> JS Bach - Partitas BWV 828-830 [KM]: Classical CD Reviews- Nov 2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

  Founder: Len Mullenger
Classical Editor in Chief: Rob Barnett


Crotchet   AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Johann Sebastian BACH (1685-1750)
Partitas BWV 828-830

Partita No. 4 In D Major, BWV 828
Partita No. 5 In G Major, BWV 829
Partita No. 6 In E Minor, BWV 830
Praeambulum In C Major, BWV 924
Praeambulum In F Major, BWV 927
Prealudium In D Minor, BWV 926
Praeludium In D Major, BWV 925
Praeludium In F Major, BWV 928
Praeambulum In G Minor, BWV 930
Glenn Gould, piano
Rec: July, August 1957, November, December 1962, March, April 1963, 30th Street Studio, New York City; January, February 1980, Eaton’s Auditorium, Toronto, Canada.
SONY SMK87768 [60.34]

This second disc of partitas, containing the fourth, fifth and sixth partitas, also includes a selection from the nine Little Preludes from the Wilhelm Friedemann Bach Buchlein. Gould’s recordings of these works cover a vast period of time; the partitas were begun in 1957, and other tracks were recorded in 1962 and 1963. Some of the tracks are in mono (the 5th and 6th partitas, with the exception of their first and last movements) giving a slightly unbalanced sound overall.

The fourth partita is probably the most balanced work, having been recorded over a shorter period of time, between November 1962 and April 1963. Gould shows here his great sensitivity to Bach’s music, especially in the magnificent allemande, which Gould turns into an anthem of beauty. His legato-less approach fits so perfectly with the tone of this movement; his muted lyricism is so appropriate. And when he goes on to the following courante, one familiar with Gould’s often hyper-fast tempi is almost surprised that he treats this movement as if it were a sister of the allemande, with a gentle, round touch. The sarabande of this work features some of Gould’s lightest touch; again, lyricism wins out over energy, and he constructs this movement like a subtle poem. It is quite refreshing to hear such a delicate performance of this fine partita from Glenn Gould - this is one of the finest recordings of this work for piano.

There is a noticeable difference between the first movement of the 5th partita and the following movements - not only are the first and last movements in stereo, and the others in mono, but the piano is a few hertz off. This difference is apparent when listening to the end of the first movement and the beginning of the second, for example, but, in spite of the dampened sound of the mono tracks, it is not a big problem. Gould here adopts a much more rapid tempo than for the 4th partita, yet makes it sound almost like no other tempo would be appropriate. His breakneck rendition of the corrante is surprising, yet fits the music. He slows down a bit for the sarabande, yet this, too, sounds correct. Note that Gould does not play the repeats for this partita, making it very short overall - it is less than 10 minutes long. (Most pianists play this work in about 20 minutes.) When the final gigue begins, the listener is jarred by the return to stereo sound, which opens this music again to its true depth. Alas, if only Gould had recorded the entire work in stereo…

The sixth partita, like the fifth, has its outer movements recorded in stereo, while the others are in mono. Gould takes an approach here that is similar to the fourth partita; he is gentle, round, poetic and subtle. The opening toccata, at almost 10 minutes, is one of the longest recordings by a pianist; in fact, of the dozen recordings in my possession, on piano, harpsichord or clavichord, it is indeed the longest. Gould approaches this movement as though it were a separate work, treating each of its sections with a different touch. He begins at a medium-fast tempo, then slows down in the second section, playing it like an allemande or sarabande. The difference in tuning of the pianos between the first and second movements is more noticeable here; there also seem to be some points in this partita where the tape slurs a bit. Again, the mono recordings lack depth, but not musicality.

This disc ends with six Little Preludes, which, far from being filler, show that an artist like Glenn Gould can take what are banal works written for Bach’s son Wilhelm Friedemann, and turn them into tiny musical gems.

This is one of the essential Gould recordings of Bach. His readings of the partitas are some of the finest recordings he made, and the 4th partita and the toccata of the 6th partita stand as monuments to his mastery of this music.

Kirk McElhearn

Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.