspired by Mendelssohn's visit to the Holyrood chapel. The Allegro which follows maintains the mood of melancholy but brings more turbulence, while symphonic unity is ensured by the new material's derivation from the introduction. A more animated section acts as transition and a solo clarinet presents the second subject against a counterpoint, in fact the first subject, in the strings. The development is typically ingenious, and powerful too, while the transitional theme is omitted from the recapitulation, to be held back until the turbulent coda and the return of the brooding music with which the music began.

For contrast, the second movement is a lightweight scherzo of the type that only Mendelssohn could write, its semiquaver activity giving just the right point to the clarinet's dotted quaver tune. The textures here are inspired and achieve the composer's unique 'fairy music' quality. The second subject enters pianissimo but builds to an ecstatic climax, whereas the movement ends with a diminuendo of great delicacy.

The Adagio is prefaced by a short and forceful statement which makes way for a graceful string theme which is treated to various developments, although its outline always remains clear. The colourful orchestration maintains the level of interest, until a more serious idea appears. This stems from what was heard at the opening of the movement, and is given out three times in between statements of the main theme. Once more there is an effective conclusion; the theme is heard in broken phrases on the clarinet against the quiet martial rhythms of the timpani.

The finale sets out in sprightly fashion, but as well as the lively rhythms there are several fine tunes which are developed with much contrapuntal ingenuity. The design is a regular exposition and development, but then in stead of the expected recapitulation there is a lengthy and noble peroration, Allegro maestoso assai. The theme is one of Mendelssohn's most memorable inspirations, but it is not really new, since like so much else it derives from the Symphony's introduction. Therefore its majestic appearance succeeds in conveying symphonic logic as well as romantic expressiveness.

Terry Barfoot

Return to Index

Error processing SSI file