> Johannes Brahms - Piano Concerto No.2 [JW]: Classical CD Reviews- June2002 MusicWeb(UK)

One of the most grown-up review sites around
One of the most grown-up review sites around

Search MusicWeb Here


International mailing

Up to 40% off

  Founder: Len Mullenger

MusicWeb is now part of See what else is on offer

Johannes BRAHMS (1833-1897)
Piano Concerto No 2
Paganini Variations Op 35
Julius Katchen, piano
London Symphony Orchestra
Janos Ferencsik
Recorded 1960 (Concerto), 1965 (Paganini Variations)
DECCA ELOQUENCE 458 171-2 [67.06]



Katchen’s death from cancer at forty-three robbed the world of a musician whose talent had yet fully to develop. It’s salutary to realise that had he lived he would now be only seventy-five. Though he recorded widely – Rorem and Britten as well as Mussoursgky - it was in Brahms that he established something of a hegemony. He was especially convincing in early Brahms but his traversals of the violin Sonatas with Josef Suk and the trios with Suk and Starker were profoundly distinguished and are still amongst the most recommendable of versions. Silent now since his death in 1969 his Brahms has been reissued variously over the years – often coupled in more or less helpful compilations. In this new Decca Eloquence reissue the Second Concerto is joined with the Paganini Variations – a late concerto and a youthful virtuosic set.

He recorded the concerto with Pierre Monteux as well as this 1960 performance with Ferencsik in which distinctive qualities co exist with more troubling features. The 40 year old still sounds well, rich and deep, but there is a little rawness sometimes which unduly spotlights orchestral soloists. In the first movement Katchen indulges in some asymmetrical accents here and there and can sound a little mannered. The blare of the first trumpet is a distinctive feature of the movement as is the better-blended woodwind choir and Katchen’s pressured tone. I felt a slight over nonchalance on his part in some of the filigree runs and a sense of becalmed stasis at 12’30, which struck me as too indulged. The fractious angularity of the second movement is well conveyed, with strong left hand accents but maybe the beautifully melting melody at 5’10 is too casually played. It sounds to me as if Katchen’s mobile left hand is subverting, at a quick tempo, his right hand’s lyrical impulse. I admire his desire not to wallow but would have welcomed a more flexible rubato the better to fully bring out this passage.

In the Andante Kenneth Heath’s leanly focused cello solo prefaces the piano’s entry and it’s difficult for the soloist not to sound lumpy and gauche, one I feel Katchen never wholly overcomes. Ferencsik meanwhile upholds a really lyrical impulse here, encouraging affectionate phrasing from the strings, moulding the bass pizzicatos with finesse. I found the finale, however, problematic. Together with his soloist neither conductor nor Katchen get quite the right rhythm. There is instead a rather overdone quality to the music making with accents and ritardandos rather too predictably imposed. Perhaps I am alone in finding it all just a bit fey, too lacking in genuine impulse. There’s much that is attractive here though. Katchen plays with reserves of tone and technique and Ferencsik is a conductor of involvement but the air of calculation remains troubling.

The two books of the Paganini Variations are another matter. There is some colossally brilliant playing here; the Variations in sixths in Book One is a tour de force, done with virtuosity and panache. He is, however, uniformly fast and sometimes a little bellicose and this is not the kind of interior Brahms playing one might want. That not even Katchen could knock off Book One untroubled can be heard in the very bad edit at 10’57. Interestingly another lumpy edit at 1’54 in Book Two occurs during the slow waltz like introduction – every bit as tricky as the more obviously virtuosic passages – but he is here in general thoroughly and commandingly on form.

Something of a mixed bag, then, with a slightly disappointing Concerto yoked to the youthfully infectious Variations.

Jonathan Woolf



Return to Index

Untitled Document

Reviews from previous months
Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the discs reviewed. details
We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to which you refer.