> HOLMBOE Piano Works Blyme [RB]: Classical Reviews- May2002 MusicWeb(UK)

MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Vagn HOLMBOE (1909-1996)
Piano works

Suono da Bardo - symphonic suite (1949)
Sonatina Briosa (1941)
Suite (1931)
Small Piano Pieces (1930-32)
Rumaesk Suite (1937)
Anker Blyme (piano)
rec 2-3 Sept 1998, Birkerod


AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Holmboe's musical output was prodigious. As time passes I am getting a better perspective on it.

The symphonies, concertos and string quartets, all of which have been recorded, are central and many are essential. Amongst these works, even now, we recognise pieces that have a real prospect of a concert life. Others may have to wait in the same way that Bach had to wait for Mendelssohn. Of the works with durability and resilience, the core symphonies (4 to 8) stand at the apex.

In his typically helpful notes for this CD Mogens Wenzel Andreasen leads us gently through the facts and opinions. He makes the point that Holmboe was not greatly active as a composer for solo piano. Of those works that were written many were for the Romanian born pianist Meta Graf, who, in 1933, he was to marry. Graf and Holmboe trekked the Rumanian countryside collecting folksongs during the 1930s.

The wartime Briosa is still in manuscript as is so much of Holmboe's piano music. Its first movement clangs along in malignant spirit like the dance of an iron witch - a surprise for the first movement of a so-called happy sonata. The final movement is similarly remorseless. These flank an uncomplicated 'raindrop' Allegretto placido. The four movement Suite is from Christmas 1931 and is dedicated to the composer's wife to be. The work has a spring morning simplicity (akin to the carefree piano works of John Ireland) but viewed through a charcoal stained distorting mirror. The Small Piano Pieces (7) are brief splinters of inspiration - a sort of Nordic Mikrokosmos with hints of Haydn and Beethoven along the way. Some are clearly inspired by naïve ideas and childlike innocence. Others have a broader range of feeling such as the Bach-like Andante. The Rumanian Suite is a legacy of the young couple's tramp through Rumania. The gypsy fiddle, the rustic hurdy-gurdy and the crystal 'steps' of the cimbalom are all there. The characteristic curve and sinuous twist of Balkan folk music is everywhere. The work would be difficult to identify as Holnboe's - at least at surface level and would make an excellent 'innocent ear' test.

Finally we come to the five movement Suono da Bardo. This is the major work on this disc both in mien and in duration. Running to almost 35 minutes it takes up more than half the playing time. The Sound of the Bard evokes the dark woodlands and caves of the psyche. You might well suspect that the crystalline treble work of the right-hand is suggestive of the same bardic harp that haunts Sibelius's own Bard - his bleakest tone poem closer to the spareness of Luonnotar and the Fourth Symphony than to any of his other works. However Sibelius's Bard is warm by comparison with the Holmboe. The Suono da Bardo is dissonant without confusion; vinegary but not exactly sour either. Lucidity in expression is valued by Holmboe. The music certainly has linkages with Bartók but also present are unknowing glances towards works Holmboe could not have known such as the sonatas of Elie Siegmeister and Frank Bridge. We should note the oxymoronic sub-title - one which was used by Nielsen in his piano works (also recorded on Danacord by Mina Miller). The work is coherent, emotionally speaking, (do not expect anything carefree). It develops its journey by the same process of transformation favoured by Liszt and also by Holmboe's great contemporary Niels Viggo Bentzon. The closing pages lead you out from darkness into light.

Excellent performances by veteran pianist Anker Blyme and recording quality to match.

Rob Barnett



Return to Index

Error processing SSI file