> Brahms Solo piano works Skoogh [GPJ]: Classical CD Reviews- Oct 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around

54,416 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Johannes BRAHMS (1833-1897) – Works for Solo Piano

Variations on an original theme, op.21 no.1 (1856)
Piano Pieces, op.119 (1893)
No.1- Intermezzo
No.2 – Intermezzo
No.3 – Intermezzo
No.4 - Rhapsodie

Variations on a theme by Handel, op.24 (1861)
(Waltz in Ab)

George Frederic HANDEL (1685-1759)

Suite no.1 (1733)
Francisca Skoogh, piano
Recorded June 5th-7th 2001, at Helsingborg Concert Hall, Sweden


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

It seems slightly eccentric to begin a disc entitled "Brahms: Works for Solo Piano’ with a Harpsichord Suite by Handel (albeit played on the piano). However, this is not so daft as it sounds, for the suite contains the theme on which Brahms based his great op.24 Variations of 1861, which themselves occupy tracks 10 to 13 of this CD.

Francisca Skoogh is a whole-hearted player; not for her any suspicion that Brahms’s piano music might be beyond the reach, let alone the power, of a female performer! Indeed, she sometimes becomes almost too aggressive and physical at times, though her instinct is, I feel, right; i.e. that Brahms should not be approached with that slightly bland and restrained tone some players adopt. She has a technique that allows her to deliver this hugely demanding music flawlessly, which is in itself an achievement. She also understands well the inner tensions – rhythmical and harmonic – which make this composer one of the most fascinating and, strangely, forward-looking of the 19th century. She builds the larger pieces, especially the Handel Variations, with a sure sense of their long-term structure, and characterises everything imaginatively along the way. The shorter works of op.119 – shorter perhaps but no less complex – are given equally insightful readings.

The frustrating downside here is a recording that is so close that the listener quickly becomes aware of mechanical noises from within the piano, mainly the sound of the sustaining pedal coming on and off. It’s not one of those barely audible things – this is really very distracting, and it’s just such a pity that Skoogh’s fine playing is marred in this way. I do appreciate how difficult microphone placing can be for the piano; but this is a real problem, and certainly detracted from my pleasure.

That said, there is much to admire, and I’m sure we shall hear a great deal more from this gifted young (29) Swedish pianist. The Handel Suite is placed at the beginning of the disc, and if you can accept Baroque keyboard music played on the piano (and in this context you really should, because that is how Brahms would have made its acquaintance) then you’ll find this a musically satisfying and stylish reading. The op.21 Variations on a fascinating 18-bar theme of Brahms’s own invention are given an impressive and convincing interpretation; but of course, the greatest interest in the programme lies in the huge Handel Variations of op.24. Skoogh really has the measure of this. Having presented the theme exactly as it appears in the original Handel, she shapes and paces the successive variations and groups of variations superbly. Listen to the crisp fanfares of Variation 7 (reminding me that Edmund Rubbra made a splendid job of orchestrating the work); or Variation 10 with its extreme changes of register and dynamic, looking forward to Rachmaninov’s ‘Paganini Rhapsody’; or the suave Variation 11, with its gentle counterpoint blossoming through the texture. But the real tour de force is the enormous final fugue, which grows to a pounding climax, with the theme striding in left-hand octaves.

Throughout all this, Skoogh remains in total control of the overall direction of the work, yet manages to convey strongly the shifting colours and moods of the music. This is a powerful and wholly stylish reading. By the way, when the Variations come to an end, hold your horses! There’s another unscheduled track – track 14 – which contains the lovely Waltz in Ab as a bonus.

Gwyn Parry-Jones

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.